creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
John Stossel
John Stossel
22 May 2013
Sublet My People Go

My kids moved out! I have two empty rooms in my apartment. Maybe I can rent them? A tourist visiting New York … Read More.

15 May 2013
True Grit

Are you a real man (or woman)? Do you have "grit"? Compare yourself to the man on the $20 bill: … Read More.

8 May 2013
Live Free or Move

Forty-three million Americans moved from one state to another between 1995 and 2010 — about one-seventh … Read More.

First Jobs

Comment

What was your first job?

I stuck pieces of plastic and metal together at an Evanston, Ill., assembly line. We produced photocopiers for a company called American Photocopy.

I hated the work. It was hot and boring. But it was useful. It taught me to get good grades in school so I might have other choices.

Four years later, good grades got me a job as a researcher at a TV station.

To my surprise, that became a career. I never planned to be a TV reporter. I hadn't even watched TV news. I never took a journalism course.

But by showing up and trying stuff, I found a career.

I write about this because I'm appalled watching politicians kill off "first" jobs. (They say it's to protect us.)

First, they raise the minimum wage. Forcing employers to pay $7.25 an hour leaves them reluctant to give unskilled kids a chance — why pay more than a worker can produce? So they offer fewer "first" jobs.

On top of that, the Obama Labor Department has issued a fact sheet that says free internships are only legal if the employer derives "no immediate advantage" from the intern.

Are you kidding me? What's the point of that? I want interns who are helpful!

The bureaucrats say they will crack down on companies that don't pay, but that's a terrible thing to do.

Unpaid internships are great. They are win-win. They let young people experiment with careers, and figure out what they'd like and what they're good at. They help employers produce better things and recruit new employees.

I've used interns all my career. They have done some of my best research. Some became journalists themselves. Many told me: "Thank you! I learned more working for you than I learned in college, and I didn't have to pay tuition!

I could have paid them, but then I would have used fewer interns. When I worked at ABC, the network decided to pay them — $10 an hour — but it also cut the number of internships by half. Politicians don't get it. Neither do most people. Polls show that Americans support raising the minimum wage.

Most probably also support limits on unpaid internships, believing that they replace paid work.

But they don't.

OK, sometimes they do. But the free exchange of labor creates so many good things that, in the long run, more jobs are created and many more people get paid work — and we get better work.

But American politicians think they "protect" workers by limiting employers' (and workers') choices and giving handouts to the unemployed.

Outside a welfare office near Fox News, I was told that because of high unemployment, there are no jobs: "There's nothing out there. Nothing." I asked my team to check that out. They walked around for two hours, and within a few blocks of that welfare office they found lots of businesses that want to hire people. On the same block where I was told that there are no jobs, a store manager said he was desperate for applicants. "We need like two or three people all the time."

Of the 79 businesses that we asked, 40 said they would hire. Twenty-four said they would take people with no experience. All wished more people would apply.

I told German Munoz, a recent high school graduate, about one of the jobs offered, at a soul food restaurant. He went there and was hired to wash dishes for minimum wage. Within a few days, he was promoted to busboy — then to waiter. Now, two weeks later, he makes twice the minimum wage. German doesn't want a career as a waiter, but he says it's great having a real first job.

"I meet successful people, and they give good advice and tips on how to become successful. I love it. I love going there every day and learning new stuff. It is like a stepping stone," he said. Exactly.

Low-wage first jobs are indispensable for both personal advancement and social progress. Our best hope for prosperity is the free market. Government must get out of our way and allow consenting adults to create as many "first" jobs as possible.

John Stossel is host of "Stossel" on the Fox Business Network. He's the author of "Give Me a Break" and of "Myth, Lies, and Downright Stupidity." To find out more about John Stossel, visit his site at <a href="http://www.johnstossel.com" <http://www.johnstossel.com>>johnstossel.com</a>. To read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2012 BY JFS PRODUCTIONS, INC.

DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS.COM



Comments

6 Comments | Post Comment
Excellent piece. People put in place laws that kill jobs and then when the results show fewer jobs they want to pass more of the same laws. OSHA recently wanted to outlaw farmers use of their own kids in farmwork. My first job was feeding the sick pig that was kept separate from the rest. I was 7. Learning to work is good for us. When my brother and I went to a summer camp we were in a room of three people. Before we left we were told to clean up the room. We were amazed at how our roommate would wander around complaining and accomplish nothing. Needless to say we were the first ones done of the entire camp. It was simple, just clean it and quit avoiding the effort. There are multiple job killing actions of this administration. Extending the unempolyment elegibility only encourages unempolyed to avoid finding work. Raising the qualifications of "sophisticated investors" only limits job creating investments and help ensure the rich are the only ones free to get richer. Minimum wage, minimum age laws, prevailing wage laws, the paid internship laws. The cause and effect is clear to those who look, for those who pass the job killing laws all they see is that they didn't do enough in spite of the poor results.
If you want to increase imployment eliminate corporate tax, our corporations would be more competitive on the world market, jobs would come back, goods and services would cost less, and all the tax loopholes created to encourage investment in otherwise unprofitable ventures would end allowing companies to focus on investing in the most profitable ventures by value creation rather than tax avoidance. We would end up with more jobs, cheaper goods and services, and higher quality goods and services.
CM
Comment: #1
Posted by: C Moellers
Wed Jul 18, 2012 7:14 AM
Right on. The whole notion that school in any form places one in position to 'hit the ground running' in a future profession is but another example of juvenile, despotic progressive thinking. Schools can offer 'fundamentals' and a limited number of hands-on experiments but becoming usefully productive at any job is a mix of willingness and dedication to a task OVER TIME on the job. It's called 'experience' on your resume. I'm no neophyte in the kitchen but on several occasions after having enjoyed a really good meal at a specialty restaurant, I have asked the manager if they would let me work in their restaurant for a month for free if they would in turn teach me how to prepare their dishes. An offer on my part to exchange value. Most have said "yes" . . . that would be a good deal.

