opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Susan Estrich
26 Jun 2015
What Courts Do Best

Sometimes what courts do best is the same as what second-grade teachers do best: clean up sloppy sentences. … Read More.

24 Jun 2015

Does having a black president really give us a pass? Nope. So there stood the three Republicans, leaders of … Read More.

19 Jun 2015
Women Get the Money

Actually, they don't. Whether you're a butcher, a baker or a candlestick maker, you make more if you're a man.… Read More.

Love of Country


As a kid, the Fourth of July was always my favorite holiday: the bike parade with the crepe paper so carefully threaded through the spokes, the afternoon of running and jumping contests where everyone won something, and, of course, the highlight, getting the old ratty beach blanket from my father's trunk and watching the fireworks.

I didn't know much about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, but I loved that red, white and blue finale. Who couldn't love America?

Well, quite a few people, as it turns out. When I watch them chant on television and burn our leaders in effigy, my outrage is almost matched by my disbelief. People living lives of poverty and illness, mothers sending their children on rickety boats — we are not doing this to them. Our country would never do this. Save our lives so we can raise our children to hate you? That cannot be right.

Our country is not perfect, but it is nowhere near the disaster the latest round of Republican would-be presidents would have you believe. I worked for the last guy who thought you could win with a strong and positive campaign, and he ended up a gifted professor, among other things, but not president. So as many times as President Reagan used to recite the commandment about Republicans attacking each other, know that they will. And be certain, before it's over, candidates on both sides will be accusing each other of attacking their patriotism, even as they mouth the words "we all love America."

If we all love America so much — and I believe, you have to believe, that most Americans do — then how about our candidates show it in this campaign? The First Amendment protects the right of citizens to say almost anything they want about our country, but it doesn't condone such attacks.

It is only that the alternative of government control of free expression is so much worse, a point that any random five minutes of the evening news would confirm.

It's all just rhetoric, some of my friends say, part of the language of politics, the "red meat" that gets the crowd going. But in the years I've been doing this, the red meat has turned almost entirely negative — it's people shouting "no," with "yes, we can" an almost nostalgic memory.

The number of candidates only increases the risk of an ugly American campaign, in which those who do not love our country will find plenty of tinder for their fires. After all, with so many candidates that I've stopped counting, how do you stand out? Say something nice about one of your opponents? No. Say something positive and unifying? No. Go after Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton? Sure, but that's already started to sound old.

It is easy to blur the line between criticizing our leaders and criticizing our country, between recognizing all of the important challenges we face and providing fodder for those who would damn our country. And there is no easier attack line, when you're on the defense, than accusing the other person of challenging your patriotism so that everyone's patriotism is tainted.

But this seems an especially important year for the crowd of candidates to stay away from attacks on patriotism. We have been through tough times. No one in a position of leadership can fairly claim to be totally free of responsibility. Things went wrong. But we are still the greatest country on the face of the Earth, and if we — and our candidates — don't shout that from the rafters, the haters surely will not.

To find out more about Susan Estrich and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at



18 Comments | Post Comment
Estrich says

1 "I didn't know much about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights" Clearly that remains the case law degree, practicing Attorney or not. Estrich's columns routinely display an ignorance of the Constitution and Bill or Rights rivalled only by the present liberal majority on SCOTUS.

2. "Who couldn't love America?" Barack and Michelle Obama. All progressives, liberals and Democrats as is proven day in day out.

3. "Our country is not perfect" but it is nowhere near the racist, homophobic, misogynistic, politically incorrect, intolerant, imperialistic, hell hole that Estrich, the Obamas, the progressives and the left paint it to be 364 days of the year.

4." those who would damn our country" Start first in the Oval Office, then the AG's office, then Obama's old church, then any Democratic Party premises.

5."But we are still the greatest country on the face of the Earth" despite the efforts of the Obamas and those that put Obama in power to turn America into a third world beggar nation like Greece.

Comment: #1
Posted by: joseph wright
Thu Jul 2, 2015 3:43 PM
Those who don't like America can leave.
Those who don't like it and want to fundamentally transform it can leave.
And be quick about it.

