opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Steve Chapman
Steve Chapman
19 Oct 2014
Why Are Democrats Cozy with the Clintons?

It's not surprising that many Democrats running for major offices this year would prefer not to sidle up to a … Read More.

16 Oct 2014
Inflated Fears of Ebola and Terrorism

Americans are living under a dire threat that could quickly escalate into a national emergency. No, not Ebola … Read More.

2 Oct 2014
Dangerous People and Deadly Force

When a man jumped over the White House fence, ran across the lawn and entered the residence, the Secret … Read More.

The Minimum Wage Mirage


Unemployment remains high; job growth is sluggish; and millions of Americans have given up hope of ever finding work. So how do creative legislators propose to generate new hiring? Easy: Make it more expensive.

That's right. In Congress and several states, some lawmakers want to increase the legally mandated minimum wage. They think employers should have to pay more for labor. They say it should be illegal to hire people who are willing to work cheap.

This amounts to a stubborn defiance of simple reality. A recession puts strong downward pressure on wages and salaries. A slow recovery has the same effect, only milder. It's an unfortunate consequence of a weak economy.

You can't blame anyone for wanting incomes to grow. But trying to achieve that in this manner is like trying to start a campfire by aiming a hose at a swimming pool.

Still, the idea has no shortage of fans. Some supporters think it should be increased to $9.80 an hour by 2014. Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, chairman of the labor committee, told The New York Times a raise would "help hard-working families make ends meet, join the middle class, and help move the economy forward."

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg favors increasing his state's floor. Even Mitt Romney thinks the federal minimum wage should climb automatically with inflation.

No one will deny that the minimum wage provides for a meager income. Under the federal requirement of $7.25 an hour, a full-time worker earns just $15,080 a year. Illinois' $8.25 minimum wage yields an annual income of $17,160. The federal poverty level for a two-person family — say, a single mother and a child — is $15,130.

It would be nice if every worker were worth $9.80 an hour. But not all workers are. If you tell a company it has to pay $9.80 to someone who produces only $7.50 in value, the company may choose to pay that employee an even lower wage: zero.

That's one way a higher minimum destroys jobs. Another problem is that by increasing labor costs, the change would inevitably tip some companies from profitable to unprofitable.

A fast-food restaurant that can stay afloat paying $7.25 an hour might sink under the weight of a 35 percent increase. Some businesses would disappear, taking their jobs with them.

It's a time-tested axiom of economics that when the government sets a minimum wage, it causes unemployment by pricing some workers — particularly marginal ones — out of the labor market.

David Neumark, an economist at the University of California, Irvine and co-author of the 2008 book "Minimum Wages," says a 10 percent boost in the minimum wage could be expected to reduce employment among low-skilled workers by 1 to 2 percent.

Supporters of the change insist that an increase would have no such effect, and a couple of studies support the claim. But if it's true, why stop at $9.80 an hour? Why not $19.80? Why not $99.80? Water won't run up a steep slope — but it also won't run up a gentle one.

Nor is it plausible to believe, as the National Employment Law Project does, that giving more money to workers would lift the economy because it "would give people more money to spend." It would do that by leaving other people less money to spend — either the business owners who would have to pay higher wages or the customers who would face higher prices. The total amount of money available for making purchases wouldn't change.

Supporters think raising the minimum wage is a good way to reduce poverty, but it's not. Neumark says only about 17 percent of minimum wage workers are in poor families. Many of the rest of are middle-class youngsters.

A better way to help workers at the bottom is already in place — the federal earned income tax credit, which supplements the earnings of low-income workers. A woman with one child earning the minimum wage in a full-time job can get an additional $3,169 per year from the tax credit. This approach has the distinct advantage of channeling extra money to the working poor — without turning some of them into the unemployed poor.

In trying to help those in need, avoiding certain harm to the intended beneficiaries is not too much to ask. In fact, it should be the minimum.

Steve Chapman blogs daily at To find out more about Steve Chapman, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at



1 Comments | Post Comment
"It would be nice if every worker were worth $9.80 an hour. But not all workers are. If you tell a company it has to pay $9.80 to someone who produces only $7.50 in value, the company may choose to pay that employee an even lower wage: zero."

That paragraph all by itself exhibits more understanding of economics than what I've seen from the vast majority of Congress, the mainstream media, and the president.

I cringe every time I hear some politician propose a tax credit for hiring people, or suggesting that businesses should hire workers out of "patriotism."

The only reason a business should hire someone is because doing so will increase the business' profitability.

Unfortunately, with the Marxist takeover of our education system since that began in the 1960s, the very word "profit" has become a perjorative.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Jeff Gunn
Thu Apr 12, 2012 12:04 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Steve Chapman
Oct. `14
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Authorís Podcast
Brent Bozell
Ben Shapiro
Ben ShapiroUpdated 22 Oct 2014
Jacob Sullum
Jacob SullumUpdated 22 Oct 2014

14 Mar 2010 Dying People Shouldn't Have to be Beggars

11 Apr 2010 Time for a Change in Baseball

10 Jun 2007 The Endless Variations of Edwards and Romney