Is 'Based Off' Off Base? Q. When did "based on" morph into "based off"? When I was teaching, I heard my students say it a lot, e.g., "This movie was based off the book." I just saw it in print for the first time: "Two toys based off Walt Disney's hit animated film..." Ugh. …Read more. Compound Fracture of the Left Participle You're the sentence doctor! Diagnose the ailment in each of these sentences, and then prescribe a rewrite to repair the problem. Just to make things interesting, one sentence is completely healthy. 1. The fact that experts disagree about the reasons …Read more. Was Snidely a 'Wrapper'? What did the dastardly villain Snidely Whiplash say when Dudley Do-Right tied him up with Reynolds Wrap? "Curses! Foiled again!" But is there a linguistic connection between the "foil" that means "a thin sheet of metal" and the "foil" that means "to …Read more. Subba, Subba 'Few'! Q. What do you think of the following? "Subba's is one of the only Nepalese restaurants in the city." I think it should be "one of the few Nepalese restaurants in the city." — Nick Kyriazi, Pittsburgh A. Your question piqued my curiosity …Read more.more articles
Don't Forsake Meaning of 'Namesake'
First, some fun: A reader recently e-mailed me this puzzler, and I can't resist sharing it with you:
There is something unusual about these eight words. See whether you can figure it out: assess, banana, dresser, grammar, potato, revive, uneven, voodoo. The answer is at the end of the column. No peeking, but there's a clue lurking below.
— namesake — A few months ago, I wrote about the misuse of "ancestor" to mean "descendent." Now Ralph Sims of Baton Rouge, La., reports that "namesake" is being used in a similar way — to indicate the person or entity whose name is given to another, rather than the person or entity that has been named for another.
He quotes this passage from a recent magazine article: "Peter Post, director of the Emily Post Institute and great-grandson of its legendary namesake."
I was all set to give this breach of linguistic etiquette a scolding worthy of Emily Post, until I discovered that Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary accepts this REVERSAL. It defines "namesake" as "one that has the same name as another; esp. one who is named after another or for whom another is named." Those last five words mean that Emily Post could indeed be the namesake of the Emily Post institute.
All the other name-brand dictionaries I consulted limit the meaning of "namesake" to the person or entity named for another.
— reverend — Another restriction that appears to be easing is the prohibition on using "reverend" as a noun. Traditionally, "reverend" has been regarded exclusively as an adjective, meaning "revered, honorable" as in "the Reverend Kenneth Morris."
Using "Reverend Morris" or "the reverend" has long been considered a "clerical" error. But English speakers have been using "reverend" as a noun since the 1600s, and this practice has become more common in recent decades.
Kenneth Morris, by the way, was the minister of the Episcopal church I attended as a boy. He would have wanted me to remind you that "Episcopalian" is a noun and never an adjective. So it's "Episcopal minister," not "Episcopalian minister."
Puzzler answer: If you take the first letter of each word, place it at the end of the word and read the word backward, it will be the same word.
Rob Kyff, a teacher and writer in West Hartford, Conn., invites your language sightings. Send your reports of misuse and abuse, as well as examples of good writing, via e-mail to Wordguy@aol.com or by regular mail to Rob Kyff, Creators Syndicate, 5777 W. Century Blvd., Suite 700, Los Angeles, CA 90045. To find out more about Rob Kyff and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.
COPYRIGHT 2007 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.