creators.com opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Susan Estrich
25 May 2012
The Next Education President

Mitt Romney is right about one thing: Too many American children do receive what he this week called a … Read More.

23 May 2012
Susan Mary Riley, We Will Miss You

It's her voice that I keep hearing in my head. "Susan," she would say, in that quiet, commanding … Read More.

18 May 2012
Boring

When my kids were young, about the worst thing they could say about something was that it was capital-b BORRRING.… Read More.

Echoes of World War II in Normandy

Share Comment

No one told me that January is the wrong time to visit Normandy (until afterwards, that is). Most of the places we went to visit were closed. It was cold and wet and rainy. It took more than three hours each way. But I haven't been to France in fifteen years, and who knows (especially after this trip) when I will go again.

Our driver was an older gentleman, a retired executive who kept himself busy as a tour guide. As we left Paris, he enthusiastically pointed out the sights. This palace and that. This chalet and that. Napoleons' and Louis' and the rest. I finally told him, nicely, that as Americans, we had a somewhat different attitude toward kings. When that didn't work, I told him we'd be closing our eyes.

But as we got closer and found one place after another closed down, I started asking questions. He was old enough to remember World War II, or at least to have learned about it, as I did, from my parents and relatives who fought in the war. His father was a doctor, from right there.

I guess I should have known.

France had stayed out of the war, wisely he thought. After all, look at how many French soldiers died in World War I. Marshall Petain, soldier, appeaser, chief of state of Vichy France, was right to make his peace with Hitler in 1940. Look how many lives he saved. It hardly seemed right that he was prosecuted for treason after the war.

What about the Jews? I asked him. Really, he didn't know. Didn't know?

There were many righteous men and women in France who tried to save their Jewish countrymen and -women. Clearly, that did not include my driver's family. Nor the Vichy government. All told, 76,000 Jews were sent to concentration camps in France.

Refugees were among the first to be rounded up. Pity those who thought they would find refuge from Hitler in France. They were as much in the dark as I was. They paid with their lives. All but 2,500 of those sent to the camps in France died.

The only place open was the American cemetery and the small museum adjacent to it. Our driver apologized. It hardly seemed worth the trip, he said. Wrong again.

You might remember the cemetery from the opening scenes in "Saving Private Ryan."

But seeing it is different.

I stood there with my 18-year-old son. The rain poured down. We stared at row after row of crosses, interspersed with stars of David. The museum, simple, powerful, told the story of these brave Americans, many of them no older than my son.

Omaha Beach is quiet. Even on a rainy day, it is beautiful. But it was not beautiful on D-Day. The ocean was dyed red with the blood of brave Americans who waded from their boats into enemy fire — kids who gave their lives to save each other, to liberate the French, to defeat evil.

On that day, as the tape in the museum says, they carried the fate of the free world — "the entire free world" — on their young shoulders.

They saved the world.

My friend Annie was the one who told me to go to Normandy. She is the child of survivors, born in Munich after the war. She said that standing in that cemetery, she was overcome with pride to be an immigrant to this country.

For all our problems, we are still the luckiest people on the face of the globe. And one of the reasons for that is because of those young soldiers who gave their lives for our freedom — and for the freedom of people like my driver and his family. He may not know enough to appreciate that. But I do. God bless America.

To find out more about Susan Estrich and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2012 CREATORS.COM


