Tuesday, May 13, 2008 | 6:14 p.m.

Froma Harrop

Home > Opinion Columns > Froma Harrop
Please contact your local newspaper editor if you want to read Froma Harrop's column in your hometown paper.
Froma Harrop

Recently

  • Obamicans Pile on Clinton at Own Peril
    Many in the Obama camp, having outfoxed the apparently not-so-formidable Clinton machine, can't seem to get the hang of winning gracefully. They feel a need to drive a stake in Hillary Clinton's reputation, then dance. If they were smart, they'd …
  • A Perfect Calm for John McCain
    John McCain has used these weeks of Republican calm to dive into the Democratic lunch pail. This strategy clearly assumes a Barack Obama candidacy. If demographics are destiny — as the political sages keep telling us — Democratic …
  • Cosby Is the Real Prophet, Not Wright
    Jeremiah, you're no Jeremiah. Although Barack Obama's controversial former pastor the Rev. Jeremiah Wright puts himself at the center of a prophetic tradition of the Afro-American church, he's not much of a prophet. The prophet in the Biblical mode …
  • Codependent Addicts: States and Casinos
    Loath to tax the citizenry based on income, many states have increasingly turned to cigarette smokers and gamblers for revenues. Gamblers are often smokers, and both groups tend to be of modest or low income. So after taxing the daylights out of the …

The Change That Can't Be Changed

If you like Froma Harrop, you might enjoy

The Serenity Prayer, written by theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, hangs on countless American walls. I grew up with it. Whatever the reader's religious belief, or lack thereof, the prayer packs a world of comfort in a few simple lines. The most popular version goes:

"God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; courage to change the things I can; and wisdom to know the difference."

Our presidential contenders only occasionally incorporate these teachings into their messages. A sharp dose of reality can be healthy to the public, but candidates who inject it often pay a political price. People don't want to hear that they must adjust to something they don't like. They want the thing changed.

One thing that can't be changed right now is higher gasoline prices. Thus, calls by Republican John McCain and Democrat Hillary Clinton to suspend the federal gas tax over the summer are worse than pandering. They're counterproductive.

The 18.4 cent-a-gallon federal gas tax is a drop in the rising tide of fuel costs, up $1.30 from 18 months ago. Shelving it for a few months is a silly "fix" that distracts from what can be done to bring about a lasting solution — that is, cut oil use and switch to renewable energy sources.

Only Democrat Barack Obama had the fortitude to tell American consumers that the exit from high oil prices is the door leading away from oil. He noted that the tax holiday would save the average consumer a mere $30 and jeopardize funds needed for roads and bridges.

McCain plays teller-of-hard-truths when he informs hurting Rustbelt workers that the loss of many factory jobs cannot be reversed. But he fell short on proposing what can be changed, which is a strengthened social safety net to ensure that no American worker go without health coverage.

He purported to address this matter in his newly unveiled health-care plan.
Its main virtue is the unlinking of health coverage from place of employment. (That makes sense in today's churning labor market, though the same thing could be accomplished by extending the government-run Medicare program to everyone.)

But McCain's "market-based" concept lacks the wisdom to acknowledge what can't be changed — that private insurers will always avoid people with costly medical conditions. McCain's idea of a government-run pool to cover the sick ones turns his plan into another bonanza for the insurance industry. It lets insurers make a pile selling their policies to healthy people, while the taxpayers are stuck with the expensive patients.

On this issue, Clinton is the only leading candidate to show true grit and deliver a hard fact that many don't want to hear: Universal coverage cannot happen unless everyone participates in the system. This means that healthy people who don't feel like buying health coverage have to be dragged in.

The compulsory part of her program was seized on and distorted by her opponents. Obama argued that people don't buy health insurance only because they can't afford it. This ignores that Clinton's plan would have paid for the poor's coverage, and it lets the young and healthy off the hook. Obama's health-plan vision, like McCain's, would end up segregating the sick from the well.

The campaign of 2008 has all been about "change." The great irony is that the change so many middle- and lower-income Americans yearn for is change back to what they once had.

The candidates do well to push for change that can restore this lost sense of security. But today's besieged workers also need the wisdom to know which change can't be changed. That's not a popular political message, to be sure.

To find out more about Froma Harrop, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2008 THE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL CO.

DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.



AddThis Social Bookmark Button RSS Get RSS Feed for Froma Harrop Email updates Email me Froma Harrop updates Comments Comments
Originally Published on Thursday May 01, 2008


Froma Harrop's column is released twice a week.
Editors Picks - Opinion Columns
Is Barack a Team(ster) Player?
David Limbaugh
In Puerto Rico, Rare Vote for 'Presidente'
Miguel Perez
Gas-Tax Holiday a Loser
Debra Saunders
See All
More Froma Harrop
May. `08
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
27 28 29 30 1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
View By Month
About the author Print friendly format Write the author Email This Article to a friend
All newspaper editors want to know what their readers like. If you would like to read this feature in your local newspaper, please do not hesitate to share your enthusiasm with your local newspaper editor.


 

Shop Creators Syndicate

 
Tuesday, May 13, 2008 | 6:14 p.m.
About Creators | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Editor's login | FAQ
Copyright © 2006 Creators.com. All Rights Reserved.
Web Development by JJCO