creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Patrick Buchanan
Pat Buchanan
14 Feb 2012
On to Tehran -- or Is It Damascus?

Our War Party has been temporarily diverted from its clamor for war on Iran by the insurrection against the … Read More.

10 Feb 2012
Obama's Trampling on God's Turf Now

Yes, Virginia, there is a religious war going on. It is for the soul of America. And traditional Christianity … Read More.

7 Feb 2012
Who Wants War With Iran?

Appearing alongside CIA Director David Petraeus before the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence last week, … Read More.

Sgt. Crowley, a Cop in Full

Share Comment

Sunday, professor Louis Henry Gates retreated from his threat to sue Sgt. James Crowley. Friday, President Obama retreated from his charge that the Cambridge cops "acted stupidly."

As Crowley has not budged an inch — his arrest of Gates was correct, and there will be no apology — there is no doubt who won this face-off. Game, set, match, Crowley and the Cambridge cops.

It is, indeed, as Obama said Friday, a "teachable moment."

And those most in need of teaching are the professor, the governor of Massachusetts and President Obama. By charging or suggesting Gates was a victim of racial profiling, all three were guilty of having reflexively reverted to racial stereotypes about white cops.

Here is the chronology.

Answering a 911 call about a break-in in progress, Crowley encountered the professor inside the house. According to Crowley's report, his request for Gates' I.D. was initially rebuffed, and he was accused of hassling Gates because he was black. The professor made a slurring reference to Crowley's "mama."

The professor then raised such a ruckus Crowley arrested and cuffed him.

Once in the street, Gates bellowed, "This is what happens to a black man in America." Gates then called Crowley a "rogue cop."

Gov. Deval Patrick declared Gates' arrest "every black man's nightmare." Obama said the Cambridge cops had "acted stupidly" and went on to elaborate, on nationwide TV, on the sad history of racial profiling of blacks and Hispanics by police.

Thus the two most powerful black elected officials in the U.S., with no hard knowledge of what happened, came down on the side of a black professor, their buddy, against a white cop and his department, implying racial motivation in the arrest of Gates.

Yet there is still not a shred of evidence for their rush to judgment.

Crowley's partner in the arrest was a black officer who said he stands "100 percent" behind Crowley and that Gates acted "strange."

Sixteen years ago, Crowley gave CPR to an unconscious Boston Celtics star, Reggie Lewis, in an attempt to save his life. The memory of his failure caused Crowley to break down in tears and haunts him to this day.

Crowley was selected by a black police lieutenant to teach fellow officers about racial profiling.

He has been doing this for five years.

And watching TV coverage for a week, this writer has yet to hear one cop anywhere condemn Crowley's handling of the incident.

Outside the fevered imagination of Louis Henry Gates, then, where is the evidence Crowley engaged in racial profiling?

The victim here is Sgt. Crowley, not professor Gates.

Crowley is the one defamed as a "racist" and "rogue cop." He is the officer whom Gov. Patrick implied perpetrated "every black man's nightmare." He is the cop on the Cambridge force who, Obama told the nation, "acted stupidly."

If anyone has grounds for legal action, it is Crowley. Indeed, upon what grounds would Gates sue?

That he was wrongly arrested, when Crowley, his black partner, the Cambridge P.D., the police union and 1,000 cops would gladly come to Cambridge to testify that Crowley went by the book?

Moreover, no one says Crowley abused Gates in any way. And there were witnesses in the street to the arrest. And Crowley apparently had his mike open, and a recording of the incident exists.

But if Obama's racial reflexes served him badly Wednesday night, his political instincts served him well him on Friday. For he must have sensed that this confrontation was shaping up as three powerful black men coming down hard on a white cop with a stellar record who had only done his conscientious duty.

Obama picked up the phone, called Crowley, regretted his choice of words about him and the Cambridge P.D., walked into the press room and told the nation Crowley was a "good guy," he himself had misspoken, that he and the sergeant had talked about getting together for a beer.

It was a goodly slice of humble pie the president ate there, but it was a class act. To ask more would be churlish. As for Patrick and Gates, they, too, should eat a little crow.

The president's decision to go before the White House press corps also suggests Obama is acutely aware of the political peril here.

For while his black support is rock solid, his white support is soft. And Americans will usually side with an Irish cop over a Harvard don, especially when the professor is pulling rank and the cop is right.

"This isn't about me," says Gates. Sorry, professor, it is about you. You have shown the country why William F. Buckley won laughter all over America when he wittily observed that, rather than be governed by the Harvard faculty, he would prefer to be governed by the first 300 names in the Cambridge telephone directory.

Patrick Buchanan is the author of the new book "Churchill, Hitler and 'The Unnecessary War." To find out more about Patrick Buchanan, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2009 CREATORS.COM


