creators.com opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
Dennis Prager
Dennis Prager
30 Sep 2014
What the Arab World Produces

At least since the early part of the 20th century, aside from oil, the Arab world has produced and exported … Read More.

23 Sep 2014
'Not Islamic'?

President Obama declared in his recent address to the nation that "ISIL is not Islamic." But how does he know?… Read More.

16 Sep 2014
Ted Cruz's Speech to Arab Christians

Last week at the inaugural summit of the organization, In Defense of Christians, founded to help the most … Read More.

Accusation that Voter ID Is Racist Demeans Blacks

Comment

While dining out last week, I periodically looked up at one of the television monitors to see the score of the first game of the NBA finals. As there was no sound on to interrupt diners' conversations, the monitor was in caption mode: One could read rather than hear the words spoken. At the conclusion of the game, an announcer was interviewing a member of the victorious Miami Heat players. I saw from the captions the player saying the words "they isn't."

Closed captions display the words spoken. They don't correct for poor grammar.

All I could think was: How can a grown man in America today say "they isn't" rather than "they aren't"?

First, how is it possible for anyone to graduate an American elementary school, not to mention a high school or, most incredibly, attend college, and leave with an inability to conjugate the verb "to be"?

Second, has anyone — a parent or another relative, a teacher, a friend, a coach — in that player's life ever corrected his grammar?

I assume that the answer to the second question is "No."

And I assume that the answers to both questions are related: The left, which dominates our culture and educational institutions, has too often lowered standards for black Americans. Even worse, it has declared that if you are black, "they isn't" is not only not to be corrected, but many in academia have declared it an acceptable form of English, i.e., Ebonics, or Black English.

It doesn't end.

I saw "they isn't" the same week the Democrats and others on the left virtually unanimously condemned all Republican attempts in state legislatures to pass legislation requiring voters to show a photo ID. The Democrats labeled it a means of "disenfranchising" blacks. Many Democrats compared it to Jim Crow laws.

"Jim Crow, move over — the Wisconsin Republicans have taken your place," charged Wisconsin Democratic State Sen. Bob Jauch, referring to his state's new voter ID law.

It is hard to imagine a more demeaning statement about black America than labeling demands that all voters show a photo ID anti-black.

This is easily demonstrated. Imagine if some Democratic politician had announced that demanding a photo ID at the voting booth was an attempt to keep Jewish Americans from voting. No one would understand what the person was talking about. But why not? Jews vote almost as lopsidedly Democrat as do blacks. So why weren't Jews included in liberal objections to voter ID laws?

We all know the answer. Jews are generally considered intelligent and therefore no one would assume that obtaining a photo ID was demanding too much of even poor Jews (yes, there are poor Jews).

Therefore, one can only infer that the argument that demanding photo ID for voting will disenfranchise many blacks suggests that many blacks lack the capacity to obtain a photo ID.

If that is not a legitimate inference, then only one other inference is possible: The argument is made solely in order to score political points by portraying black Americans as victims of Republican racism. Of course, that argument simply takes us back to the original question: Why does requiring a photo ID to vote prevent blacks from voting?

It is, however, effective. Calling Republicans racist has worked for half a century and will not be abandoned until it is universally recognized as the libel that it is.

What we have in both instances — the poor grammar that too many blacks use and the argument that demanding a photo ID is too hard on blacks — is not Republican racism. What we have are two more examples of the destructive consequences of leftist policies on black America.

It is difficult to overstate the negative impact making lesser demands on individuals, especially members of select groups, has on them. The message is as clear as day: We expect less of you. Why? Because we think less of you.

Do most of those on the left really think less of black Americans?

Given the lack of demands, given the rationalization for poor speech (before the left took over education, both blacks and whites spoke and wrote far better), given the advocacy of lowering standards for blacks from everything from civil service tests to college admissions and given other examples, it is hard not to conclude that many on the left really do think black Americans are not equally capable of excellence (outside of sports and entertainment). It is what George W. Bush called "the soft bigotry of low expectations."

If this is not the case, there are two other explanations.

One is guilt. White liberals are so filled with guilt over historic American maltreatment of blacks that they have somehow concluded that making the same demands of blacks as of all other Americans is somehow unfair.

