creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Miguel Perez
Miguel Perez
22 May 2012
In Defense of Colombianas and Cartagena

Working at a Manhattan jewelry store, the last thing my friend Claudia expected was confronting a new … Read More.

15 May 2012
The Spirit of Ada Merritt

Perhaps it was the times we lived in; the 1960s were special to almost everyone. Or perhaps it had more to do … Read More.

1 May 2012
Supreme Setback Looms Ahead

If the Supreme Court tea leaf readers are correct, if more than four justices decide to uphold Arizona's … Read More.

'Largest Minority' Still Means 'Nada'

Share Comment

Now that the statisticians have begun to crunch the numbers and interpret the information gathered by the 2010 census, get ready for a new epidemic of xenophobia.

It happens every 10 years. As census figures reveal that Latinos are multiplying at a faster rate than other segments of the U.S. population — even surpassing African-Americans and becoming "the largest minority" in additional cities, counties and states — more people get unnecessarily alarmed about the growth of the Hispanic community.

Of course, being "the largest minority" means absolutely nada. It's a completely worthless title that only serves to further scare those who already suffer from immigration paranoia. It exaggerates the false perception, shared by some white Americans, that Latinos are "taking over." And it makes some African-Americans — having lost their "largest minority" title — erroneously assume that Latinos are going after their small share of the American pie.

Perhaps the blame should go to all the politicians who have spent years telling Latinos that "soon, you will be the nation's largest minority group" — as if that would solve all our problems.

It was all lip service, a phony way of promising empowerment without having to do anything to help Latinos obtain it. They knew that mere population numbers would not automatically make Latinos the most influential minority — or even one that is represented adequately in politics. But they went ahead and flaunted the fabricated and fictitious "largest minority" milestone, perhaps without realizing that it could be used to scare those who already feel some apprehension about the growing number of U.S. Latinos.

Based on 2010 census figures being released gradually on a state-by-state basis from now until April 1, the media already are giving the impression that — as if the census were a magic wand — Latinos are about to gain significant political empowerment. Some people are scared by reports asserting that there are 50 counties and 21 states where Latinos already are "the largest minority" — as if that means anything! In fact, in most of those counties and all of those states, Latinos still are grossly underserved and underrepresented.

Unfortunately, these census-based news reports mostly serve as ammunition for race-baiting politicians, who use these figures to turn more Americans into xenophobes.

Here's the reality: Of the 48.4 million Latinos the U.S.

Census Bureau estimated to be in the country last year, only 20.1 million are now eligible to vote. The majority of Latinos still fall under the other two huge categories: Some 15.5 million Latinos are U.S. citizens but too young to vote, and about 12.8 million of all ages — including some 11 million undocumented immigrants — are not yet naturalized citizens. By the way, those numbers are based on Census Bureau population estimates conducted prior to the 2010 census and released last year. The national Latino population based on the 2010 census will not be known until all the states receive their respective census results, which are due to them by April 1.

Yet when those more accurate 2010 census figures are in — still — fewer than half of U.S. Latinos will be eligible to vote. Political empowerment for Latinos, in proportion to population, is not exactly around the corner — not when the "largest minority" hoopla keeps scaring the xenophobes, not when those numbers are used to fuel anti-immigrant and anti-Hispanic measures in Congress and state legislatures throughout the country.

At a time when several states are trying to emulate Arizona's Draconian anti-immigrant and racial profiling measures and when a new crop of conservative extremists is getting ready to assault Latinos' civil rights in Congress, the news reports touting the growth of the Hispanic population could be a two-edged sword for Latinos. Unless they turn their growing population figures into a rising number of Latino voters, the census results will be more harmful than helpful.

Some Latino community leaders — in areas where the "largest minority" title now is being acquired, thanks to the 2010 census — still will argue that now they will have to be taken into account by the political establishment. Good luck!

But keep in mind that nationally, Latinos have been the largest minority since July 2002. That's when the Hispanic population reached 38.8 million, edging out the African-American population of 37.6 million. In many cities and counties throughout the nation, Latinos have been the largest minority for even longer. Yet that distinction has meant very little in places where the population figures are not converted into naturalization and voter-registration numbers.

The time will come when the U.S. Latino population (projected to be 132.8 million by 2050) is so big that even if half of them are voting, it would make a huge difference. But that time has not arrived yet. And even then, it should not be reason for anyone to be scared or apprehensive.

To find out more about Miguel Perez and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2011 CREATORS.COM


Comments

8 Comments | Post Comment
The Ethnocultural Amendment is the true Democracy Amendment, the missing eleventh Right of the Bill of Rights and an ethnoracial organizing principle par excellence.

The Ethnocultural Amendment

No citizen shall be denied or deprived of the right to an ethnoracial identity; no citizen shall be denied or deprived of the right to belong to an ethnoracial group; no ethnoracial group shall be denied or deprived of the right to ethnocultural sovereignty.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Luis Magno
Tue Feb 15, 2011 7:48 AM
You want to change the Bill of Rights? When and where and how is anyone preventing you from doing any of these things right now? You have all the same rights that I, a white woman descended from European immigrants, has. You are completely free to dress how you want, speak the language you want to, and vote however you want to. Nobody is lifting a finger to stop you. Now of course some choices will inhibit your opportunities, especially when it comes to job opportunities. I know very well that if I dyed my hair blue and started speaking only German, they would fire me from my job. But nobody is preventing me from doing that.

