Mamdani Could Ease Trump's Return to New York

By Froma Harrop

November 25, 2025 4 min read

There's no mystery why Zohran Mamdani wanted to get along with Donald Trump. The president threatened New York City with funding cuts, deployment of federal forces and other unpleasantries if its voters elected the self-described democratic socialist as mayor. But why after calling Mamdani all kinds of names, even warning of his possible arrest, did Trump later smother the mayor-elect with flamboyant affection?

An explanation: The MAGA show is closing — as is Trump's time in the White House. Trump needs a new forum on which to stage his dramas.

New York may seem a natural place for the man who, before becoming president, styled himself as Mr. New York. He already has real estate there and, as a builder, might want to cozy up to a mayor who vows to build thousands of apartments. But first, he has to get past the fact that many New Yorkers loathe him.

Mamdani could ease Trump's way back in. The charismatic new mayor could play defense to make his return smooth.

Of course, Trump has other places to go after the White House. Mar-a-Lago would be an obvious choice. Problem is, Palm Beach will be much less lively once Trump can no longer dispense government favors to rich hangers-on. Furthermore, once he's no longer president, the cameras will move on.

There's "Trump Country," one supposes. The problem there is he's leaving much of Trump country in shambles. The tariffs are bankrupting farmers, and the immigration crackdown is taking their workforce. Meanwhile, most of rural America will be hurt by Medicaid cuts.

Besides, wild horses couldn't drag Trump to the places that most loved him. Not enough models. Not enough monied nightspots. Not enough money, in general. And above all, not enough cameras.

The cameras never left Manhattan. Trump may again want to "play the Palace." The expression refers to the 1913 Palace Theatre, then the most famous vaudeville theater in America. For performers, to play the Palace was proof they had truly made it.

But Trump will be 82 when he leaves office. He's no longer the swinging young buck who gamboled his way onto tabloid covers. New Yorkers didn't particularly hate Trump in the old days. They regarded him as an amusing rogue.

Mamdani is also a cagey guy and unlikely to let Trump play him. Trump's offer to help him "Make New York Great Again" didn't play so well in Gotham. New York already regards itself as great. It's much of the MAGA heartland that doesn't seem to be doing so great.

On the other hand, as long as Trump controls the federal government, he has carrots to dangle. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul has pretty much shot down Mamdani's plan for free buses. The state runs the region's transportation system, and she is not keen to provide the $800 million that would be needed.

But didn't Trump offer to work with the next mayor for the betterment of New York City? Consider that $800 million is nothing in Washington. Trump could do the free buses in return for something personal.

Now, becoming bros with Trump would be problematic for Mamdani, who had vowed to be the president's "worst nightmare." Is it really in his interests to participate in a rehabilitation of Donald J. Trump?

But Trump may figure, what goes down can also go up. In 2016, he cinematically launched his first presidential run by coming down the Trump Tower escalator as actors reportedly paid $50 each applauded. Trump may now want to take the up escalator, back to the glittery New York life he once well knew.

But he would probably find, as the expression goes, that "the past is a foreign country."

Follow Froma Harrop on X @FromaHarrop. She can be reached at [email protected]. To find out more about Froma Harrop and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators webpage at www.creators.com.

Photo credit: wes lewis at Unsplash

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

Froma Harrop
About Froma Harrop
Read More | RSS | Subscribe

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE...