creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Lenore Skenazy
Lenore Skenazy
4 Feb 2010
The Extracurricular Activity Kids Need To Succeed

You know what's weird? Parents. Most of us are just trying to do the best we can — which often … Read More.

28 Jan 2010
Pregnant Moms Don't Have To Be Perfect

This is a note to the pregnancy police, the folks who see a pregnant lady at Starbucks and scowl as if she … Read More.

21 Jan 2010
Obama, Haiti and Lard

Can't stomach any more Haiti broadcasts? Maybe you don't have to. If you watched Katrina unfold or the … Read More.

End of the Supermom Era

"This car climbed Mt. Washington," says the usual bumper sticker.

"This car wants to jump OFF Mt. Washington." That's the bumper sticker Patty Konjoian came up with as she and her sister were penning their book and Web site, "Shut Up About … Your Perfect Kid!" While their work was inspired by their particular children's challenges — one has Asperger's syndrome, one has bipolar disorder — they've been surprised by the response they're getting.

"What we didn't realize was that a lot of people with 'average' kids would say, 'You know, I can relate to this because my kid is not a Rhodes scholar,'" says Konjoian.

The truth hit them like a ton of underachievers: Most of us are sick of perfect kids, perfect parents and, worst of all, those paragons of perfection — supermoms (if anyone could ever stand them in the first place. Wasn't unspoken anti-perfectionism really what sent Martha Stewart to the slammer?) In any event, we are in the midst of a big Anti-Perfect Mothering Moment.

On behalf of all the normal-to-slacker moms out there, I'd like to request TV, movies, magazines and advertisers to please stop showing us happy moms with every hair — and kid — in place. And if you really want to make us love you, throw in a crumpled-up Burger King wrapper.

Former Letterman writer Jill Besnoy is part of the anti-perfection wave. She created the Web site honestbaby.com, where you can buy tiny T-shirts that say, "Not sleeping through the night," and, "I survived nipple confusion" — a retort to all the breastfeeding-only zealots who think giving the kid a bottle now and then is pretty much on par with infanticide. Take that!

Konjoian and her sister have labeled this "The Movement of Imperfection," and you can find plenty of books on the shelves proffering the same message, including "Good-Enough Mother" and "Mommy Guilt: Learn To Worry Less, Focus on What Matters Most, and Raise Happier Kids." (For dads, there's "Daddy Needs a Drink.")

The cover of a recent Hallmark Magazine trumpeted the story "Letting Go of Perfect" by Karen Houppert, who confessed to living in a rundown house with no time or, frankly, oomph to spruce it up.

All she was looking for was the courage to tackle the chaos, "and the wisdom to accept the bathroom tiles I cannot change."

To find these, she went to a lifestyle guru — the new kind, who teach acceptance and meditation rather than competition and makeovers — and there she had a revelation: Just as she never judged people by the neatness of their homes, why would anyone normal judge her? It's a realization more and more people are coming to.

"I think years ago, there was much more of a sense among young mothers that there was a need to do everything and be perfect," says the magazine's editor, Lisa Benenson. As the former editor of Working Woman, she remembers when women first entered the workplace; they felt they had to give 110 percent on all fronts. "Personally, for me, I spent years hand-making my children's Halloween costumes until they got old enough to say, 'You know, we'd prefer the store-bought ones,'" she says.

As do my kids. And many more. They like instant ramen more than homemade chicken soup, too.

So don't feel bad if you're not a supermom, or not being raised by one, or not married to one. But do feel free to enjoy some moments of tortured self-doubt if you are one.

Then you'll be just like the rest of us.

Lenore Skenazy is a columnist at The New York Sun and Advertising Age. To find out more about Lenore Skenazy (lskenazy@yahoo.com) and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2007 CREATORS SYNDICATE INC.