The other is political opportunism — portray liberals and their policies as the saviors of black Americans. Aside from its constituting cynical exploitation, the problem is that in order to portray oneself as another person's savior, one must portray the other as in need of saving.

Conservative Americans, on the other hand, actually believe there is no difference between black and non-black abilities, and therefore see only harm in depicting a substantial percentage of the black population as essentially incapable of obtaining a photo ID.

Which group has more respect for black Americans? The answer is obvious. And one day, most black Americans will know the real answer to that question. That will be the beginning of the final stage of black liberation, as well as the end of the Democratic Party as we now know it.

Dennis Prager hosts a nationally syndicated radio talk show and is a visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. He is the author of four books, most recently "Happiness Is a Serious Problem" (HarperCollins). His website is www.dennisprager.com.

COPYRIGHT 2011 CREATORS.COM



Comments

4 Comments | Post Comment
Excellent article! and I am a black American conservative.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Talitha McEachin
Wed Apr 25, 2012 1:00 AM
dear sir i cw dean i know it racist to reject a person cause they do not have a picture on a piece of paper or card before law makers could think had only a social security card and birth certificate that is your id i do not know why tx, ca, la ok, az f,l ms, al and the other dixie states your want to follow there good old boy network why are you trying to use your elected office office to abuse authority make law to swing your weight around for political power need to quit makes us look stupid i myself been all 48 and over stop acting out of character all eyes are on you and violence not the key and need to stop killing people cause of what you think is right especially when they surrendered use a positive approach keep focus you are only human mistakes are made keep your fate and stop letting other countries see how acting they do not like doing business with us as it is and also letting them know your next plan keep some thing's to yourself i must end my notes to say let' s us as the media focus on good and not bad all the time and for michael sam's at the end of day he is still a man and stop judging that's his life not yours pray for him later.
Comment: #2
Posted by: cw dean
Tue Sep 2, 2014 8:31 AM
dear sir i cw dean i know it racist to reject a person cause they do not have a picture on a piece of paper or card before law makers could think had only a social security card and birth certificate that is your id i do not know why tx, ca, la ok, az f,l ms, al and the other dixie states your want to follow there good old boy network why are you trying to use your elected office office to abuse authority make law to swing your weight around for political power need to quit makes us look stupid i myself been all 48 and over stop acting out of character all eyes are on you and violence not the key and need to stop killing people cause of what you think is right especially when they surrendered use a positive approach keep focus you are only human mistakes are made keep your fate and stop letting other countries see how acting they do not like doing business with us as it is and also letting them know your next plan keep some thing's to yourself i must end my notes to say let' s us as the media focus on good and not bad all the time and for michael sam's at the end of day he is still a man and stop judging that's his life not yours pray for him later.
Comment: #3
Posted by: cw dean
Tue Sep 2, 2014 8:31 AM
dear sir i cw dean i know it racist to reject a person cause they do not have a picture on a piece of paper or card before law makers could think had only a social security card and birth certificate that is your id i do not know why tx, ca, la ok, az f,l ms, al and the other dixie states your want to follow there good old boy network why are you trying to use your elected office office to abuse authority make law to swing your weight around for political power need to quit makes us look stupid i myself been all 48 and over stop acting out of character all eyes are on you and violence not the key and need to stop killing people cause of what you think is right especially when they surrendered use a positive approach keep focus you are only human mistakes are made keep your fate and stop letting other countries see how acting they do not like doing business with us as it is and also letting them know your next plan keep some thing's to yourself i must end my notes to say let' s us as the media focus on good and not bad all the time and for michael sam's at the end of day he is still a man and stop judging that's his life not yours pray for him later.
Comment: #4
Posted by: cw dean
Tue Sep 2, 2014 8:31 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Dennis Prager
Sep. `14
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Authorís Podcast
Michelle Malkin
Michelle MalkinUpdated 1 Oct 2014
Brent Bozell
Roger Simon
Roger SimonUpdated 1 Oct 2014

1 Nov 2011 Four Legacies of Feminism

5 Oct 2010 A Letter from a Republican to Hispanics

29 Jun 2010 If You Believe America Has Lousy Health Care, Here's Why ...