opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
John Stossel
John Stossel
10 Feb 2016
High-Tech Ted

Politicians tailor their messages to different audiences. Facing New Hampshire's primary, Ted Cruz talked … Read More.

3 Feb 2016
Political Arrogance

After the Iowa caucus results, it looks like Hillary Clinton vs. Marco Rubio in November! They lead the … Read More.

27 Jan 2016
Running on Empty

Cars run on fuel. Politicians run on votes, and they'll do almost anything to get them. That includes … Read More.

Making a Bad Bill Worse


How do you make a dreadfully bad piece of legislation — the nearly $900-billion so-called "stimulus" bill — worse? Simple — add protectionism.

The "Buy American" provision of the stimulus bill, which mandates the use of domestic iron, steel and manufactured goods even if imports are cheaper, makes our trading partners nervous. That created a problem for President Obama: "I think it would be a mistake ... at a time when worldwide trade is declining for us to start sending a message that somehow we're just looking after ourselves and not concerned with world trade," he said (

But some members of his party were elected on protectionist platforms, and they are not about to blow this chance to reward their union and industrial constituencies. What was Obama to do?

He did what old-style politicians always do: tried to have it both ways by resorting to vague rhetoric. He said he'd "see what kind of language we can work on this issue" (

The Senate then added a line saying that the "Buy American" section must be "applied in a manner consistent with U.S. obligations under international agreements" (

So is the bill protectionist or not? It sounds as though our trade agreements must be respected, but as The New York Times noted, "[I]n many cases it [a "Buy American" provision] is not considered a violation of trade treaties." Public Citizen's protectionist website, Eyes on Trade, agrees: Under its trade agreements, the United States has "always been allowed to do most if not all of what is in the stimulus package" (

As long as it remains in the bill, the "Buy American" section will haunt us. Protectionism is poison. Prosperity means having access to the least expensive goods the world has to offer. When we save money buying something cheaper from abroad, we have more money to spend on other things or to invest. Laws that force us to pay more for things cannot make us wealthier.

Protectionist unions and firms say that a "Buy American" policy creates jobs at home.

But that is misleading, because while protectionism does save some American jobs — often temporarily — the policy also destroys jobs at home.

It destroys jobs in two ways. First, when foreigners lose sales here, they have fewer dollars with which to buy American exports or to invest in the U.S. economy. Jobs in the export sector disappear, and the jobs that would have been created through the new investment won't be created.

Second, when foreign nations retaliate against American exporters, even more jobs are destroyed.

"Buy American" is a dishonest slogan because it leads to a loss of American opportunities for prosperity. It is special-interest legislation that is paid for dearly by other Americans. As my first college economics professor, Burton G. Malkiel, wrote in The Wall Street Journal last week, "Beggar-thy-neighbor policies create more beggars and hostile neighbors" (

The alleged "stimulus" bill is a rotten idea to begin with. Government has no resources that it hasn't first taken from someone else. By borrowing $800 billion to pay for pet political projects, government prevents that money from being used to rebuild the economy according to consumer preferences. Bad stimulus drives out good.

Protectionism makes it even worse, and we should know better. In 1929-30, President Herbert Hoover and the U.S. Congress helped turn a depression into the Great Depression by enacting the infamous Smoot-Hawley tariff. Hoover's mere announcement that he would sign the bill pushed the stock market into the tank. Hoover and Congress then made their bad tariff decision worse by approving a "Buy America Act," which required federal projects to use only American supplies. Hoover signed it on his last day in office. Countries the world over retaliated, and by 1932, U.S. exports had fallen 64 percent, aggravating unemployment, which approached 25 percent.

The effects of the "Buy American" provision of the "stimulus" bill may not be as egregious, but who knows?

What we do know is that many of our so-called leaders have learned nothing from history.

John Stossel is co-anchor of ABC News' "20/20" and the author of "Myth, Lies, and Downright Stupidity." To find out more about John Stossel and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at




1 Comments | Post Comment
Without Textile and Furniture Manufacturing Jobs America won't survive!

"Group shifts focus to entrepreneurship"noting that UNCG starting new
programs. I'm quoting "One aimed at undergraduates, and anyone with college
degree!" Look around, the 'fat cats' in government always hire
people to make statements like "We're putting people back to work",
when in essence they're only creating bigger goverment with no stability! It's
now a proven fact, you can get all the degrees you want, but without 'common
sense', 'getting your hands dirty', and actually working in a business from
sweeping the floors to answering the phones (I do mean answering phones when
they ring), you're backing up! It's going to take more than talent! Hard
labor and long hours come to mind. Looking like you just stepped off the
front page of a magazine won't be happening, so get over it!

I've written many articles over the years about the Heartbeat of our
America! Until Textile and Manufacturing jobs are brought back to America
there's absolutely no need for government, let alone bigger government, as
these were the 'working with your hand jobs' that used to be the backbone
and stability of our country.

Let's look at economics, my way! Fast Foods, Donut & Coffee Shops, Bars,
Saloons and many more come to mind (service oriented, not manufacturing
anything), but I'm trying to make a point! Leases/Rents, furnishings, heat,
lights, water, and licenses/permits have to be paid whether you get a
business up and running in 3-5 years or not. Just opening the doors to
public, ordering food or supplies for your new business cost money. After
all, there's only so much you can charge for a cup of coffee, donut,
biscuit, and manicure! This is why the overhead of these type businesses
will never be profitable!

Let's see if I can explain this further! Our forefathers worked long, hard
hours using their hands, horses and crude tools. Raising and pulling cotton
to put clothes on their backs, curtains, and later provide material
coverings for furniture (that we no longer have in America). Using hoes and
mules to provide gardens. Raising cows, hogs and chickens to provide for
their families. The new type American thinks all they have to do is get a
degree so they don't have to get their hands dirty! Well, I hate to burst
your bubble, but that degree is a piece of paper, and if you have acquired
none of the traits, used by your grandparents and great grandparents, you're
useless in America!

The Amish Community should always be proud that they've maintained a world,
filled with the best of everything, and to know that they've done all they
do without destroying our earth! America needs more Amish folks and less Al
Gores and big government!

Comment: #1
Posted by: Shirley deLong
Sun Feb 22, 2009 11:00 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
John Stossel
Feb. `16
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Veronique de RugyUpdated 11 Feb 2016
Matt Towery
Matt ToweryUpdated 11 Feb 2016
Froma Harrop
Froma HarropUpdated 11 Feb 2016

8 Jul 2009 Insurance Is No Answer

12 Mar 2013 Frack to the Future

19 Nov 2014 Control Freaks