creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
William Murchison
William Murchison
24 Nov 2009
Lions and Christians

The perceived necessity of a Manhattan Declaration would have jarred the Pilgrims from prayerful … Read More.

17 Nov 2009
Women in Danger!

A major detail of the Fort Hood horribleness has escaped comment, insofar as I can tell. I'm going to comment,… Read More.

10 Nov 2009
Mrs. Pelosi Thumbs her Nose

After 10 months of Nancy Pelosi at the helm of the House, Americans could be forgiven for unfurling their … Read More.

Time For Recess

According to a recent poll by Political Strategies Inc./POLITICO, only a quarter of Americans "trust" Nancy Pelosi.

Mrs. Pelosi, reacting to a question about the poll, replied, "I don't care." The reporter with whom she was speaking said she was "laughing heartily."

Now for today's topic: democracy.

Say what you will about it, and there's plenty to say on both sides, democracy is the system that holds leaders accountable for performance, assuming the voters take the time and trouble — as increasingly, to Mrs. Pelosi's chagrin, and the president's — has become the case with health care.

Leading Democrats have bleated like sheep over Congress' inability, unwillingness, or both to follow White House orders and get health care "reform" passed before the August recess.

Guess what these leaders are pretending not to notice: democracy in action. The sovereign people, as orators and such sometimes call them, are growing edgy and nervous; so are, correspondingly, the senators and House members they elected to represent their interests in Washington.

Quite a few of the sovereign people fear that the White House and the Capitol Hill leadership are determined to ram a certain kind of reform down their throats, just as quickly as 300 million American mouths can be pried open to receive same. The White House and the leadership don't want argument or debate. That's why there haven't been substantive debates, just White House press conference lectures on abstractions such as "need," with few connections drawn between problem and indicated solution.

More and more Americans, in short, see their political leadership as issuing orders from yards — meters — miles above the common herd, scarcely bothering to explain; more interested in telling than asking, in getting it done as opposed to getting it right.

Brothers and sisters, if that's democracy, then up is down, hard is soft, and Warren Buffett is an apprentice bookkeeper in the Virgin Islands.

Democratic bleating over growing opposition to Pelosi/Obama-style reform — opposition generally portrayed in the District of Obama as willful or selfish — can't disguise reality.

An August recess from bleating is just what the doctor ordered. Our representatives need to go home, face the voters and find out whether the reform style on the table is what said voters really want. If it seems to be — with voter assent signified by the simple act of piping down — then it's coming our way. If, however, the cost, and the degree of nannylike oversight envisioned by the plan rub us wrong, that, too, is democracy. Better to have a kind of referendum now before the cell door slams and the Democrats flip through our wallets to see what they want to buy next.

A vast variety of arguments can be made against DemoCare, a particularly salient one being that we haven't even talked this one through. An extra trillion-to-trillion-and-a-half of our money ... for what? Does Nancy Pelosi know? How could she? Nobody can know. One can project — that's all, according to one's presumptions, which probably won't match the presumptions of someone else sitting two feet away

(BEGIN ITALS) Nobody knows. (END ITALS) Yet Nancy Pelosi wants to flog this one through so she can flog something else through, like cap-and-trade policies to fight global warming.

Mrs. Pelosi doesn't care, apparently, whether the voters trust her. Wherefore it has come to this: The administration we looked to for "change" and "unity" works night and day to force-feed us its ideas and plans and designs.

Don't ask question is the administration's slogan. Don't hold open hearings. Don't call in the expert on both sides. Don't try to make the thing right — try to make it happen.

August can't come too soon. We need a break for thought — a pause that refreshes bare and banal discourse. The voters need to see their representatives, hear them, speak to them and listen as they speak back. How odd such an approach may seem in the District of Obama. In venues less exalted they have a name for it — democracy.

William Murchison is the author of "Mortal Follies: Episcopalians and the Crisis of Mainline Christianity." To find out more about William Murchison and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2009 CREATORS.COM

??

??

??

??


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
More
William Murchison
Nov. `09
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Author’s Podcast
John Stossel
John StosselUpdated 25 Nov 2009
Michelle Malkin
Michelle MalkinUpdated 25 Nov 2009
Brent Bozell
L. Brent BozellUpdated 25 Nov 2009

26 Jun 2007 Free Speech And The Politicians

10 Mar 2009 Of Stem Cells And 'Ideologues'

6 Nov 2009 The Fort Hood Massacre