Understandably, Republicans are seething.
When Hank Paulson demanded $700 billion to haul away the trash in the dumpsters of JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs — assuring us we could hold a garage sale of the junk — they rebelled. They acted as the nation, by 100 to one, demanded. They killed the Wall Street bailout.
The Dow quickly sank another 1,000 points, and, charged with criminal irresponsibility by the elites, the GOP buckled, reversed itself, rescued the bailout — and was wiped out on Nov. 4.
Now we hear from Paulson that the $700 billion Congress voted will not, after all, be used to buy up all that rotten paper on the books of the big banks. Some banks are using the cash to buy other banks.
So Republicans are right to be enraged. They are victims of the biggest bait-and-switch in political history. But they are now about to do something terminally stupid. With GM, Ford and Chrysler teetering on the brink, they are turning a cold stone face to Detroit and are about to follow the counsel of that quintessential Bushite Dick Darman, who said of our computer chip industry, "If our guys can't hack it, let 'em go."
America responded — by letting George H.W. Bush and Darman go.
Are Republicans aware of what they are about to do?
When workers, execs, engineers, dealers, salesmen and suppliers are all factored in, the Big Three employ 3 million people who contribute $21 billion a year to Social Security and Medicare, and $25 billion in federal income taxes. Add in all the businesses that depend on the auto industry, and we are talking about one-tenth of the U.S. labor force.
As columnist Tom Piatak of Chronicles and Takimag.com writes, 850,000 retirees, and their families, depend for pensions and health care on the Big Three. If they go under, the burden falls on us.
And to let the auto industry die is to write America out of much of the economic future of the planet.
In a good year, like 2005, Americans buy more than 17 million new cars, and West Europeans as many. Tens of millions in Eastern Europe, Russia, China, India and Southeast Asia are now moving into the middle class each year. These folks will all need or want one or two family cars. If we let the U.S. auto industry die, that immense and burgeoning market will be lost forever to America, and ceded to Asia.
"Who cares?" comes the free-traders' reply.
Japanese and Koreans are setting up factories here. They can pick up the slack.
But that means Americans will work for and depend on foreign companies for a necessity of our national life as vital as the imported oil and gas on which our cars and trucks operate. All the profits of the mighty automobile industry in America will be sent abroad.
Before Republicans follow this free-trade fanaticism to their final interment, they might study the results of a poll by Peter Hart:
— Seventy-eight percent of Americans believe the U.S. auto industry is highly or extremely important. Three percent think we can do without it.
— Ninety percent of Americans believe the death of the U.S. auto industry would do great damage to our economic future.
— By 55 percent to 30 percent, Americans favor federal loans to save it. And by 64 percent to 25 percent Americans back President-elect Obama's resolve not to let the U.S. auto industry go under.
If the GOP blocks these loans, and the industry dies, the party can forget about Ohio, Michigan and the industrial Midwest. For the Reagan Democrats will never come home again. Nor should they.
By the choices we make, we define ourselves and reveal what we truly care about. Thus, consider:
We bail out the New York and D.C. governments of Abe Beame and Marion Barry. We bail out a corrupt Mexico. We bail out public schools that have failed us for 40 years.
We bail out with International Monetary Fund and World Bank loans and foreign aid worthless Third World regimes.
We bail out Wall Street plutocrats and big banks.
But the most magnificent industry, the auto industry that was the pride of America and envy of the world, we surrender to predator-traders from Asia and Europe, lest we violate the tenets of some 19th-century ideological scribblers that the old Republicans considered the apogee of British stupidity.
Nancy Pelosi is talking about tying loans to a restructuring of the industry. But Congress is not competent to do that.
What needs to be restructured is the U.S. tax-and-trade regime.
Dump globalism. Instruct Japan, Canada, Korea, Germany and China that if they wish to sell cars here, they will assemble them here and produce the parts here. And we shall have the same free access to and same share of their auto market as they have of ours.
To accomplish this, use the same import quotas and tariffs Ronald Reagan used to save the steel industry and Harley-Davidson.
Reciprocal trade. Even Democrats like FDR used to practice it.
Patrick Buchanan is the author of the new book "Churchill, Hitler and 'The Unnecessary War." To find out more about Patrick Buchanan, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com.
COPYRIGHT 2008 CREATORS SYNDICATE INC.

