creators home
creators.com lifestyle web

Recently

Held Hostage by Depression Dear Annie: My roommate, "Michelle," is suffering from depression. Six months ago, she suddenly lost interest in going out with friends and would cry for no reason. She began calling in sick so many times that she was fired. She cashed out …Read more. Hands Are Tied when a Messed-Up Child Is a Legal Adult Dear Annie: My 20-year-old nephew has been a troubled youth, despite all the attempts of his family to help him, including counseling and rehab. When he was 18, he became involved with a messed-up 14-year-old girl who used drugs, alcohol and sex to …Read more. Damaging Favoritism Amid Broken Boundaries Dear Annie: I have two daughters, ages 5 and 2. My in-laws favor the older girl. They buy her more presents, give her more money and pay way more attention to her than to her sister. They almost seem obsessed with her. As soon as she walks in the …Read more. Ex Con on the Straight and Narrow Canned Dear Annie: After eight years at my job, I was let go. I have a felony record. The CEO who knew of my background retired last year. He felt I had proved myself and had no problem with me. When he retired, we got an interim CEO. I told him about my …Read more.
more articles

Annie's Mailbox®, March 16

Share Comment

Dear Annie: I'm 18 years old and still live with my family. A few months ago, my uncle moved in with us. He comes home drunk all the time. I can smell the liquor on him, and I hate it. I make sure to be in my bedroom before he walks in the front door, which often means I'm upstairs by 6 p.m.

I want nothing to do with him when he is drunk. He tries to hold my baby brother, but it makes the baby cry, so I have told my uncle to stay away. I want to tell him how I feel, but I'm not sure how. When my mother told him he's not welcome in the house when he's been drinking, he hit her.

What should I do? Should I ask my grandma to kick him out, or should I move into my own place? — Niece of a Drunk

Dear Niece: If your uncle is physically abusive, he should not be living with you. By all means, talk to your grandmother and your mother. If possible, talk to your father, as well. Most likely, your mother believes she is helping your uncle, who obviously has a problem, but allowing him to terrorize you is not the way to do it.

Suggest that she contact Al-Anon (al-anon.alateen.org) at 1-888-4-AL-ANON (1-800-425-2666). If your uncle hits anyone again, call the police. And if you cannot change the situation, we urge you to move out as soon as possible.

Dear Annie: I recently began volunteering to tutor someone in the community, and I love it. However, at yesterday's session, my student gave me an envelope that contained a gift card for a fairly large amount of money.

I had previously told this student that I cannot be paid because it is volunteering, and I do not want payment. But when he handed me the envelope, it seemed awkward to refuse it. In his culture, that would be considered rude.

He told me it was a gift between friends, but I feel so bad and dishonest about accepting it that I am extremely uncomfortable.

Since he cannot return the gift card, is it acceptable for me to reciprocate at some point with a gift of equal value? I cannot conscientiously log the time with him as volunteer hours with this weighing on my mind. — Sick About It

Dear Sick: Do you have a supervisor who runs the tutoring program? If so, ask how you should handle the gift card. You might also consider using it for tutoring supplies — paper, pencils, books, etc. Under no circumstances should you get into a gift-reciprocation program, which not only might escalate into something expensive, but could give the impression that your relationship is something other than student and teacher.

Dear Annie: I would like to respond to "Louisville Lass," who complained about overindulgence by grandparents at Christmas. I faced this situation the first year after going through a divorce. The kids spent Christmas with both sets of families and came home loaded down with gifts.

I decided to write a list of big items the children wanted, and each parent and set of grandparents would get to pick one. This way nobody would feel they needed to compete with anyone else. It worked beautifully and was so appreciated by everyone that to this day, my girls do the same thing with their children. I understand the appeal of giving to a college fund, but as a grandparent now, I would really miss seeing the joy on my grandchildren's faces when they open my presents.

And if that's too much materialism, perhaps they could work alongside their grandchildren in a charitable situation, thereby instilling in them the value of helping their community. I'd bet the children would remember this long after they forgot what presents they received. — Jeannie

Annie's Mailbox is written by Kathy Mitchell and Marcy Sugar, longtime editors of the Ann Landers column. Please e-mail your questions to anniesmailbox@comcast.net, or write to: Annie's Mailbox, c/o Creators Syndicate, 5777 W. Century Blvd., Ste. 700, Los Angeles, CA 90045. To find out more about Annie's Mailbox and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2010 CREATORS.COM


Comments

8 Comments | Post Comment
LW1 --At the age of 18 lw should have called the law when drunk uncle hit mom. LW2-- Being this is a volunteer tutor job who cares that it would be rude in his culture to return the *gift*? Any returned gift in any culture should be considered rude. However he was made aware of the situation ( I am assuming) He is aware of the volunteer tutoring. Give it back, if he's insulted then he can get over himself. LW3---I think it's insulting to give a list to the grandparents and the father and expect them to get only 1 big gift. Why is she the one to decide what a big gift is? To some people it could be $50 and to others a big gift is $200.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Cathy
Mon Mar 15, 2010 9:25 PM
I do not think the tutor should return the gift. I think "Cathy" is way off base in suggesting this. If she is this uncomfortable about accepting the gift, why not give it to the organization through which she is doing the tutoring and tell the student that she is doing this. It is probably a non-profit organization and could use the gift. It also gives the student the idea that gifts should be given to the organization, not the tutor. Teachers have always been given gifts at holidays or at the end of the year. This is not unusual.
Comment: #2
Posted by: Connie Tyler
Mon Mar 15, 2010 9:57 PM
LW2: When someone offers me a gift, I accept it, say "Thank you" and generally do not mention it again. Don't worry about reciprocating. There are only a few exceptions to this and this situation doesn't strike me as one of them. To refuse a gift is rude in pretty much any culture or situation. A person wouldn't voluntarily offer you something if he didn't want you to have it. It's good that you're worried about the appearance of impropriety, but I would just stick the gift card in my pocket and not mention it again. Don't complicate the situation.
Comment: #3
Posted by: Matt
Mon Mar 15, 2010 11:18 PM
I have to disagree with Comments 1 & 2 in regard to gifts.