As to candidates, the more the merrier! Let the people have a choice and not be force-fed the choice of the insiders.

Comment: #2
Posted by: pb1222
Thu Jul 2, 2015 5:53 PM

LOL. Reading about a Liberal complaining about others hating the USA is like reading about Satan complaining about people doing bad things. Just funny as heck.

Comment: #3
Posted by: SusansMirror
Thu Jul 2, 2015 8:44 PM
Conservatives love America, they love sending its soldiers to useless wars,they love deficit spending,they love giving tax breaks to companies who don't pay any taxes anyway,Boeing, GE,pick one,they love waving the Stars and Bars and claiming it has nothing to do with slavery,they love religion except today (see Bozell) when their Pope came out and told them what hypocrits they are,they love small government unless "their house" is in a hurricane,they love for government to get out of your life unless the NSA needs to collect all your useless phone calls,Patriot Act.Conservative love is all about hypocrisy,phoney patriotism,flag waving, and marching off to get sombody elses kids ass shot off not their kid,see George W. Bush!
Comment: #4
Thu Jul 2, 2015 9:39 PM

Spoken like the truly ignorant, uninformed, leftist indoctrinated tool and "useful idiot" that he clearly is.

With idiots like Kelley able to vote (probably numerous times in each electoral race) a destitute third world barrio America with no foreign influence or hegemony, with a majority population of useless indolent dole seeking, out of work, no intention of working, hand out seeking, tax credit accepting, parasitic non English speaking immigrants, and wellfare kings and queens and a nuclear Iran, a rampant Islamic caliphate, and a dominant Russia, is just around the corner, if not mostly already here.

That's the nihilist progressive/Democratic Party dream, which thanks to those who put Obama in power is now within their America hating grasp.

A universe away from the true American dream.

God bless America and borrowing from Obama's Rev Wright, God damn the America haters that live amongst us and who have been given power by their fellow travelers: their chickens will surely come home to roost.

Happy destitution ! They will soon run out of other people's money.
Comment: #5
Posted by: joseph wright
Fri Jul 3, 2015 7:23 AM
Re: joseph wright

Is funny all of a sudden Constitutional Conservatives hate the Constitution for working just as it was designed to work. Reagan supported a ban on assault weapons, Scalia ruled that it is constitutional, so remind me again how this is about Obama, freedom, & the second amendment.
As to your other concerns, no worries. There's still lots of other countries you can go that oppress homosexuals, provided you don't mind a lot of Blacks & Muslims:) Maybe should remember 'religious freedom' doesn't mean your freedom should cost others their freedom. And, even if 'the' conf flag comes down in SC & throughout the country, the republican conservatives will still honor their tradition of keeping taxes high on poor & low on wealthy; keeping wages low & stealing from pension plan; privatizing & stealing from the common wealth, and denying health insurance to as many as possible. And must remember to congratulate Republican presidential candidates for giving back money received from Council of Conservative Citizens & other white supremacist organizations ~just as soon as they got caught taking it. One thing for sure Conservative party have plenty of room for racists, bible thumpers, pedophiles, homophobes, science deniers, chicken hawks, and Obama blamers. For they say if it weren't for Obama being black, all the exposure of racism wouldn't have happened. Gays getting married doesn't affect religious freedom; burning black churches and making a slaughterhouse out of another, does.

And remember all you disgruntled American 'patriots', as cartoonist Joe Heller remind us, July 4, 1776 started with it's own Take Down That Flag campaign. And they didn't keep the 'jack' in the corner to appease those Americans who didn't want to separate completely.
Comment: #6
Posted by: steveM
Fri Jul 3, 2015 1:51 PM

You speak much truth, but the fear and denial is strong on this site:)
Remember when the 'voice of Conservatism', Rush Limbaugh said he'd leave America & move to Costa Rica if Obamacare passed:))
Comment: #7
Posted by: steveM
Fri Jul 3, 2015 2:04 PM
Re: steveM

Hey crazy steveM ! What's up? Bored? No children or animals to molest today? Keep taking the meds!

Just remember what 4th July is about.