|
 |
Comments
|
4 Comments | Post Comment
|
|
Got this one mostly right, Byuke. Good job. A dog biscuit for you. Keep on sniffin.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Masako
Mon Nov 17, 2008 9:04 PM
|
|
|
|
Sir; tell me about it... When I was a kid, eighteen; I went to see The Govenor, George Wallace in Lansing Michigan, an Oldsmobile town. And I got a front row seat, and a going over by the secret service along with my tape recorder, and except for always paying attention, that is as close as I ever came to being a press person... And, I must admit that between the two, Granpa Jones, and Mr. Wallace, that they put on a hellova show... And my guess is that blue collar, factory rats, and Reagan democrats filled up the civic center that night... I want to tell you something... I have worked in many auto plants, and everything everyone else was doing, modernizing, trimming down the fat and the dead wood, engineering a better product is something the auto industry in Michigan has been doing all along... They we doing fine in all the places like China and Europe where they shipped American Jobs... If those markets are blown there, as much as they are blown here -by imported autos and foreign car producers -in this land, then; that is a fact of capitalism, and not particular to Michigan and Ohio... The big three didn't have control of the fuel, or the fact that we went to war and ruined the value of the dollar with inflation. They cannot control the out of control spirel of health care....And, in some instances, they were producing for a market that will always be there, for pickups and suvsthat screwed the cafe standards.... For Richard Shelby of Alabama, a certified sore and fossil himself to call the big three a dinosaur is a damned lie... They are deeply in debt because they were struggling to modernize, and get a younger work force, more pliable working conditions, and robots on every single process that could take automation, and don't think robots are not expensive...And the worst part of the expense is that robots do not buy cars, and if you multiply that fact of mechanization, across society you can get an idea of how deep this depression will be. In addition; their insured work force subsidized the health cost for every person in the State.. Because their bills paid every bill that did not get paid by people who could not pay, and for that very reason, our jobs went to Canada... We do not have many people in America who actually produce value, perhaps 20% of the work force... 80% of our economy is service related; but ninty percent of the profits of this society were enjoyed by the finanacial sector... Now, this bears checking because I have the facts off the tube... But if this last is true, then we were working all over this country to pay interest, and were not in the black anywhere without an overburden of debt...I have heard jokes about building a Negro retirement home for Generous Motors; but the fact is that those people work hard, in a miserable job, and they often had to run to keep up with assembly lines I helped build, and it was not easy, and it ruined people and made them fickle, and sometime broke them physically... But, I never talked to too many of them who were not republican in outlook... What ever Richard Shelby thinks he is doing for himself; he isn't doing anything for the republicans around here...Maybe they have seats to spare in the house of Reps... Why sell the dear when you can give them away???Thanks...Sweeney
Comment: #2
Posted by: James A, Sweeney
Tue Nov 18, 2008 6:55 AM
|
|
|
|
A brief note. I understand that President Clinton, early in his term, called all the auto makers to the White House and asked them to commit to manufacturing a car that would get a hundred miles to the gallon by the year 2000. They all agreed they could do it if they tried. Well, none of them quite got there, but Toyota and Honda came damn close with their hybrid cars, didn't they? They did their best. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Somehow, I don't think the miserable failure of the U.S. to place in even the qualifying heats was due to the workers who always DEMAND TOO MUCH, like a living wage, the ability to live when they're too old to work for wages, and access to a doctor when they're sick, which by the way, they bargained for fair and square. I think it was due to the lazy CEO's who got their money anyway no matter what they did, NO STRINGS ATTACHED. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
What a nice deal. "We sill suck the money out anyway, no matter what we actually accomplish. We don't care, we don't have to." That was the motto those highly visible, role-model American CEO's were holding out to our kids, our future leaders. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
It just goes to show you what a deal and a handshake means in the business world these days. It means a hell of a lot more in Japan and other countries that don't have laurels to rest on than it does in the United States, and that's why auto industries everywhere else are knuckling under and surviving while ours are are on their knees begging for spare change. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
They need change, all right, but not the chump change Republicans want to save by selling them off. They need to submit to fundamentally new management directed by the government. You know, the government we look to when we really need to get something done, like saving our asses from invaders or epidemics. We need the same kind of can-do commitment that put a man on the moon, on time, as promised, courtesy of the United States of America. ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................,.
And let the chump change Republicans who want to sell off the nation's jewels sell off their spare kidneys instead. They only need one apiece after all, and that market is still humming, last time I checked.
Comment: #3
Posted by: Masako
Tue Nov 18, 2008 8:24 PM
|
|
|
|
You say that the auto industry is vital to this nation and should be supported. What separates the auto industry from any other manufacturing industry?
You advocate mercantilism, but at what point should you draw the line. Obviously it would be stupid for our own nation to supply 100% of the goods and services we consume. Yet you advocate protection of local industry. When do we stop protecting it. At what dollar amount does it no longer make sense to prop up the auto industry or any other industry. There is a reason that mercantilism is discredited by the economic community. While it may make intuitive sense if you carry it out fully you end up with a far less prosperous nation.
Our country's international economic relations is not a zero sum game. Trade can help everyone prosper. This is a fundamental truth taught economics 101.
Comment: #4
Posted by: bohstedt1
Wed Nov 19, 2008 6:14 PM
|
|
|
|
|
|