creators home
creators.com lifestyle web

Recently

Don't Get All Up in My Grill! If you opened your window last weekend, you could hear it: homeowners across this great country walked out into their backyards, pulled the grill covers off their gas grills after a long hard winter, dusted them off, opened the lid, and cursed, …Read more. Hair Today In the news last week, we learned that as a high school student, Mitt Romney held down another boy in school with long hair and gave him a forced haircut. I am not weighing in on the story, because I have a rule. I never discuss politics in my …Read more. Fighting Against Sensorship – in the Bathroom When our great, great grandparents wanted to find water, they got themselves a forked stick, walked all over their property with that stick stuck out in front of them, and when the stick pointed itself at the ground, they'd dig a well. It wasn't …Read more. Shape Up or Ship Out For the past year or so, I've been making a concerted effort to not get in worse shape. Some people make resolutions to actually get in better shape, but mine was more simple and straightforward — I'd like to simply maintain my present …Read more.
more articles

It's All in the Presentation …

Share Comment

Like other children across the country, my kids are being taught practical skills in school. They still learn reading, writing and arithmetic, but these days, they're also learning a lot of things that are supposed to come in handy once they enter the business world.

A lot of these newfound skills are just setting them up for disappointment once they get real jobs. In school, they give speeches on every topic you can think of, something that very, very few adults get to do, unless they're running for office, in which case no one is listening. They produce videos to show to classmates, even though in real life, adults never get to be producers of videos. (Do you know any? Didn't think so.) They have a project where they design and build a car. The way things are going, this skill will only really be useful for their futures if they also learn Japanese.

One of the big things they're all learning is PowerPoint presentations. For those of you out there who have never seen a PowerPoint presentation, count yourself lucky. A PowerPoint presentation usually involves one person at the front of a room, holding a clicker, while 20 to 30 other people sit in chairs and desperately wish they were dead. Often, they turn out the lights during PowerPoint presentations so that the presenter doesn't have to acknowledge how many people are tearing up in frustration.

Last month, my 13-year-old daughters started another push in their relentless campaign to convince us to make a tough choice: Either get them cell phones or run off without providing a forwarding address. They've tried various methods, none of them very effective. At times, they've gotten angry, other times, tried slamming doors, and once or twice, used the silent treatment. This last one drives my wife crazy, but I'm immune. As a man, I often have to actually be told that I'm getting the silent treatment. To me, it just seems like peace and quiet.

Last month, one of the girls walked into the kitchen to announce, in a calm voice, that she'd like to make a presentation to us in the living room.

We hadn't heard this one before, and were suspicious.

We walked into the living room to find the computer set up facing the couch. In a professional manner, our daughter asked us to take our seats, and started the presentation, entitled "Why I Should Get a Cell Phone."

The first few slides provided details of her current "Sad Life" without a cell phone, and asked, rhetorically, how this might be changed. We could already guess the answer.

There was a full section on how responsible she was. She had not, for instance, lost any of her other electronic items. She fed her hamster every day — up until the day he died. (To be fair, that was only two weeks.) She also had not broken her digital camera (that was her friend's fault).

A cell phone, the presentation promised, would also be important to her babysitting clients, many of whom look up to her. There was an entire section on how good her grades were. She made a citation to a report card where she was deemed "hardworking" by a teacher. Also of note: Not one detention. Ever.

Another slide, complete with graphics, was devoted to the injustice that her older brother had gotten a cell phone, despite the fact that he is widely considered to be lazy and unworthy of such a responsibility. Also in the negative but persuasive category, a list of classmates who were clearly considered by their peers to be immature but already had cell phones.

A cell phone would benefit us, as parents. We were treated to a slide citing cell phone advertisements that promised to bring families together. Also important: A cell phone would give us a privilege we could take away as a punishment should she misbehave.

The presentation ended with a smiley face, and a "Thank you for your time!" slide, just like the ones where they're trying to sell you a timeshare.

My wife and I thanked her for the professional presentation, and said it gave us a lot to think about. We shook hands, and I told her I'd have to discuss it with my business partner and we'd get back to her when we had an answer.

Which, as any businessperson knows, means thanks, but no thanks.

To find out more about Peter McKay, please visit www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2009 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.


Comments

5 Comments | Post Comment
I think a rebuttal would be most appropriate in this situation. I didn't get a cell phone until I was almost 26. Now-a-days I think a cell phone when children learn to drive is appropriate so they can call in case of an emergency. You could always give your girls a PowerPoint Presentation of your own with annoying bulleted lists, graphics, and sounds. Our Reasons 13 Year Olds Should NOT Have A Cell Phone: there's the cost of adding them to the plan, then the fact that if they go over on minutes- it is very expensive, the fact that not all 13 year olds have one nor do they actually need one, also there's the fact that during school hours they are not allowed to have cell phones at school so it's pointless since after school they are home or at a friend's house where there is a land line for their use. Typically if they are off somewhere they cannot drive to their destination but an adult, who probably has a cell phone, will be driving them. Your son probably has one because he drives a car and it is a safety procaution. All of the late 20-somethings and older can tell your girls that we all did just fine in middle and high schools without a cell phone and they will too.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Amber C
Tue Jun 2, 2009 5:02 AM
Your daughter sounds like a very responsible girl. If you start her out with a pre-paid phone, she can learn that if she runs out of minutes she will have to wait until her allowance to refill her card, and she will learn responsibility of control. If she uses her minutes early, then she has to wait until she has money to buy more. I really like your humor. You take every day things that we all can relate to and turn them into something funny. I always look forward to reading your humor. Keep up the great work. As long as there are people in this world, there is humor to write about.
Comment: #2
Posted by: Michele A
Tue Jun 2, 2009 4:23 PM
I really don't see the point in having a cell phone until a person has a car or moves out on there own. I'm 21, didn't get my own until I was 18. Got a car when I was 16, and borrowed my parents cell phone when I left the house. I could see the point of getting them a pre-paid phone for emergencies, or when they're at the mall, Wal-Mart other places like that. The first person to give their kid a cell-phone for everyday use should be shot. Maybe I went too far, but you get the picture.

Thanks for the great articles. I'm not sure how I could get through college without them.
Comment: #3
Posted by: Matt
Wed Jun 3, 2009 4:51 AM
Kudos to your daughter for having intuitively grasped the sole effective use of PowerPoint-type presentations: to persuade people to do what you want. They are much better at obfuscating details and presenting sales slogans than they are at informing people about complex subjects.

I hope that you will be sufficiently immune to these cheap sales tactics so that you'll at least hold out for her future offers, such as "I have already saved up enough cash to buy the phone and pay for the first year's operation, and as you can see from my spreadsheet, I can reasonably expect to earn enough income to continue paying for it indefinitely."

Comment: #4
Posted by: once
Mon Jun 8, 2009 2:45 PM
I wonder: is "Michelle A", who wrote such a flattering and cell-phone-supportive message, actually your daughter?
Comment: #5
Posted by: once
Mon Jun 8, 2009 2:47 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
Other similar columns
W. Bruce Cameron
W. Bruce Cameron
by W. Bruce Cameron
Dr. Rallie McAllister
Your Health
by Dr. Rallie McAllister
Holiday Mathis
Horoscopes by Holiday
by Holiday Mathis
More
Peter McKay
May. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month