Franken First Senator to Fall in Cultural Fires

By Jamie Stiehm

December 8, 2017 5 min read

WASHINGTON — Democratic Senator Al Franken of Minnesota said he'd step down within weeks, under intense pressure. A secret past of sexually accosting and mocking women came to claim his future. But the truth is, it's not a tragedy.

In a flat farewell floor speech, Franken said he is a "champion of women." He said he was innocent of some charges. After, he exchanged silent hugs with about 20 Democrats. Only one Republican senator, Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., clasped Franken's hand to wish him well. Relief permeated the chamber.

Ironically, Senate Democrats cleared a cloud of sexual harassment allegations just as Senate Republicans may add a notorious man accused of sexually harassing and assaulting girls, Roy Moore of Alabama, to their ranks. (The election is Tuesday.)

In a rare rush to get rid of a colleague, 32 Senate Democrats (out of 48) publicly urged Franken to resign Wednesday as the number of accusers mounted to seven.

Pointedly, Senator Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., said the rising number of women coming forward made the difference. "Democrats take this (sexual misconduct) very seriously. I wish Republican colleagues did as well. I wish the White House did as well," she told me.

A lead voice was Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., but after several Democratic women spoke out against Franken, a crashing wave of men senators joined the call. When the respected Senator Dick Durbin, D-Ill., made clear he thought Franken should go, Franken had few friends left, not even caucus leader, Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. The Senate is personal that way. It can be coldblooded.

Sexual misconduct rapidly became a cultural flash point, like a raging river, this fall. Still, you may wonder why these "Silence Breakers" defined the times, according to Time magazine's person of the year. The answer is: simply, an answer. Angry white men remain President Trump's loyal base, despite his admission of preying on women. As a collective counterpoint, women are speaking out of an anger of their own to answer abuse in the workplace by powerful men.

The dangerous blazes burning large swaths of California are an apt metaphor for the larger conversation. Some say a "reckoning."

Franken is the first senator to be counted a casualty of that flash fire. Days earlier, a powerful House Democrat, John Conyers Jr., D-Mich., announced he'd retire under similar circumstances, a pattern of accusers. Conyers, 88, considered a civil rights beacon, was the oldest member of the House. Angering the Congressional Black Caucus, Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi reluctantly called for him to step down.

When Conyers did resign, speaking from a hospital bed, the riptides of the House and Senate produced such a political fusion that Franken ran out of time to take his case to an Ethics Committee investigation. Conyers' stature in the House was greater than Franken's in the Senate. Once Conyers fell, Franken's fate was a matter of time.

By losing these two visible lawmakers, Democrats can say they "get" an incendiary issue that really matters to voters.

Contrary to his book, "Al Franken, Giant of the Senate," Franken is no giant. Modesty is not his strong suit. His brash manner suggests Harvard (his alma mater) and New York, not the Minnesota state fair.

Now, at 66, the former "Saturday Night Live" comedian's presidential aims were no news to anyone. He was dead serious about it, aside from an occasional cackle on the ceremonious floor.

Playing on a new stage, the Senate since 2009, Franken cultivated a new image. The entertainer was gone and in his place was an earnest lawmaker who prided himself on doing his homework, especially for the Judiciary Committee. One shining moment as a senator was when he grilled Jefferson Sessions about any Russian contacts during Sessions' Attorney General confirmation hearing. This testimony later caught Sessions in a bind.

Yet the faintly misogynist tone of "Saturday Night Live" proved hard to shake. The jokes he wrote involved rape, and in his last book, Franken refused to express regret, saying that was his job.

But lo and behold, a political presidential star is born. Now it's Gillibrand, on the floor to bid Franken a gracious goodbye.

To find out more about Jamie Stiehm and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit

Photo courtesy of 

Lorie Shaull

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

Jamie Stiehm
About Jamie Stiehm
Read More | RSS | Subscribe | Contact



The Senate Tax Bill: Like Turkey Marrow Soup

The Senate Tax Bill: Like Turkey Marrow Soup

By Jamie Stiehm
The Senate — the Republican Senate — is ready to sell us out, though it will be a very near thing. As I write from the press gallery, the place is buzzing like a beehive over this tax act and braced for a late night — aptly under cover of night. By "u Keep reading