I dated a Latino man (with Mexican-born parents) for over a year. He spent so much of his time and energy being angry and hateful about any perceived slight to his culture and his people. He went out of his way to take even the most benign comment as an insult. It was mentally exhausting to be with him and constantly watch every word I said, and I eventually left him for that very reason. I feel sorry for him though, because his hatred blinds him to all the wonderful things he has - - a lovely house, a completely free college education (thanks to a racial-based scholarship), a good career, and friends who never give a second thought to his ethnicity and just like him for the person he is. If he ever stopped focusing so much on hate, he would see that he is living an enviable life - - one that most people in this world would die to have! But to this day he is the exact same way, and I feel like the author of this column is the exact same way: doomed to a life of smoldering hatred. What a terrible shame.
Comment: #2
Posted by: Kim
Tue Feb 15, 2011 9:31 AM
Re: Kim
Excellent point...Integration...This is a melting pot...Hispanics that continue to wish for equal treatment under the premises that they can retain their language, culture, roots, and separatism from the American mainstream are playing with fire...Integrate, learn the language and culture, and become part of the melting pot as other minorities have done...Hispanics continue to compare their plight to that of the American Negro...These are two distinct minority movements...The American Black is a homogeneous group with a similar language, culture, and traditions, besides having American citizenship by birth....The Hispanic minority is a large, fragmented minority composed of descendents and natives of an incredibly large number of Latin American nations with distinct cultures and even variations of the Spanish language...The American Black had the leadership of a Martin Luther King who eventually became a martyr for the cause and is now revered as a saviour of the cause....Any resemblance to the leadership of the Hispanic minority movement?????? Definetly not...
Comment: #3
Posted by: Andy
Wed Feb 16, 2011 9:35 AM
"No citizen shall be denied or deprived of the right to an ethnoracial identity; no citizen shall be denied or deprived of the right to belong to an ethnoracial group; no ethnoracial group shall be denied or deprived of the right to ethnocultural sovereignty."
Comment: #1
Posted by: Luis Magno

This means Nazis get their rights...at last! Sieg Heil!

Thanks, "Mango."

Good post, Kim!
Comment: #4
Posted by: T.H. Asgardson
Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:52 PM
Re: T.H. Asgardson
-
Sieg Heil
Heil dir im Siegerkranz (German: "Hail to Thee in Victor's Crown") was from 1871 to 1918 the unofficial national anthem of the German Empire. Previously it had been the anthem of Prussia, but the melody of the hymn is actually the same as ...
-
I am proud of my Germanic (Austrian) heritage.
-
Yes, under the Ethnocultural Amendment "Whites" including mixed-race, hate-filled "White" Nationalists like you would have collective rights. You can then stop bitching about being overrun by "mud" people and go back to being human.
Comment: #5
Posted by: Luis Magno
Thu Feb 17, 2011 1:58 PM
Re: Andy
-
A majority of Hispanics are mixed-race. A third are of European descent. To "Whites" all Hispanics are "non-White". It is a delusional view of the Hispanic reality. Hispanics are a linguo-cultural group consisting of a multiplicity of ethnoraces and nationalities. Blacks are an ethnoracial group but are mostly seen by "Whites" as simply a racial group as "Whites" also see themselves. That is delusional.
-
Should Hispanics assimilate as Anglo-Saxons? Did Blacks? Blacks were, moreover, under slavery already Anglicized. There are necessarily fundamental leadership differences between ethnoracial groups and linguocultural groups.
-
The Ethnocultural Amendment is the product of European-descended Hispanics who are proudly conscious of both their cultural and racial ancestral heritages and are committed to the survival of both. "Whites" identify primarily and in most instances solely with their physical bodies. It is as if they had no cultural ancestral heritage, the essence of being a human being.
-
That is the major difference between European-descended Anglophones and European-descended Hispanophones. Hispanic European Americans are rooted in reality. Most Anglo European Americans are not. To be sure the Hispanic European American experience is a difficult one. Anglo European Americans are generally too dumbed-down to understand what is in their own long-term interest. Without the protection of the Ethnocultural Amendment they will soon be a minority.
-
But to "Whites" Hispanics are all simply "non-White" except perhaps on occasion for personal reasons. Anglo-Saxon America is delusional. This is 2011 not 1776. Half-baked ideals will not suffice. Two-thirds of a person is passé. The Ethnocultural Amendment is key to saving the American Dream turned nightmare for "Whites" as well as for "non-Whites" for which it has generally been a nightmare.
-
The ethnocultural rights protected by the proposed Ethnocultural Amendment would have prohibited Black slavery and Indigenous genocide hence its omission as a concession to the slave owners and the Money Power who were willing to wait another two centuries before their final enslavement of Americans and of all mankind.
-
Comment: #6
Posted by: Luis Magno
Thu Feb 17, 2011 2:39 PM
Re: Luis Magno

"Whites" identify primarily and in most instances solely with their physical bodies. It is as if they had no cultural ancestral heritage, the essence of being a human being."

This is utter garbage with no basis in reality. It is pseudo-intellectualism at its most royal rotten. Take your half-baked theory and quit trying to impose it on an incurious world.

" Anglo European Americans are generally too dumbed-down to understand what is in their own long-term interest..."

"Dumbed down" is someone who uses a hyphen where it does not belong.
Comment: #7
Posted by: T.H. Asgardson
Fri Feb 18, 2011 3:49 PM
Re: T.H. Asgardson
-
Are you all there?
-
Comment: #8
Posted by: Luis Magno
Fri Feb 18, 2011 5:01 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Miguel Perez
May. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Roland Martin
Roland S. MartinUpdated 20 Jun 2012
Marc Dion
Marc DionUpdated 28 May 2012
Steve Chapman
Steve ChapmanUpdated 27 May 2012

27 Nov 2007 Latino-American History 101: Our Pre-Mayflower Thanksgivings

2 Dec 2008 The Jobs That Americans Didn't Want

10 Aug 2010 Birthright Citizenship or Opportunistic GOP Demagoguery