opinion web
Liberal Opinion Conservative Opinion
David Sirota
David Sirota
25 Sep 2015
Should Companies Have to Pay Taxes?

Reading companies' annual reports to the Securities and Exchange Commission is a reliable cure for insomnia. … Read More.

18 Sep 2015
A Fight Over One of America's Most Important Waterways

Environmental groups and Democratic legislators are pressuring New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo to say that General … Read More.

11 Sep 2015
Prosecution of White Collar Crime Hits 20-Year Low

Just a few years after the financial crisis, a new report tells an important story: Federal prosecution of white-… Read More.

The Last Row of the Plane


A recent flight I took was, like most these days, completely packed. About 100 fellow travelers and I were crammed into a way-too-small coach cabin. But when I stood up for a moment, I discovered we were all making our situation worse.

Looking out over the rows, I saw that almost all aboard had pushed their seats back, invading the space of those behind them. This was bad for everyone. As any flier knows, the benefit of reclining is more than offset by the inconvenience of having a stranger in your lap. And yet, most passengers — including me — had contributed to the problem.

The seat recliner uses the public domain — in this case, space — and we have gotten used to using as much of that domain as we can, not just on planes but everywhere. This is our destructive “me” culture: Anything we want in the public sphere, we take or use, with little regard for the overall ramifications.

A stranger reclines into your lap. Someone in a theater talks through the movie. The guy at the next table yammers so loudly on his cell phone that you can't hear your lunch companion. A passerby litters in the park. In each example, the public domain is trampled and usurped by the "me" culture.

But what happens when this culture affects the really big stuff — like, say, planetary survival? It is a critical question because, according to the new book "Apollo's Fire," that's precisely what's going on.

Written by Congressman Jay Inslee, D-Wash., and Center for American Progress fellow Bracken Hendricks, the book describes how our society's carbon-reliant economy treats the atmosphere in the same counterproductive way as seat-reclining passengers treat the limited space in coach. As a result, while we may enjoy leaving lights on, driving a gas-guzzling SUV or, yes, flying, the carbon emissions we generate from such activities are pushing the planet toward a global warming disaster, rife with floods, droughts and general societal upheaval.

"We look at the air like it is infinite, rather than what it really is — a limited resource," Hendricks told me after a speech in Denver.

The problem revolves around cost. Just like you are assessed no additional fee to lean your airplane chair back and set off a chain reaction of reclining and cabin-wide discomfort, we are assessed no additional fee when we pump carbon dioxide into the air and help wreak planet-wide destruction.

And the results in our "me" culture are predictable. We recline and pollute away — overall consequences be damned.

"Apollo's Fire" offers ways to address the crisis, the first being a cap on greenhouse gas emissions or a tax on carbon. We limit access to or charge fees for using water, land and other natural resources. Why shouldn't polluters have to pay to use the air — the most precious natural resource of all? Equally important, the book explores both public and private investments that could change the way we generate energy in the first place.

Fortunately, the political will to protect the atmosphere is already building. For instance, some forward-thinking energy companies are cutting down their carbon dioxide output in anticipation of a price on carbon. Governors from coal-producing states are acknowledging that carbon emissions need to be cut. Even some major corporate shareholders are pushing their companies to cut back on carbon emissions. They see big profit potential in providing the world with clean energy.

These moves reflect polls that show the public realizes the health of our atmosphere has worth — and needs to be protected. Just like The New York Times recently wrote that many people "feel a brief, murderous urge to strike back" when the airplane chair in front of them reclines, we are beginning to feel similar emotions when a carbon-belching Hummer drives by. That is, we are beginning to feel violated when others harm the planet.

In short, our "me" culture is colliding with our recognition that the Earth is one big confined airplane, and that when it comes to the atmosphere, we are all in that last row — up against a wall, unable to kick back when we are encroached upon. Global warming is showing that our air, like cramped coach space, is actually finite. Let's hope things don't have to get too uncomfortable before we do something about it.

David Sirota is the bestselling author of "Hostile Takeover" (Crown, 2006). He is a senior fellow at the Campaign for America's Future and a board member of the Progressive States Network — both nonpartisan research organizations. His daily blog can be found at To find out more about David Sirota and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at



3 Comments | Post Comment
We have destroyed our democracy and our surroundings by not having "manners."
Miss Manners in an interview:

Cole: Where do you draw that line, though?

Martin: Where do you draw that line, yes. And America has never decided.

Cole: I was just thinking . . . My father's highest accolade about somebody was that he was a gentleman.

Martin: Exactly. But in court societies you'd be a gentleman by birth no matter how you behaved. That's the point about America--you have to behave like a gentleman to be a gentleman. And surely that is a superior system.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Roger Erickson
Fri Dec 7, 2007 8:31 AM
While any effort on global warming is laudible, you shouldn't trust Inslee. His interest is self serving. He wants to be governor of Washinton State or Energy Secretary in the next Democratic administration. He is willing to support the war in Iraq toward that end and support the DLC's anti-impeachment strategy.
He uses energy to change the subject and promote his career.
I have seen him lie to his constituents and obfuscate. It's sad but true. He's gone over to the dark side.
He needs to be replaced.
Comment: #2
Posted by: Carol Davidek-Waller
Fri Dec 7, 2007 6:18 PM
How about all the rich and super-rich setting examples for the rest of the country? I mean, with their private jets and mega-mansions, they use more of our resources than the average citizen does who just uses them to stay warm and get himself/herself back and forth to work and to the grocery store! Why is Gore beating the drum for greening of the planet, when his utility bills hover in the area of $2,000/month? For some of us, that would cover a whole year's worth of home energy consumption!
I'm tired of the famous lecturing to the average Americans about energy conservation, when they turn around and use up more of the energy than probably 100 average citizens do!
Comment: #3
Posted by: judy pilarski
Sun Dec 9, 2007 9:59 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
David Sirota
Sep. `15
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
30 31 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 1 2 3
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Lawrence Kudlow
Lawrence KudlowUpdated 13 Feb 2016
Mark Shields
Mark ShieldsUpdated 13 Feb 2016
diane dimond
Diane DimondUpdated 13 Feb 2016

21 May 2010 Laying Bare the Myth of "The Left"

25 Apr 2013 A Cronkite Moment for the Blowback Era

6 Aug 2010 The Stadium-Mob Mentality