Its about:

1. Taxation without representation. Taxation now is all about forced wealth redistribution from the productive to the parasites like you.

2. Religious Freedom. The left is using tools like you to attack religious freedom.

3. Unjust laws. The Bill of Rights ( the first ten Amendments) were not passed so that some liberal asshole judge could invent rights within it.

4. It was about the right to bear arms. We are the militia. The reason we need to bear arms is because of the tyranny of Government. And this present Government is all about tyranny.

5. Seizure of Property. Under this administration it is fine to seize property for the so called common good. That is communism.

Oh and a word of thanks is due from you to people like me for providing you with the living you vote for.
Comment: #8
Posted by: joseph wright
Fri Jul 3, 2015 3:09 PM
Comment: #9
Posted by: steveM
Fri Jul 3, 2015 9:22 PM
Re: joseph wright,

I wasn't bored until I read your reply:)
Me, I'm as happy with some bread & butter as I am with a sumptuous meal and I don't eat animals but believe guns are for hunting and protecting and all else is gun nonsense spewed by venomous Wayne La Pierre and spouted by tools like you. Speaking of nonsense, some class three SOT seven FFL holders have their own thoughts;) and NRA used to agree:
"I don't believe in the general promiscuous toting of guns. I think it should be sharply restricted and only under licenses." NRA President Karl Frederick 1934.
That was before the NRA worked for the gun and ammo corporations. Wayne La Pierre..he built that myth about the storm troopers at the door.
Remember joseph, no one trying to ban gun, but then you gun nuts are all or none, day or night, black or white..well white.
And lol, you can't regulate a militia without regulation, but I hear you and know you. Conservatives want non regulated militias and well regulated vagina$ and blacks, and homOsexuals, and Muslims, and...
Conservatives also say the problem in America is they don't teach Christianity in the schools. The real problem is Christianity isn't taught in church.

Remember, joseph wright, We The People, means ALL the people...and there's nothing more American than a 'first
daughter' born on the 4th of July. Happy Birthday Malia Obama.

Comment: #10
Posted by: steveM
Fri Jul 3, 2015 9:39 PM
Re: steveM
I care nothing about what you eat, save that I probably pay for it.
The second Amendment is expressly about the preservation of the "free state" not hunting.
Preservation of the free state means preserving against all enemies of that free state.
Clearly you know absolutely nothing about Christian teaching in church.
Unlike her POS father who along with tools like you has set us on the road to becoming Mexico or worse Greece, Malia Obama has caused neither me nor America any harm or damage and accordingly have no issue with wishing her a happy birthday.
As for her openly America hating father....and her openly America hating mother .....and all the America hating progressives .....well that's a different story.
Comment: #11
Posted by: joseph wright
Sat Jul 4, 2015 5:47 AM
Re: joseph wright

I know you & your ilk love your whipping boy, Obama, you wax on all the time about how he did you and this country wrong, and worse, seem to believe your own drivel. Yet all he did was inherit the white man's mess.
I find you & those who always choose to challenge me in your condescending, patronizing way, entertaining in your obtuseness; you live in a solipsistic world where sane commentary is not allowed to enter but humor is occasionally approved. How bleak your lives must be. I fight this battle long time but often thwarted by your ilk; who prefer to spread the lie over truth. Maybe a shock to your system I and many others foresaw the coming storm and the events that have occurred in EU and are occurring in Greece right now. I give you lyrics from a Bruce Cockburn song I first hear in 1986.
from 1985....They Call It Democracy.

Padded with power here they come
International loan sharks backed by the guns
Of market hungry military profiteers
Whose word is a swamp and whose brow is smeared

with the blood of the poor.

Who rob life of its quality
Who render rage a necessity
By turning countries into labor camps

Modern slavers in drag as champions of freedom

Sinister cynical instrument
Who makes the gun into a sacrament
The only response to the deification
Of tyranny by so-called 'developed' nations

Idolatry of ideology

North South East West
Kill the best and buy the rest
It's just spend a buck to make a buck
You don't really give a flying f*k

About the people in misery.

IMF dirty MF
Takes away everything it can get
Always making certain that there's one thing left

Keep them on the hook with insupportable debt.