Comments

12 Comments | Post Comment
Amen
Comment: #1
Posted by: wayne
Wed Jan 11, 2012 12:47 AM
Two initial points (1) "as Americans, we had a somewhat different attitude toward kings" that is unless the "we" are Democrats who would happily coronate and bow down to king barak the first and (2) was this Estrich's for the first time in my adult life I am proud of my country moochelle moment?
That said the American cemetry overlooking Omaha Beach, which I have visited many many times over the years is one of the saddest, heart wrenching and yet simultaneously the most moving and inspiring places in all of the world.
AS to "For all our problems, we are still the luckiest people on the face of the globe. And one of the reasons for that is because of those young soldiers who gave their lives for our freedom" Amen to that.
Comment: #2
Posted by: joseph wright
Wed Jan 11, 2012 2:50 PM
Enjoyed eading the article. My wife & I finally made it to Basse-Normandie in October 2010. It was a somber visit to the Colleville-sur-Mer American cemetary and the visits to Armefreville, Ste Mere Eglise, Utah & Omaha beaches. My Dad jumped out of a Higgins boat at Omaha so I had a vested interest in addidition to being an appreciative American for what was accomplished there. Susan did a fine job on the article. I may not agree with her political views but I appreciate her writing it and the realization of the price paid that day (June 6th) as well as the enormous struggle that was the Battle of Normandy from the beaches to St Lo, Carentan the German counter strike at Mortain and the many other firefights & battles. Too bad her driver was seemingly clueless to the events. It was the experience for my wife & I (and our 2 sons on a subsequent visit in April 2011) that in the Basse-Normandie area there is an appreciation for the Americans' efforts there. Not all French were Vichy and the Marquis & Free French fought well against the Germans. Good job Susan!!!! Al George Kandahar , Afghansiatn
Comment: #3
Posted by: Al George
Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:53 PM
My wife and I had similar feelings on our visit to Normandy in 1997. From your description of your visit it seems you did not get on the beach and that's unfortunate. Looking up at those cliffs and immagining trying to climb them under fire filled me with awe at the courage of our boys. Looking at the date of birth of those buied there caused us to think of our fathers who survived the war and how lucky we were and how much those brave men burried there gave for us. Because of them and those like them we were raised in a land blessed with freedom.
We were pleasantly surprised with the reverence shown by 2 or 3 bus loads of French school children who were there visiting. A particularly touching moment occurred wihen I read a handwritten note from a 15 year old girl that was lying next to the monument. She said she was thankful for what these men had given up for her and promised to continue to visit because she knew that the commardes of those there were getting to be to old to visit.
Joe Stine Warrington PA
Comment: #4
Posted by: joe stine
Thu Jan 12, 2012 11:04 AM
I disagree with almost everything Susan Estrich says, but this was a beautiful column. Those soldiers saved the world. We are so lucky.
Comment: #5
Posted by: Brian
Fri Jan 13, 2012 5:11 PM
I, too, visited the Normandy Beaches during a driving gale, almost a re-enactment, for it was in June. The surprise, to me, was the width of the invasion area. I can read a map, but in the many times I have studied diagrams giving the names of the individual "Beaches", nationality of the forces, etc., the scale escaped me. I had an impression of a single stretch of sand, conveniently divided into continuous sections, each named separately for administrative convenience.

In fact, the invasion coast stretched for fifty miles. This not only stresses the enormity of the effort, but makes the point that there was almost no way the Germans could hope successfully to defend the entire area at the same time.

As a WWII Veteran who spent a couple of years in India, I must confess that I do not regret missing the show on D-Day.

Mac McConnell

Comment: #6
Posted by: Mac McConnell
Fri Jan 13, 2012 7:55 PM
What did you expect the French government to do with Nazi Germany at their doorstep? The smart thing would have been to do what Marshal Petain did. Should he have Sacrifice hundreds of thousands of French in a loosing proposition. I also notice you only seem concerned about the Jews. Quite frankly I am tired of hearing about how the Jews suffered. There were millions of no-Jews who lost their lives. There were around 20 million Russians wo lost their lives. It is fine to sit here in America 66 years after the war and cry about the capitulation of the French but it is a far different thing to be there and commit suicide trying prevent the enevitable. It is time to let WW11 go and for you Jews to move on like the rest of the world did.






Comment: #3
Posted by: Chris
Sat Jan 14, 2012 11:23 AM



Reply
Report this post

Comment: #7
Posted by: Chris
Sat Jan 14, 2012 11:31 AM
Chris asked what were they supposed to do? I suggest he reads the the history of what the Norwegians did.
Comment: #8
Posted by: dunce
Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:44 PM
Chris asked what were they supposed to do? I suggest he reads the the history of what the Norwegians did.
Comment: #9
Posted by: dunce
Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:44 PM
What a contradictory snob! She gets pissy becuase her guide has a different view of his countries history, but SHE refuses to learn about the same country's history too. Maybe if she understood the history and culture of a country that was born out of a feudal system, she just might understand her hosts views (not agreeing with them, but with context, I understand it).

And really...who travels to another country and doesn't do ANY research on the location? Common sense would dictate that if one was traveling in the winter...to a vacation spot...that things might be closed due to the weather. You know, like how Martha's vineyard or the Outerbanks close down for the off season.
Comment: #10
Posted by: Ilumine
Mon Jan 16, 2012 4:39 AM
As for the Cemetary, I have been there too. It IS awe inspiring. But for a full appreciation, go down to the beach at mid tide (what the first wave had to go in on) and look at the expanse and the cliffs...then you will see.
Comment: #11
Posted by: Ilumine
Mon Jan 16, 2012 4:42 AM
There is a difference between Norway and France in geography and distance from Germany. But it doesn't make any difference because I am tired of people who criticize others when they haven't been in their shoes and France has always been the whipping boy for some reason. Remember all this stuff about freedom fries. So because France didn't want to go into Iraq and slaughter innocent people we great Americans ridiculed them. After Iraq who are we to talk about the Nazis?
Comment: #12
Posted by: Chris
Mon Jan 16, 2012 11:01 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Susan Estrich
May. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Marc Dion
Marc DionUpdated 28 May 2012
Tom Rosshirt
Tom RosshirtUpdated 26 May 2012
David Sirota
David SirotaUpdated 25 May 2012

14 Oct 2011 Bulletin: Republicans and Democrats Do Something

17 Sep 2010 Beyond Party

19 Jun 2009 Gay Rights