opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Robert Scheer
Robert Scheer
5 Feb 2016
Crisis of Faith and Football

As a recently suffering Oakland Raiders fan, I greeted the death of Kenny "The Snake" Stabler with a cocktail … Read More.

26 Oct 2015
An Idiotic GOP Is Looking at the Wrong Thing in Its Clinton Probe

The Republicans on that committee investigating Hillary Clinton are idiots for focusing on decisions about … Read More.

19 Oct 2015
Bernie Blew It: He Sold Out Instead of Confronting Clinton

Bernie blew it. By embracing rather than confronting Hillary Clinton, Sen. Sanders fell into the trap of … Read More.

Apple's China Comes Home to Haunt Us


Four decades ago, Richard Nixon, a once famously hawkish Republican president, cut a deal with the Communist overlords of China to reshape the world. The result was a transformation of the global economy in ways that we are only now, with the sharp critiques of Apple's China operation, beginning to fully comprehend.

At the heart of the deal was a rejection of the basic moral claim of both egalitarian socialism and free-market capitalism, the rival ideologies of the Cold War, to empower the individual as the center of decision-making. Instead, the fate of the citizen would come to be determined by an alliance between huge multinational corporations and government elites with scant reference to the needs of ordinary working folk.

It was understood by both parties to this grand concord that monopoly capitalism could be constructed in China to be consistent with the continuance in power of a Communist hierarchy, just as in the West capitalism was consistent with the enrichment of an ostensibly democratic ruling class. Sharp income inequality, the bane of genuine reform movements bearing the names "populist," "socialist" and "democratic," came to be the defining mark of the new international order.

The current controversy over Apple's treatment of its 700,000 foreign workers, mostly in China, is a manifestation of that cross-ideological betrayal. The ironies are manifest. Not the least of which is that businessmen from Taiwan, the bastion of anti-Communist Chinese during the Cold War and still the pretend reason for a U.S. military presence in the region, are the essential organizers of mainland China's workforce. But in the pursuit of profit, and at a time when the startling success of China's hybrid communist-capitalist model keeps the U.S. Treasury afloat, few questions are asked.

Indeed, the pressure is now on to better emulate that model within the United States, to keep still more jobs from being shipped abroad. The human rights concerns of the U.S. have by now been opportunistically tailored to exclude any serious concern about the rights of workers to organize unions to make their job conditions more humane. China's labor practices are now to be admired rather than scorned, lest the American economy decline further in the new world order.

As The New York Times pointed out last month in its devastating overview of Apple's shift from its once proud claim of making its products in the USA to near total dependence on China, "It isn't just that workers are cheaper abroad.

Rather, Apple's executives believe the vast scale of overseas factories as well as the flexibility, diligence and industrial skills of foreign workers have so outpaced their American counterparts that 'Made in the U.S.A.' is no longer a viable option for most Apple products."

Parse that language to find the excuse to run roughshod over environmental protections, workers' rights and occupational safety standards in order to allow "flexibility" at the massive Foxconn and other plants in China where robotic work is performed by humans under conditions that even Apple has conceded in an internal audit are unacceptable under modern industrial standards.

In reality, the multinational corporations prefer China's state-sponsored model of capitalism, which assures them an endless supply of docile workers unprotected by those pesky unions and restrictive government regulations. As Steve Jobs told President Obama last year, "Those jobs aren't coming back." The reason that Jobs supplied in his 2011 approved biography is that the Chinese government is so wonderfully acquiescent to the development plans of foreign corporations. Not so in the U.S., where, Jobs claimed, "regulations and unnecessary costs" make it difficult for companies to operate. That the result of China's deregulation is poisoned air, worker suicide and a massive waste of resources is deemed to be beside the point.

Oddly enough, Jobs, who succeeded in business without attending more than part of a single college semester, also blamed a U.S. educational system "crippled by union work rules" for what he proclaimed to be the sorry state of our domestic labor force. One of the basic human rights being violated by the Chinese government is that of workers to organize unions responsive to their needs; rather, they are at the mercy of phony organizations tolerated by the Communist government. It is sad and discouraging that Jobs endorsed a blatantly anti-union position by claiming that until the teachers' unions were broken, there would be almost no hope for education reform.

Considering the workforce employed by Apple, one has to question what sort of properly trained graduates Jobs had in mind. If the habits required of Apple's workforce in China are to be emulated, the U.S. military or perhaps our outsized prison system should become the essential schooling system for American workers to better compete with the properly disciplined assemblers of iPhones in China.

Robert Scheer is editor of, where this column originally appeared. Email him at To find out more about Robert Scheer and to read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Webpage at



2 Comments | Post Comment
I didn't expect more from China, I did expect more from Steve Jobs and Apple and the suffocating holier than thou attitude of Corporate American. They'd have this country and the world back to the days of the Industrial Revolution and before, when the air was so filthy it was called "pea soup" and the waters were so dirty with factory waste, human waste, and the carcasses of the dead and dying fish, birds, and wildlife. The air in Detroit and the waters of Lake Erie and Lake St Clair and the Detroit River were so polluted from years and years of unregulated Industrial pollution everything and everyone was sick and dying, but healthcare and the economy was booming. That wasn't back in the early 1900's, It was during my lifetime and it was up to and including the late 1970's early 80's. The intriguing and revealing parts of your column touches not only on the plight of workers, it tells the truth of Corporate Greed, names names, exposes the lies and here we are 2012 prepared to cut funding to EPA and all the significant regulations put in place to protect the American worker and our great country. Steve Jobs, Apple, Communist Capitalists, the US, Global Big Business all in bed together. And they say homosexuals are strange bedfellows. Huh!
Comment: #1
Posted by: demecra zydeem
Fri Feb 17, 2012 6:36 PM
To compete with China we need a younger and better trained workforce. Child labor laws should be changed to allow 13 year olds or older to work in safe fast food places and assembly line work on a part time basis at lower than minimum wage. The public school system is doing such a poor job of educating a tech savy workforce and giving little or no homework that working children is the one solution to becoming more competitive with China. Children used to help out on the farm at young ages. It is high time that children once again learned the American work ethic in the real world and they should get paid for it! Instead of shuttling children to and from sports activities in school the parents should be shuttling children to and from part time work experiences!
Comment: #2
Posted by: Uldis Sprogis
Mon Mar 12, 2012 6:10 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Robert Scheer
Feb. `16
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Patrick Buchanan
Pat BuchananUpdated 12 Feb 2016
Veronique de RugyUpdated 11 Feb 2016
Matt Towery
Matt ToweryUpdated 11 Feb 2016

31 May 2012 Hope Burning

2 Apr 2013 It Wasn't David Stockman Who Wrecked the Economy

19 Oct 2015 Bernie Blew It: He Sold Out Instead of Confronting Clinton