opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Tom Rosshirt
Tom Rosshirt
26 Apr 2013

Earlier this month, I traveled down to Texas to visit my dad. Twenty years after buying the house that he and … Read More.

19 Apr 2013
Will the Boston Attack Kill Immigration Reform?

As news came out Friday on the background of the suspects in the Boston Marathon bombings, TV commentators … Read More.

12 Apr 2013
We're Not in This Together

Former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, who died April 8 in London at the age of 87, was often … Read More.

The Bigger the Problem the Riskier the Solution


Since the recent collapse of the supercommittee, there have been competing narratives about who wins and who loses from the failure. Some say Democrats gain, because it highlights the issue of millionaires paying more taxes. Some say Republicans gain, because it shows the government is incompetent.

I believe both parties lose and Americans Elect wins.

Americans Elect is a group that is inventing an online method for nominating a presidential ticket for the 2012 election. It believes that the political center can prevail over the extremes if the public is given a chance to choose a presidential candidate directly through social media — unfiltered by corporate money and the will of the major political parties.

The group is well on its way to getting its ticket on the presidential ballot in each of the 50 states.

Is this a good thing?

Norm Ornstein and Thomas Mann — two of the most respected scholars of American politics — say no.

If an independent were to win, they say, he or she would have no leverage with the Democrats and Republicans in the Congress and, therefore, couldn't govern. More likely, the independent would not win but would tilt the contest to a major-party candidate, perhaps a far-right Republican nominee. In any event, these two experts argue, the next president would take office with fewer votes than past presidents, making him or her politically weaker. That is not a recipe for resolving a political standoff.

I posed some of these objections to Americans Elect's Doug Schoen — a political strategist, a pollster and an analyst for Fox News.

Schoen argued that the most powerful person in Washington from 1994-96 was Ross Perot. He was the reason the budget got balanced. He didn't even have to win; just by running in '92 and threatening to run in '96, he forced the other candidates onto his agenda.

Similarly, Schoen argued that if you have a national ticket talking about the need to find solutions in the center, it's going to force the two major-party candidates to take up that message, to compete for those votes. That will create a chorus of major candidates all promising cooperation, which would make it likelier to happen.

But I would argue that the problem hasn't been with the president.

The problem is with members of Congress who see their refusal to compromise as a mark of virtue.

How do you change Congress by changing the way you elect the president?

In my view, you can do it only indirectly, by changing the political culture. You would have to bet that a presidential campaign that emphasized cooperation could change the political climate so much that a refusal to compromise would become a political liability for a member of Congress.

Americans Elect wants us to make that bet. It believes that the great majority of Americans want cooperation and compromise but that they're marginalized because the process gives more power to extremists.

But where's the evidence for that view? "The Big Sort," written by Bill Bishop (a friend and former co-worker of mine), argues with powerful statistical evidence that since 1976, Americans have increasingly segregated themselves into neighborhoods, churches and volunteer organizations according to their political views. Once in the company of a large majority of people who think as they do, their views become more extreme and uncompromising. This would suggest that Congress is polarized not because of the major parties and corporate money. Instead, members of Congress are polarized because the people who sent them to Congress are.

Schoen acknowledges that there is no certainty that the extremists will compromise — no matter what happens in the presidential election. But he argues that there would be a much better chance of compromise after a strong third-party challenge than there would be if Obama were to win in a two-way fight with a Republican.

Good argument, but is it worth risking the dangers Ornstein and Mann warn about for a chance at a new political culture that values cooperation over extremism?

Frankly, no one is waiting for the answer. Americans Elect is going forward; social media will make a transforming impact in this election or the next. The technology appears to be in the hands of centrists now. It may well be better-used by extremists in the future. We are a restless society. We invent new things and use them without knowing whether they will make life better or worse.

Man, I hope this helps.

To find out more about Tom Rosshirt and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at



1 Comments | Post Comment
I don't think the right wants to compromise, nor do I think they should. What the left wants is simply bad for the country. We have compromised to the point of permanent 10% unemployment and a stagnant economy. Time to go in another direction, and that is that. If the driver got you lost would you compromise and let him continue to drive?
Comment: #1
Posted by: Tom
Tue Dec 20, 2011 12:29 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Tom Rosshirt
Apr. `13
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Star ParkerUpdated 10 Feb 2016
John Stossel
John StosselUpdated 10 Feb 2016
Jim Hightower
Jim HightowerUpdated 10 Feb 2016

5 Apr 2013 My Dream Candidate

6 Apr 2012 The Wisdom of Doubt

8 Mar 2013 Cheney's Main Fault