Having a job is on of many examples of free market trade of value. What ever you do for your employer has to be salable to his customers as some value greater than he pays you . . . not so with government. There are precious few individuals on government salaries that produce a valuable service. This gives roots to the idea that government has a charter to tell anyone how they should manage their employee/employer relationship.

After generations of children being raised, educated and governed by intellectual children, we are knee deep in tar pit of despotic progressivism. Those still capable of recognizing the danger and reacting to it in a useful way need to get with the program pretty soon. We're dangerously close to the tipping point . . . assuming that point is not already past . . .
Comment: #2
Posted by: Bob Nuckolls
Wed Jul 18, 2012 8:50 AM
While a min wage job or unpaid internships are great for first jobs were you fail to also mention are the people that lose there full time time (making 50k +) and have a family and small home. These min wage jobs are not going to support a family, a house and a car let alone if your kids are in college. I will agree that these jobs are ok for FIRST time jobs, jobs to have while in college and working towards a real job. But in this word with so many people out of work who have family having a low wage job will not cut it. Unless the GOP want the middle class to live in trailers and bike to work, and also understand that these families that have low wage jobs buying power goes down and that means no movies, no dinner, or vacation,etc this hurt everyone. all I'm saying is there is a differente between a first job and a livable wage job, people have families to feed and you can't do that on a mini wage job.

Thank you
Comment: #3
Posted by: HHFFF
Wed Jul 18, 2012 12:47 PM
Internships and summer jobs for teens are one thing. One can argue that the value added in experience offsets the monetary gain to an extent so minimum wage restrictions could reasonably be modified in these cases. [I would hope though that if my college student son should land an internship he could at least earn a stipend to offset expenses, some college credits or, better yet, both.]

Making a living, however, is a different animal all together. To imply that the employment crisis in this country would be solved if only worker's would [or could] resign themselves to the concept of less than $300 per week [gross] being the new employment paradigm is as cold-hearted as it is preposterous.

Interesting that the term “free exchange of labor” appears in this piece as this was same argument put forth by the Supreme Court during the Gilded Age to defend practices such as Child Labor, Union busting and Sweatshop working conditions. [Ahh! The good old days!]

Mr. Stossel, I seem to recall a time when you were considered a friend of the average man and professed an interest in fair play and equal opportunity. True, I haven't followed your career too closely since the move to FOX [I value my brain cells too highly for that] but I detect a change.
Comment: #4
Posted by: ABarkus
Fri Jul 20, 2012 11:15 AM
" Mr. Stossel, I seem to recall a time when you were considered a friend of the average man and professed an interest in fair play and equal opportunity. True, I haven't followed your career too closely since the move to FOX [I value my brain cells too highly for that] but I detect a change. "
Well Mr.Barkus, You truly blew a great posting in just one paragraph.
The reason Mr. Stossel moved over to FOX was for the reason you just dissed him for.Your "Leftard" MSM news outlets have tried to shut down the power of intelligent, truth based, journalism such as
Mr. Stossels for years, FOX has been the only network over the past ten years+ to let people like him investigate the truth and then report the truth's that he finds.
One would have to guess that you must be a diehard MSNB"S"C /Progressive/Leftard yourself.
I think that if you take an inventory of those brain cells that you value so much, you just might find quite a few missing
Comment: #5
Posted by: Chas from NJ
Wed Jul 25, 2012 1:42 PM
Re: Chas from NJ

Actually, Chas, I agree with you. The comment would have been more effective without the fourth paragraph. Though I stand by the opinion experessed, it was off-topic and gratuitous. The gift of Sarcasm can be difficult to control at times. Point taken.

As far as the insuling remarks about my viewing habits and mental capacity, I was pretty sure it was Fox that had the reputation you attribute to MSNBC, so happy viewing.
Comment: #6
Posted by: ABarkus
Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:46 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
John Stossel
May. `13
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Ray Hanania
Ray HananiaUpdated 23 May 2013
Brent Bozell
L. Brent BozellUpdated 23 May 2013
Larry Elder
Larry ElderUpdated 23 May 2013

17 Sep 2008 Barack Obama and White Privilege

16 Apr 2008 Market Magic

29 Mar 2013 Imperial Washington