When It Comes to AI, the U.S. and China Are Light-Years Apart

By Keith Raffel

November 18, 2026 7 min read

For the life of me, I cannot see how China and the United States will ever reach an effective, enforceable agreement on the development and use of artificial intelligence.

Over three decades ago, a bestselling book suggested that when it comes to relationships, "Men are from Mars and women are from Venus." Maybe, maybe not. But when it comes to what the world's two superpowers stand for, China and the United States aren't merely on different planets. They're in different galaxies.

China is an ancient civilization now run by its Communist Party that ranks social harmony and stability far above individual liberties. A single person's rights are trumped by what the party considers the greater good of millions. By comparison, the United States is a young country founded on the principles of individual liberty and limited government. Neither country consistently lives up to its ideals, but the gap between them remains wide and deep.

And that chasm makes it awfully hard for them to agree on how to handle artificial intelligence. We find ourselves in a world where neither the top brass of the Chinese Communist Party nor America's tech lords have much incentive to compromise.

In the United States, AI development is driven by private corporations seeking to generate profits for themselves and their shareholders. In China, the rules governing AI are ultimately determined by the Communist Party to ensure harmony and the greater good, at least in theory.

In Xinjiang, Chinese authorities have used AI tools to analyze vast troves of surveillance data to identify persons deemed suspicious based on their social circles and religious practices. It's estimated that more than half a million Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities are in prison or detention.

China's AI companies may be listed on the Shanghai and Hong Kong stock exchanges, but even they operate within the bounds set by the Communist Party. The country's National Intelligence Law requires cooperation with intelligence agencies. And its generative AI regulations require AI providers to uphold the country's "core socialist values."

After the Chinese company DeepSeek announced its breakthrough generative AI product, the government stepped in to discourage recruitment of its employees, screen prospective investors and restrict overseas travel. The message was clear: Innovation remains under the supervision of the party.

Boy, oh boy, do things ever work differently in the U.S.

Ten of the world's 12 most valuable publicly traded companies are American, and all of them have made significant investments in AI. They range from Apple to Nvidia to Amazon to Tesla. Google's original motto was "Don't be evil." Now Google's parent company Alphabet, another of those corporate giants, uses the slogan, "Do the right thing."

Excuse my cynicism, but it appears that doing the right thing for Alphabet and other AI companies is coincidentally compatible with increasing market share and stock prices.

A decade ago, Harvard's professor Sheila Jasanoff warned that companies such as Google and Facebook (now Meta) could use individuals' data, the basis of AI, pretty much as they like. She wrote, "Though technically private, or nonstate, these companies straddle a line that makes it difficult for states to hold them accountable for data use, or misuse." Technology has changed, but the problem of holding the tech lords accountable remains.

Jensen Huang, Nvidia's former CEO, was among the most prominent advocates for easing American restrictions on exporting AI chips to China. His position might not have been consistent with U.S. national security interests, but it did suit Nvidia's bottom line. Huang's resignation was announced on Nov. 12 following revelations about his relationship with a former senior executive of Singapore-based Megaspeed. That company was under investigation for allegedly shipping advanced Nvidia chips to China in violation of U.S. laws.

As we have learned from Russia's war against Ukraine, AI has become an increasingly important military asset. Using AI to help relatively cheap drones identify and destroy targets has proven a major strategic advantage in the struggle. Giving up on using AI for military advantage would be high-risk for any military establishment. When it came to arms treaties, President Ronald Reagan used to say, "Trust but verify." The U.S. and China don't much trust each other, and verifying restrictions on software used to target weapons would prove far more difficult than counting missiles or inspecting nuclear weapons facilities.

When I worked in Silicon Valley, I used to repeat this truism: The company with the biggest database wins. A Stanford study found, "Access to government-collected data allows China's facial recognition AI firms to innovate more in both government and commercial applications." This ability to mobilize governmental resources can give Chinese AI companies an advantage their American competitors will find hard to duplicate. Meanwhile, unilateral action by Washington to rein in AI could handicap American companies in their competition with China.

Washington and Beijing can discuss AI safety until the cows come home. But with the distrust between China and the U.S., the near impossibility of verifying compliance, the Chinese advantage in building huge databases, and the incentives for American companies to pursue profit, the outlook is bleak for any serious AI agreement between the countries.

An effective, enforceable Chinese-American pact on AI development and use is about as likely as Donald Trump writing a million-dollar check to support a Pete Buttigieg presidential campaign.

A renaissance man, Keith Raffel has served as the senior counsel to the Senate Intelligence Committee and started a successful internet software company. His sixth novel, "The Duplicate," will be published in March 2027. He currently spends the academic year as a resident scholar at Harvard. You can learn more about him at keithraffel.com. To read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators website at creators.com.

DIST. BY CREATORS

Photo credit: Cash Macanaya at Unsplash

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

The Raffel Ticket
About Keith Raffel
Read More | RSS | Subscribe

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE...