Is it a Good Idea to Borrow in Order to Buy Stocks? by Carrie Schwab Pomerantz on Creators.com

Recently

Can You Collect Both a Public Pension and Social Security? Dear Carrie: I'm 69, worked 23-plus years in the private sector and I am still working in the public sector and receiving monthly Social Security payments. When I retire and start receiving public employee's retirement payments, there's supposed to …Read more. Love and Money: Can You Overcome Your Financial Differences? Dear Carrie: My husband and I have been married for less than a year. He comes from a moderately wealthy family and my family was always scrimping for every penny. Ironically, I'm now earning more than he is, but he's still ready to spend. How do we …Read more. Retiring Early: What's the Best Plan for a Too-Small Nest Egg? Dear Carrie: I only have about $21,000 saved and I am headed into a way-too-early retirement. Should I be investing aggressively to make up for lost time? —A Reader Dear Reader: In the financial world, we often talk about the importance of …Read more. Can You Start Investing With a Small Amount of Money? Dear Carrie: Please help. I don't have a clue as to how to invest my small amount of money. Also, I don't understand what people mean by "long term" or "short term" in actual years. —A Reader Dear Reader: When you're just …Read more.

Is it a Good Idea to Borrow in Order to Buy Stocks?

Dear Carrie: I'm a 43-year-old male who bought a $300K home six years ago and have it paid off completely. With interest rates so low, I'm wondering about taking out a mortgage and putting the money into the stock market where I'm more likely to get a higher return. Is this the right idea? — A Reader

Dear Reader: You pose an interesting question: leveraging your house to buy stocks. To help you make a decision, let's take a look at the potential benefit but also think about the risks.

The investment rationale is pretty straightforward. You have an asset that allows you to borrow cheaply. Current 30-year fixed-rate mortgages are right around 5 percent, and the interest is tax deductible. Your effective, after-tax interest rate will depend on your tax bracket, but I'd guess it would be around 3 percent to 4 percent. So, the practical question is this: Can you earn more than that in the stock market?

The answer isn't clear. Yes, stocks have historically returned around 8 percent, and many investment gurus have reduced expectations to closer to 7 percent. So if you can borrow at an effective cost of 3.5 percent and earn an average of 7 percent, it would work in your favor.

But that's looking at this decision purely from a return perspective. And as an investor, you must look at every investment decision from the potential downside as well. What are you risking if you move ahead?

When you borrow in order to invest, you're taking on risk. You would have mortgage payments to maintain, which should be fine as long as you are confident about your income. But looking at some worst-case scenarios, what if you lose your job? Or the value of your home falls? Or the stock market takes another dive? A combination of these events could put you into a very bad situation.

Now these scenarios may seem unlikely, but before you move ahead, ask yourself the following questions:

— Am I prepared for emergencies? Before even considering taking on a mortgage to buy stocks, make sure you have a comfortable emergency fund: at least three to six months of living expenses.

Be sure to include the amount of your mortgage. Even a year's worth of expenses in liquid assets wouldn't be overdoing it.

— How secure is the value of my house? Many real estate markets may have hit bottom, but if you feel the equity in your house is on dangerous ground, borrowing to invest is probably not prudent.

— How secure is my income stream? A mortgage is a long-term commitment, so before you borrow against your home, you'll have to be confident about your job security. The more comfortable you are about your income, the more comfortable you could feel about moving ahead.

— Am I preparing for retirement? Finally, have you been diligent about saving for retirement? Retirement should be at the top of your priority list, so make sure that taking on a mortgage wouldn't interfere with your ability to contribute fully to your retirement funds.

I realize the objections I've raised may seem extreme, but in the last year we have seen millions of people lose their jobs at the same time that they have lost their homes. Of course, investing is always about the balance between risk and reward. And if you are confident that you can afford a mortgage, your proposal could work to your benefit. Just be sure you fully understand the risks. Best of luck.

Carrie Schwab-Pomerantz, CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER (tm) is president of the Charles Schwab Foundation and author of "It Pays to Talk." You can e-mail Carrie at askcarrie@schwab.com. This column is no substitute for an individualized recommendation, tax or personalized investment advice. To find out more about Carrie Schwab-Pomerantz and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.