creators.com opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop
14 May 2013
Democrats and the ‘Ethics' of Max Baucus

Max Baucus' reputation as one of the most ethically challenged members of the U.S. Senate is well earned. The … Read More.

9 May 2013
Three Girls Lost in Cleveland

The story of three girls grabbed from the streets of Cleveland and caged in their neighborhood for some 10 … Read More.

7 May 2013
Bangladesh and Us

You know a corner's been turned when someone in a legion of foreign sweatshop workers is given a face. That's … Read More.

Cats vs. Dingoes

Comment

The fight goes on. Whether cats are bird-killing machines or soft balls of love (for themselves, anyway) remains a subject of painful debate.

The first part is undoubtedly true. Cats in the United States destroy a median of 2.4 billion birds a year. Add to that death toll 2.3 billion mammals, many of them native creatures: chipmunks, rabbits and voles, reptiles and amphibians.

These numbers came from a much-quoted report by scientists at the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. They are several times higher than previous worrisome estimates.

A black cat hangs around my house. When I come home at night, she slips out of the shadows, giving me a "what are you doing here?" look. I purr, "Here, kitty, kitty," and she slinks off with barely a backward glance.

If she's not going to bond, the least she can do is stay away from my birdbath. And I do wish her owner would keep her indoors. There she'd be safe from speeding cars, pit bulls and my broom.

Of more concern are colonies of cats living in the wild. Their human guardians may regard themselves as animal-rights activists, but the unflattering term for what they do is "subsidize predators." They are enabling an ecological crisis.

Most cats are not native to North America. They are a European and African import, introduced in the 19th century to control rodents. The International Union for Conservation of Nature lists cats among the world's 100 worst invasive species.

The researchers found that pet cats don't account for nearly as many kills as the feral ones. But all cats put together destroy more native wildlife than cars, pesticides, collisions with buildings and other human-related causes.

Some champions of feral cats do partly the right thing by having the animals neutered, then returned to the wild.

But a cat's inability to reproduce does not curb its appetite, and providing food does not quiet the instinct to hunt.

Making the problem worse, cat owners no longer interested in caring for their pets often see cat colonies as a perfect dropping-off place. This, of course, adds to the roaming predator population. The American Bird Conservancy puts the number of homeless cats as high as 100 million.

Some solutions to the problem are not very amenable to cat lovers. (Cousin Janet in Dallas, forgive me for what I'm about to say.) In recent years, coyotes have greatly reduced my neighborhood's outdoor cat count. Sad what happened to Oscar and Buttons and the other feline faces peering down from "missing cat" posters. But the coyote visitation has led to an explosion of bird song.

Dingoes are another possibility. Studies from Australia, where these wild dogs flourished until farmers killed them, see dingoes as a possible savior of birds and other native animals. Researchers at Deakin University in Victoria found that dingoes eat cats and also scare them off, narrowing the window of cat-prowling time, especially right after dusk.

Suffice it to say, cats belong indoors. Whether cats are happier indoors is another matter, but there's no doubt that the beautiful community of winged creatures is safer when cats are watching from a window.

I don't know my silky visitor's name or which neighbor provides her primary address, but I do know this: I don't hang bird feeders and fill the birdbath to create a Dave and Buster's of kitty amusements. At the same time, I don't want to see that pretty feline mug on any cat-missing posters.

As for the human feeders of feral cats, please stop supporting the cat explosion. If you don't, new environmental laws should stop you.

To find out more about Froma Harrop, and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators webpage at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2013 THE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL CO.

DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS.COM



Comments

6 Comments | Post Comment
Everyone needs a break from the grusomeness of politics every now and then. I already knew about the cats killing billions of birds thing, but I'm a science geek so I doubt many others, espicailly cat owners, are aware of this fact. How would they even comprise this kind of data. Do they call up cats and ask them how many birds they've killed in the past week?
Comment: #1
Posted by: Chris McCoy
Thu Mar 28, 2013 6:25 AM
i don't know where to start, Chris McCoy ,a "Science Geek" that does not know how to spell 'especially' or the writer of the article that is so misinformed it's criminal.
Cats killing BILLIONS??? of songbirds? Come on.
Seems to me the article was written by a person who had a neighborhood cat pooh in their garden a few too many times. This is an attempt at revenge to put hate out there against cat lovers.
I agree,if you are feeding cats ,they need to be spayed/neutered & vaccinated. The writer did not mention that cats keep rats,mice ,roaches & other critters at bay. If you've ever lived in the southern, warm weather climate near the water, you'd know how valuable a cat(s) is to have around.
I find cats in colonies rarely kill birds in my neighborhood. The statistics that were sited by the writer come from where? It's extremely questionable. Reminds me of a quote- '3 types of lies- lies,damn lies & statistics.'
Cousin Janice in Dallas was not the only one insulted by your comment about coyotes killing cats. Hopefully you are not out a dusk or dawn when they attack. Coyotes are a threat to everyone,including children & yourself. I'd rather have cats in my neighborhood than a coyote.
Do yourself a favor, ask your feeder neighbor to make a mulch & dirt box in their back yard,so the cats will go there to pooh. There are deterrents you can place in your yard to keep cats away. ( A motion activated scarecrow for one). many plants repel cats from your gardens.
After hurricane Katrina many cats were left unattended in neighborhoods. One such neighborhood asked people not to feed b/c it may attracks rodents.(No rodents were seen at that point.) When they stopped feeding the neighborhood was taken over by rats ,mice & roaches. The original requester asked to bring the cats back.
It's a fine balance ,if a person starts taking cats away from a colony & not returning them,the remaining cats will start to reproduce faster b/c they feel their numbers are dwindling. If you spay/neuter,vaccinate,maintain the colony(& not over feed) Those cats will keep new comers out & die off through attrition. It's called the vaccum effect. So Ms Froma Harrop,do not knock the TNR process. You are lucky to have people that VOLUNTEER to do TRN(trap/neuter/return to colony) in the community.
Your data is flawed & you sound like a cat hater. Please use your energy on more important causes.

One more comment. You state cats are European & African imports? Everyone here in U.S. are "imports", except the Native American Indians.
Comment: #2
Posted by: liz newman
Sat Mar 30, 2013 4:32 PM
The author should have written negatively about the humans that have created this problem. It's a better use of energy to "EDUCATE" careless people as to what their irresponsibility leads to for a homeless cat in the wild. It is a harsh and cruel life out there with plenty of suffering.

To her credit she did sate "cats should be proteced from being "outside."

A good part of the solution to this problem is for public funded shelters to step-up their Trap NeuerRelease programs as put forth by the No Kill Advocacy Center in Oakland, CA. TNR done properly TRAPS / NEUTERS / RELEASES (plus ear notches for I.D.) the cats back into the colony where they can not reproduce ... the colony eventually shrinks in size and dissipates.

This is the compassionate solution. Not the end of the author' s broom.

To learn what would have made a more pertinent article please go to: nokilladvocacycenter.org

Also: www.justneday.ws to see how the No Kill Movement has erupted positively in our country.

YOU CAN MAKE A POSITIVE DIFFERENCE IN YOUR COMMUNITY BY HONORING THE JUNE 11th NATION-WIDE EVENT HONORNG THE FOUNDING OF THE NO KILL MOVEMENT BY GOING BEFORE YOUR COUNTY OFFICIALS TO DEMAND THEY BECOME A NO KILL COMMUNITY BY FOLLOWING THE MATRIX OF THE NO KILL ADVOCACY CENTER - WHICH ADVOCATES FOR TAP/NEUTER/RELEASE - the author of this article is still in the dark ages of cat hating rhetoric- when she hould beome up-to-date about the REAL SOLUTION TO THE PROBLEM.

Irresponsible cat owners are at fault!

Keep cats inside where they belong and have them sterilized too!

For the at-risk and vulnerable,

Sally Ann Bergquist, No Kill Animal Advocate
Treasure Coast Florida Cordinator - JUST ONE DAY 2013
Comment: #3
Posted by: Sall Ann Bergquist
Sun Mar 31, 2013 9:37 AM
The author should have written negatively about the humans that have created this problem.

To her credit she did state "cats should be proteced from being outside" - it is a harsh world out there for them with great suffering.

A good part of the solution to this problem is for public funded shelters to step-up their Trap Neuer Release programs as put forth bythe No Kill Advocacy Center in Oakland, CA. TNR done properly TRAPS / NEUTERS / RELEASES (ear notches for I.D.) the cats hen go back into the colony where they can not reproduce ... the colony eventually shrinks in size and dissipates.