Comments

6 Comments | Post Comment
Sir;...You need to learn something about the world...You know how whites are gradually being outnumbered by minorities... Think of all the places in this world where we sojourn as extreme minorities... Is this the lesson we wish to teach the world; that no Black Man is ever equal in his own land??? Do you want to teach the world, where we are relatively few in numbers, that we are some white devils who must be banished from humanity??? I know what happened there, and so do you...The man came home from a trip, and needed to drain his vein...His door was stuck and he was frustrated, and in walked the cops adding insult to indignity...The explanation is simple...The fact is not entirely clear whether the officer would have treated a white man as rudely....My money is on the Black Man...I see the way the cops treat people around here... Law enforcement is our single largest county expense by far, and while the Sheriffs department is handing out yard signs saying: I support the Sheriffs Department, they and the City Police seem to be everywhere handing out more and more tickets...Look around, cops...Everyone is hurting...Everyone is behind and trying to catch up... And I don't like it when they use my road for a drag strip, but there has to be some limit to trying to support the government, or the price of law enforcement with speeding tickets...I can't support them...I don't speed any more, or much less...I don't have any points, and knock on wood...The fact is that the more law we have the more law we need, and the higher the price goes, the higher it will go... Law makes more criminals than it cures...It is a monumental failure... Blood feuds were not much of a success either...People were happy to hand the job of justice over to others... But when the perception is, that justice is not forthcoming, or even possible no matter how much law we have if you are black; then you take justice into your own hands..Do we want every man to set himself up as the judge of his own behavior???? Law is stupid, so it is no surprise when police act stupidly... When we cannot afford health insurance we are wrong to put any money into law or defense...We need something to defend, and history shows us that the more we prepare for war the more our neighbors seem like enemies... The same is true of law, that the more money we put into law, police, and prisons the more the free society begins to resemble a prison, with no one free...The problem is not the indignant professor... The problem is that those who make the law think they can make injustice legal...Government, and business which are the soul and the purpose of law need the light of law shone upon them... If any act is not just, it cannot be legal...It does not matter what authority was given to the police in the legitimate pursuit of their goals...Not one of them has the authority to do an injustice, because no power in America can give anyone that authority...People do injustice on their own authority...As justice is a goal of our federal government it should be a goal of all governments, and each is only as legitimate as it is just...The policeman in this case does not understand his job, and he does not understand the need for the cooperation of the people in the pursuit of justice...He made trouble..He disturbed the peace...Every person is entitled to peace in his own place, and if you defend peace for the poor professor, you defend it for the worthless rich...That should be you goal...It is not mine... I do not defend peace more than I defend Justice...Thanks...Sweeney
Comment: #1
Posted by: James A, Sweeney
Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:58 AM
once again pat buchannan spews his venom. get over it pat, a black man, Barack Hussein Obama, is president of the U.S. Your racist attitude is prevalent among white men across the country, who would rather the country go to hell instead of backing this intelligent, capable leader of the free world. where was all this criticism when george bush was saying dumb things everywhere he went to everybody he came in contact with. all you and your conservative cronies have done since the election of this brilliant man is to try to de-legitimize him and seemingly are trying to call forth one of the crazies of the world to assassinate him. however, what you don't understand is that Barack was ordained by God almighty. he is president because of that. it was divine, not from man. you cannot stop him. pat get over it!!!!!!!
Comment: #2
Posted by: cathy jo williams
Tue Jul 28, 2009 12:08 PM
This has nothing to do with race; this is about abuse of authority by a policeman and violating the civil rights of an American by a government agent.
The facts are these: Gates was inside the confines of his own home; there was NO probable cause to believe that a crime was being or had been committed; there was NO reasonable suspicion that Gates had committed or was about to commit a criminal act; there is no legal grounds for charging a person with "disorderly conduct" in his own home (which is probably why the cop wanted Gates outside the dwelling). Once Gates had shown his ID, the cop was trespassing on private property, plain and simple.
The cop committed a criminal violation of 18 USC 241 and ought to be summoned into federal court to face criminal charges. Will the US Attorney charge the cop? No way in hell! No cop has been punished for violating someone's rights in America since the Rodney King case. This is the essence of a police state; the Constitution be damned.
It is irrelevant what Gates's race is.
Comment: #3
Posted by: CanisLatus
Tue Jul 28, 2009 12:55 PM
I was interested in the article but I quit reading because Mr.Buchanan wasn't there. He wrote it like he witnessed it. He doesn't know what was said on the scene because he wasn't there. The only proof what was said was the 911 tape. Both Mr. Crowley and Mr. Gates were never recorded on the 911 tape.
Comment: #4
Posted by: Ron
Tue Jul 28, 2009 10:25 PM
Re: cathy jo williams;...Ma'am, ...I surely think it was divine that the better man won...Usually money fixes the situation so that will not happen...Or the better man, who is the more moral man, does something stupid as though his brains were made for keeping his ears parted....No; I don't know if God played a role... I do know that God loves us no better than the choices we make...Thanks...Sweeney
Comment: #5
Posted by: James A, Sweeney
Wed Jul 29, 2009 8:04 PM
Pat, and everybody else,
I was pleased when I heard of Obama's response to this incident, even though I do not like nor trust him. How did Gates end up outside? Was he dragged out of his own house? Would that be okay if he were mouthy?
The police also need to be monitored, whether you, Pat Buchanan, feel it necessary or not. "Because I told you so" is never an appropriate response here for a policeman. If they don't know their stuff, they should not be serving, and I mean serving, us.
I will grant you that Sgt. Crowley does not seem a bad man. Still, perhaps, this not-bad man was tested, and failed in his goal of fulfilling his duties to the letter of the law. In which case he should 'fess up, tell the truth, and apologize for his mishandling of the situation. As a servant of the people, I expect acknowledgements of bad judgement. There is no reason to believe his version over a citizen: that would be discriminating, now wouldn't it?

While one may or may not believe Gates' stances to be good or bad or right or wrong, the truth as I see it, day in and day out, is that policemen consider themselves ABOVE THE LAW. Which we must show them they are not.
Comment: #6
Posted by: billbowman
Fri Aug 21, 2009 2:04 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Pat Buchanan
Feb. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 31 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 1 2 3
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Author’s Podcast
Austin Bay
Austin BayUpdated 15 Feb 2012
Michelle Malkin
Michelle MalkinUpdated 15 Feb 2012
Jim Hightower
Jim HightowerUpdated 15 Feb 2012

25 May 2007 Why Congress Caved to Bush

22 Jul 2011 Is a Tea Party Triumph at Hand?

7 Mar 2007 Martyr of the War Party