LW2 said the the gift card was was for a "fairly large" amount. While ordinary gifts might fit into the accept-thank-and-never-mention-again mode, this recipient is in a very special relationship, that of teacher (automatic authority figure) to student (automatic subordinate figure). It is always inappropriate, and even dangerous, for a teacher to accept anything other than a social "token" gift, from a subordinate figure or for the teacher to personally gift a student for anything other than approved awards, preferably from the governing organization.

Token gifts do not include anything expensive and should NEVER be accepted in a one-on-one relationship, as exists here. Even what may be acceptable for a classroom teacher from her students, is not acceptable for a tutor. It is quite likely that the teacher's employing organization already has a "no gifts" policy in place, which applies both ways. Awards may be publically presented from authority to subordinate for goals achieved, but never because one likes the other.

My advice to LW2 is that he or she should have thanked the student very graciously for the thought, then refused the card, if only on the grounds that LW2's employer forbids accepting gifts of any sort from students (or their parents!). That is one of the benefits of having an employer -- one can always blame them for such things. This is NOT rude: It is called maintaining the proper distance between student and authority figure.

Even now, if at all possible, the card should be returned with the above excuse, but under no circumstances should the teacher use the card for any purpose, nor should LW2 accept a gift from anyone under her teaching authority again.

It's too bad if the student can't return the card or use it for someone else, but the gift was highly inappropriate under any circumstances and should never have been accepted.

Comment: #4
Posted by: Sue in La
Tue Mar 16, 2010 1:57 AM
I have a better suggestion than that offered by LW3 whose children received too many gifts following her divorce. Instead of writing down lists of "big" items the children WANT, how about sending thoughtful notes to the families involved asking them to donate any gift funds to local charities in the childrens' names. Gift giving in today's society has gotten entirely out of hand. People have forgotten what it means to give and to receive a gift. Once upon a time, a gift giver selected a personal item to give a recipient because s/he wanted that person to have the item. Conversely, recipients cherished gifts given to them because they knew what it meant to the giver to present them with a gift. Nowadays, people provide lists of items they want to givers and when they don't receive those items, they callously re-gift the unwanted items or take them back to the store for exchange. The entire process of giving and getting gifts has become perverted by greed and a sense of entitlement. How sad. I gave up exchanging gifts for holidays years ago and have informed all of my family members that I won't be giving gifts (nor do I wish to receive them) for any holidays or family events. That was the best decision I ever made and I have no regrets whatsoever.
Comment: #5
Posted by: Chris
Tue Mar 16, 2010 4:13 AM
When my kids were small we had the same problem as LW3. We solved the problem without causing any rifts in the family. I allowed the family to buy whatever they wanted for my kids. The kids had a lot of gifts on their B-days & Christmas. They thanked everyone for the gifts. When we got home we would decide what they could part with (some years were harder than others) then we would take the donations to the local homeless shelter and foster facility. My kids grew up knowing they were privilged to have family who loved them & they got to experience the fulfillment that comes with helping others.
Comment: #6
Posted by: Nance
Tue Mar 16, 2010 10:03 AM
Re: Nance
You made them give up their brand new gifts?? Hmmm...if so, that's pretty harsh. I bet they tell that story to their own kids: "you won't believe what grandma made us do..." I think what would be better is to go through their older toys and give those instead to make room for the new ones.
Comment: #7
Posted by: Renee
Wed Mar 17, 2010 3:07 PM
LW1 Are you still in high school? Are you still dependent on the support of your family (lowpaying parttime job or no job)? If yes to either or both questions, talk to the parents of a friend to see if they will let you move in for a few months if you have to. Let them know about uncle and assure them you will become selfsupporting as soon as you finish school. Why? Because if you call the authorities the next time uncle hits someone, or when you talk to mom and grandma about him, there is a chance they will refuse to see it and you will need somewhere to go either temporarily until things cool down or until the end of high school. Or if your parents are not together (father was not mentioned in letter) maybe you could stay with him. If you can't find a friend with sympathetic parents or get help from dad, go to your school guidence counselor. He/she might know of some resources to help you. You need to be aware however, that if the guidence counselor decides your little brother is in danger, he/she will be obligated to call CPS about the situation. The Annies had good advice about moving out, but needed to give you some advice as to how, since most 18 year olds are in their senior year of high school and have few resources to just move out without family support.
Comment: #8
Posted by: Elizabeth
Wed Mar 17, 2010 10:21 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
Other similar columns
Amy Alkon
The Advice Goddess
by Amy Alkon
Margo Howard
Dear Margo®
by Margo Howard
Ann Landers
Classic Ann Landers
by Ann Landers
More
Kathy Mitchell and Marcy Sugar
Feb. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 31 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 1 2 3
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month