This is the compassionate solution.

To learn what would have made a more pertinent article please go to: nokilladvocacycenter.org (see TNR)

Also: www.justoneday.ws to see how the No Kill Movement has caught fire in our country. It's mainstream!

YOU CAN MAKE A POSITIVE DIFFERENCE IN YOUR COMMUNITY BY SUPPORTING THE JUNE 11th NATION-WIDE EVENT HONORNG THE 11th YEAR FOUNDING OF THE NO KILL MOVEMENT BY GOING BEFORE YOUR ELECTED COUNTY OFFICIALS TO DEMAND THEY MAKE A NO KILL COMMUNITY WITH YOUR TAX DOLLARS BY FOLLOWING THE MATRIX OF THE NO KILL ADVOCACY CENTER - WHICH ADVOCATES FOR TAP/NEUTER/RELEASE - the author of this article is still in the dark ages of cat hating rhetoric- when she should beome up-to-date about the REAL SOLUTION TO THE PROBLEM.

Irresponsible cat owners are at fault! They should be at the end of her broom!

Keep cats inside where they belong and have them sterilized too!

For the at-risk, vulnerable and voiceless,

Sally Ann Bergquist, No Kill Animal Advocate
Treasure Coast Florida Cordinator - JUST ONE DAY 2013
Comment: #4
Posted by: Sall Ann Bergquist
Sun Mar 31, 2013 9:53 AM
Froma Harrop should do rudimentary fact-checking before regurgitating misinformation found in “Cats versus dingoes”. The NY Times 1-29-13 article on the Smithsonian report indicates that results were based on a mathematical model constructed from other studies selectively sifted for inclusion. This technique led to estimates of from 1.4-3.7 billion birds and 6.9-20.7 billion mammals killed each year by cats, whose total population was also estimated. These wild guesses are perfect illustrations of the statistical concept, “garbage in….garbage out”. Alley Cat Allies dug deeper, noting that the results were based on a sample size of 69(!!) birds, 42 of which died, with 6 deaths directly related to cats. Condemnation of cats who must hunt to survive is misplaced. Can the cats who have been employed for many years as rodent control distinguish “good prey” from “not-good prey”? Should hawks, owls, foxes be condemned? Does Harrop seriously think that dingoes used to kill cats would limit their hunting to selected cats? Harrop seems unaware of efforts to sterilize community cats, and gives too much credit to those who abandon cats, claiming that they seek out feral cat colonies when abandoning pets. The misinformation in this opinion column is so extreme that I almost thought that Harrop was presenting her own “modest proposal” hoax. We humans need to accept responsibility: outdoor cats are outdoors because we put them there; they reproduce because we have failed to spay or neuter them. Harrop might note that chickens are birds, too. Perhaps she could spend some time informing us of the treatment of egg-laying hens stacked in cages with footprints no larger than a piece of printer paper, and the fate of the millions of (non-egg-laying) male chicks who are culled and killed by maceration (feeding them into grinders while alive & conscious). To paraphrase Harrop's final sentences: As for human purveyors of such pain and suffering, please stop. If you don't, new laws should stop you.
Comment: #5
Posted by: karen waible
Sun Mar 31, 2013 11:25 AM
I have a 10x15x32 live animal trap certified by my local humane society. I have neighbor who feeds "only one cute cat" but five others have been eating the food, too. I've explained to my neighbor how wild animals will be attracted to the constant food source and then defecate and urinate in my yard, kill my birds etc., to no avail. I've reported her to the local humane society and she lies to them that she is no longer feeding any cats. I've seen her feeding one and then leaving the unfinished food out. When I purchased the trap there were six cats. I've caught five, one died and now there are seven cats digging in my garden. They remind me of illegal criminal alien invaders.
Comment: #6
Posted by: David Henricks
Sun Mar 31, 2013 4:33 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Froma Harrop
May. `13
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Susan EstrichUpdated 15 May 2013
Roger Simon
Roger SimonUpdated 15 May 2013
Robert Scheer
Robert ScheerUpdated 14 May 2013

25 Jun 2009 Helping Borrowers Save Themselves

13 Sep 2012 Close the Mortgage-deduction Loophole

12 Jun 2008 On Issues, Obama Poetry Won't Rhyme