See the paid-off local bottom feeders
Passing themselves off as leaders
Kiss the ladies shake hands with the fellows

Open for business like a cheap bordello
And they call it democracy
And they call it democracy

See the loaded eyes of the children too
Trying to make the best of it the way kids habitually do
One day you're going to rise from your habitual feast
To find yourself staring down the throat of the beast

They call the Revolution

IMF dirty MF
Takes away everything it can get
Always making certain that there's only one thing left

Keep them on the hook with insupportable debt

Now, joseph wright, if you excuse me, family celebrating Independence Day. As usual, we getting in the water with the sharks, but we have a boat, maybe we catch a few fish...catch and release:)
Comment: #12
Posted by: steveM
Sat Jul 4, 2015 8:32 AM
Re: steveM

No Steve, you and your family are not celebrating Independence day, you know not what it means and anyway you are simply lying around like every day. No difference. Around you and yours the sea will be a parasite soup.

Oh and I know Cockburn well and indeed agree with the lyrics. But one has to ask who or what created the debt he sings of in the first place. Easy answer. Bankrupting left wing socialist policies, endless welfare, non funded pensions, and spending, spending, spending by corrupt liberal politicians buying votes and keeping the poor on the welfare plantation. And they and you call that Democracy. LOL!

You might want to consider the lyrics of "People See Through You." and before you reply I know that Cockburn originally wrote it about Reagan to whom the lyrics had no real application just the opinion of Cockburn, but the lyrics do apply fully to the Orwellian lying Obama, to the deceitful Clintons (all of them including Chelsea) and to indeed you and your ilk.

Comment: #13
Posted by: joseph wright
Sat Jul 4, 2015 10:08 AM

A word picture of Obama, lyrics by Bruce Cockburm

"People See Through You

You've got covert action
Prejudice to extremes
You've got primitive cunning
And high tech means
You've got eyes everywhere
But people see through you

You've got good manipulators
Got your store of dupes
You've got the idiot clamour
Of your lobby groups
You like to play on fears
But people see through you

You've got instant communication
Instant data tabulation
You got the forces of occupation
But you don't get capitulation
Cause people see through you

You've got the sounding brass
You've got the triumph of the will
You do what you want to
And we pay the bills
You hype the need for sacrifice
But people see through you

You've got anti-matter language
Contrived to conceal
You've been lying so long
You don't know what's real
You're a figment of your own imagination
And people see through you

You've got lip service tributaries
You've got death fetish mercenaries
You hold the tickets to the cemetaries
You're big and bad and scary
But people see through you

Comment: #14
Posted by: joseph wright
Sat Jul 4, 2015 11:48 AM
Nice column Susan!
Comment: #15
Posted by: Partsforfun
Sun Jul 5, 2015 6:03 AM
Re: joseph wright

You need to get a life.
Comment: #16
Posted by: Partsforfun
Sun Jul 5, 2015 6:04 AM
Comment: #17
Posted by: joseph wright
Sun Jul 5, 2015 10:26 AM
Re: Partsforfun

I have had a life, a good life and am thoroughly enjoying my retirement, taken very early, safe in the knowledge that I and those or whom I am responsible are as financially sound as the present world circumstances will permit. I doubt you are in the same position. So maybe I should wish that you could get such a life and I do. However, you will continue to ruin any prospect you may have by continuing to be a liberal and to support liberal ideology. Your family has my sympathy.

No what we all need is a taking back of America from those determined to destroy it, to wit, Obama, the minorities that run it, the Democratic Party, the liberal activists on SCOTUS and the GOP as it is presently constituted.
Comment: #18
Posted by: joseph wright
Sun Jul 5, 2015 11:28 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Susan Estrich
Jul. `15
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Walter Williams
Walter E. WilliamsUpdated 8 Jul 2015
Stephen MooreUpdated 7 Jul 2015
Phyllis Schlafly
Phyllis SchlaflyUpdated 7 Jul 2015

12 Aug 2009 Eunice

15 Aug 2008 Mime Time

7 Sep 2011 The President and His Team