creators home
creators.com lifestyle web

Recently

What's Best for Mom in a Mom-and-Pop Business? Q: My wife and I are in our 30s. We're partners in a business that nets us about $80,000 per year. What's the best way to report our income on our tax returns to maximize our Social Security benefits? A: Even though you're asking about your future …Read more. Bleeding Hearts and Bootstraps Q: I was surprised by the woman who wrote to you and said that people living on a small amount of Social Security were just lazy. Let me share my story to help this callous woman understand why people like me don't get very much from Social Security.…Read more. Don't Base Critical Decisions on Prophets of Doom Q: I'm about to turn 66. I want to put off starting my Social Security until age 70 because if I do, I'll get an extra $600 or so per month in a delayed retirement bonus added to by Social Security checks. But my husband said I should take my Social …Read more. Geezers and Floozies Q: I'm part of a group of old geezers who gets together every week at the local coffee place. Social Security is a frequent topic of conversation. At our last meeting, the subject of benefits for divorcees came up. One of our geezers was married to …Read more.
more articles

Illegal Immigrants Seldom Receive Social Security

Share Comment

Q: I just heard from a reliable source on the radio that illegal immigrants are ripping off American taxpayers by collecting Social Security benefits. No wonder this country and the Social Security system are in such trouble. Do you have any information about how much money the U.S. pays these illegal workers?

A: How about “zero.”

I could change the title of this column to “Debunking Social Security Myths' and I'd have enough source material to fill up my allotted space in the newspaper for the next 10 years!

And the undocumented workers are ripping off Social Security myth would be one of the first columns I would write.

There are no undocumented workers in this country collecting U.S. Social Security benefits and ripping off the taxpayers. So Iím afraid your ěreliable source on the radioî is probably just another xenophobe spreading hatred and misinformation to boost ratings!

In fact, Social Security Administration actuaries point out that undocumented workers have just the opposite impact on the programís finances. They pump millions of dollars annually into Social Security trust funds without ever collecting a nickel in Social Security benefits.

(Please bear in mind that the actuaries are not saying illegal immigration is a good thing for the country. But they are saying it has a positive impact on the financial status of Social Security.)

And I have a personal story that illustrates this phenomenon.

Several years ago while I was still working for the Social Security Administration, I was giving a speech to a large group of aerospace workers in the San Diego area.

After I was done talking, one employee came up to me. He said he wanted to talk about his father. He explained that his dad had come into this country illegally from Mexico about 40 years ago. Somehow back then he had obtained an illegal Social Security card. He had been using that card and number at various jobs over that past four decades. His dad was now in his 70s and was finding it difficult to continue working. But he did not want to risk going into a government office to try to get help. He asked if there was any way his father could collect Social Security.

And the answer was no! As long as he was in this country illegally, he would never be eligible for Social Security benefits.

Sorry pal, but ripping off the Social Security system is one social ill you canít blame on undocumented workers.

Q: I have heard we are sending millions of dollars a month in Social Security benefits overseas. How can we put a stop to sending our hard-earned money to these foreign thieves?

A: So I guess my former neighbor is a thief, huh? He's a guy born and raised in the U.S. He worked hard all his life for a well-known American corporation. He retired a while back and gets a nice pension from them and a nice Social Security retirement check from the government. About a year ago, he and his wife decided to fulfill a lifelong dream and they moved to Italy, not far from Florence. Along with his pension, his Social Security check is sent their every month. What a thief, huh?

My point is, almost all of the about 350,000 Social Security checks sent overseas every month are going to U.S. citizens now living abroad. A small number go to non-citizens, but these are folks who worked for U.S. companies and paid U.S. Social Security taxes.

To find out more about Tom Margenau and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2008 CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.


Comments

3 Comments | Post Comment
QUOTE:There are no undocumented workers in this country collecting U.S. Social Security benefits and ripping off the taxpayers. So Iím afraid your ěreliable source on the radioî is probably just another xenophobe spreading hatred and misinformation to boost ratings!UNQUOTE
Well, aren't you the asinine mudslinger. I see that you belong to the "church" of "If you criticize illegal aliens and want our immigration laws enforced, you must be a xenophobe". It's aiders & abettors like you that have cause the problem of 20 million illegla aliens that are costing American taxpayers over $100 billion per year on health care and other services, including education, law enforcement costs, and housing. – U.S. Congressman Dean Heller-Jan. 2008.
BTW, where is your source and data that supports you blanket statement that no illegal aliens receive any social security benefits?
Comment: #1
Posted by: zeezil
Wed Sep 3, 2008 5:07 AM
QUOTE: In fact, Social Security Administration actuaries point out that undocumented workers have just the opposite impact on the programís finances. They pump millions of dollars annually into Social Security trust funds without ever collecting a nickel in Social Security benefits. UNQUOTE
Yeah, boy...I'm just crying a river over this. The FEW illegal aliens that are actually paying into SS (using stolen or fraudlent SS numbers) aren't going to get a slush fund out of it. I can hear the liberals wailing and the illegal alien huggers gnashing their teeth over this. Perhaps, this "unclaimed?" amount should be garnished and sent back to every American citizen taxpayer that has been ripped off by being forced to pay for illegal aliens education, health care, social and welfare programs and law enforcement & criminal justice system expenses.
Comment: #2
Posted by: zeezil
Wed Sep 3, 2008 5:13 AM
You wrote: "My point is, almost all of the about 350,000 Social Security checks sent overseas every month are going to U.S. citizens now living abroad. A small number go to non-citizens," The implication is that a non-citizen living abroad can collect social security, but, according to what you wrote, a non citizen (immigrant alien) living in this country can't . Does that mean that the immigrant alien, who contributed to social security here, can start collecting if he goes back home?


Comment: #3
Posted by: Jerome Kurshan
Sat Sep 6, 2008 5:10 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Tom Margenau
Feb. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 31 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 1 2 3
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month