Comments

6 Comments | Post Comment

Re: maggie My daughter is 7. I thought working my bottom off would allow me to be a better mom so I could "buy" her stuff... and there we both are, laying side by side in bed, and I just look at her and say, I'm sorry, I thought if I worked more then I could buy you more stuff & be a better mommy.... She looked at me brillantly and said, gently rubbing my check... but you're perfect just the way you are :) I agree with letting kids go free. It's unnatural to sick at home and kids reach an age where they, themselves, need to be able to invite friends over, go back and forth without a lot of parent hoovering. I think my biggest disappointment parenting is that - a large part (not all) of parenting has been distorted by fooling myself into thinking & selling out to this crap of staying in with my kids all the time (and a lot of us our doing it) would make me a better mom. Wrong! It's depressing and paralyzing for all of us. Adult proofing our children is a lot smarter then this capitalism of "child proofing".

Comment: #1
Posted by: marilyn
Mon Sep 29, 2008 3:36 PM

Women just need to accept that every family and every mommy is different. Some have boundless energy and some need a village to help out. I work because I want to, and am very happy with what my daughter gets out of daycare/preschool. She seems happy too. I am not the nurturing or patient type so staying home 24 x 7 would not work out. I feel I am a better mom because I get the time away from her. Its about quality of time when you are together. As I write this it is almost 1pm on a Sunday, my daughter is finishing her lunch while still in her pajamas and is watching educational TV. All is fine as far as I am concerned.

Comment: #2
Posted by: Lisa
Sun Jan 3, 2010 10:57 AM

It continues to baffle and depress me that women are still figuring this stuff out. Men wouldn't dream of suffering guilt and self-doubt about something as trivial as a messy car, house, hair do. I'm a feminist, mom, and full-time business owner. My kids and friends spend no energy whatsoever judging me...nor do I them. Life is short. Friends are good to you. Embrace the chaos. It will be gone in short order and replaced with the silence of the empty nest. When you ask any American kid who is happy and healthy "What do you love about your Mom?" I promise you it is NOT that you keep your house clean or comb your hair. They love us for the time and attention we give THEM, not time we give to the PTA, the cooking, the cleaning, etc. Banish guilt forever and hug your kid!!!

Comment: #3
Posted by: maggie
Sun Jun 29, 2008 7:18 PM

I was just telling my friend yesterday that I have never once judged another person by the cleanliness of her home or her children. Why do I judge myself so harshly?

Comment: #4
Posted by: Sandy
Thu Sep 17, 2009 7:07 PM

THANK YOU ! Our society's demand for perfection is (I feel) the leading cause of DIVORCE in this country. I let my 9 year old son walk 5 blocks to school, in a residential area, in a small community where I know a large majority of my neighbours and I am labeled a "bad mom". I sit on the PTA, I make home made lunches and raise three children as a single parent (self employed).... the continued unrealistic expectations of our society on parents sets everyone up for failure.

Comment: #5
Posted by: Reena
Tue Apr 22, 2008 1:49 PM

I work with parents who aren't perfect. I would welcome a messy home, burger king wrappers on the floor, that would mean that the children were fed recently. Breast feeding and nipple confusion? I'm thrilled if some of them remember to feed the baby the entire bottle, instead of putting it down, it falls into the couch cushions, and they let the baby cry from hunger because they forgot about the bottle. Perfect parents (parents who feed their kids, take care of them, make sure they are educated, medically treated, safe at home and elsewhere) are a breath of fresh air to people who work with troubled families. Putting them down is not something I would do, I would encourage them to use some of their time getting a PTA tutoring ring together for kids whose parents aren't perfect, are hardly parents.

Comment: #6
Posted by: Kimberlayn
Wed May 7, 2008 9:39 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:
Creators.com comments policy
More
Lenore Skenazy
Feb. `10
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 1 2 3 4 5 6
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Author’s Podcast
David Limbaugh
David LimbaughUpdated 9 Feb 2010
William Murchison
William MurchisonUpdated 9 Feb 2010
Deb Saunders
Debra J. SaundersUpdated 9 Feb 2010

6 Jun 2007 You Did Time in Jail? Cool!

17 Jun 2007 100 Words Every Grad Should, Supposedly, Know

31 Dec 2009 Resolutions for the Geeks Who Keep Designing New Electronics