creators home
creators.com lifestyle web

Recently

Maybe the Cougar Doesn't Fit, but She Might Still Be Delusional One fact has gotten lost in all the give-and-take between If the Cougar Fits, me and you. And that fact is that if she dates these guys who are 20-plus years younger than her, she's going to keep it a secret from her kids, the oldest of whom is 17. …Read more. My Ears Are Still Burning The fallout continues over the column about Diane, whose firefighter husband left her for a paramedic who worked at his firehouse. She wondered if there are more women whose husbands had left them for female firefighters and paramedics. "The …Read more. My Ears Are Burning The recent column about Diane, whose firefighter husband left her for a paramedic who worked at his firehouse, touched off, well, a firestorm. This is what enflamed everyone: "I wonder if there are more women who've lost their husbands to …Read more. Who Needs a Degree When You've Got Love? We recently heard from Not My Son-In-Law. She was the mother who was upset because her 32-year-old daughter was about to make "a terrible mistake." The very successful, never-married daughter was dating a 45-year-old widower who had a …Read more.
more articles

A Band-Aid, Not a Cure

Share Comment

"Torn" wrote in several years ago asking for advice. She'd been married for seven years and had a two-year-old and another on the way. She said her family had a very hard year. Both she and her husband changed jobs, and they also moved.

"The stress," she wrote, "has been enormous."

Torn said she'd "come to terms" with the fact that her husband was "verbally abusive" when he was under stress. When he calmed down, he apologized.

The weekdays were fine, but the weekends were horrible. "The verbal harangues start on Saturday morning."

As a short-term solution, Torn said she decided to leave the house on Saturday mornings. But long term, she didn't know what to do.

"I can see myself divorcing when the kids are grown. Part of me says, why not now? I can't tolerate the way things are. And if I stay with him, I'm afraid I'll lose my inner strength.

"On the other hand, I like him during the week. And there're the children to consider. And I need to know I gave the marriage my best shot. I also know moves are hard, and if I left now, I'd never know if the move caused all this."

I advised Torn to make a weekend plan with her husband every Friday night, including alone time for each of them. I told her to make a list of triggers that set him off so she could avoid them and he could deal with them without losing control. I suggested having a safe word to use when things started to heat up.

"Working through a difficult situation like this can only increase your inner strength," I wrote.

Torn wrote in six weeks later to say that the weekends were getting better. She was using the word halt as a signal to herself when things looked like they could get out of control.

"Now that I have a word, I don't need to be emotional to communicate. This is the end for me so I stay calmer. He's even started using halt to mean, 'We need to stop talking or I'm going to lose it.

"I really liked your assertion that working through this would make me stronger. It helped change my mindset from 'This is weakening me; I'm injuring myself by staying' to 'I'm a strong person; I'm working through this.' That helped my self- esteem tremendously.

"While I doubt that this is the end of our troubles, it certainly has at least bought us respite."

Torn is back to say, "Some of the stuff worked — planning the weekend ahead of time was good; the idea of having a word worked for a short while; each of us having alone time was good, but you fell into the same trap most people do — me trying to fix him by suggesting that I avoid his triggers and find a way to stop his behavior before it escalates. That's like asking the wife of an alcoholic to find ways to stop him from drinking. It's giving responsibility to the wrong person."

In any case, Torn says those things were just Band-Aids, and the abuse got worse.

In the next column, we have an update from Torn. . .

Have you and your partner run out of things to talk about? What do you do? Send your tale, along with your questions, problems and rants to cheryllavinrapp@gmail.com. To find out more about Cheryl Lavin, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2012 CREATORS.COM


Comments

2 Comments | Post Comment
The question about the advice is, was it advice to help survive short term or meant to be long term advice on how to make the relationship better. From the way the writer sounded it sounded like she just needed survival tips in the original letter. It certainly wouldn't work long term where you expect your spouse to grow up and learn to be reasonable. You cant reason with unreasonable people. Also abusive people are strange. sometimes if you immediately show you wont put up with it they are all right with that but then if you do put up with it then try to change the dynamics, they really freak out. Others just want you for their scapegoat forever and ever. i sure hope Torn has moved on and has some relief from it all.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Laurie
Fri Feb 3, 2012 8:53 AM
After reading the next column, I'd have to agree with Laurie. Torn has some work to do -- "you fell into the same trap most people do — me trying to fix him by suggesting that I avoid his triggers"?

Um, no. That's not quite correct. Torn, you suggested that that your husband might be reacting to stress and so you weren't ready to leave him. Cheryl suggested ways to lower the stress -- ways to break the patterns that you had both established. These were indeed short term survival strategies, meant to propel you to the place where you could talk about long-term solutions -- generally found in counseling -- and not to eternal bliss.

Now, perhaps Cheryl did not spell that out in her original response (which I don't remember). If not, she should have. "Once things are calmer, talk with your husband about getting to counseling so you can both find better means of dealing with stress long-term. If he refuses to go, go alone, and recognize that because a relationship involves two people, some problems are beyond the power of one person to fix alone."

I realize that abusive relationships are easy to fall into and very difficult to get out of, that there is never any excuse for abuse. However, blaming everyone else -- "most people" and an advice columnist to whom you downplayed the abuse, for crying out loud! -- for your abuse looks to me to be continuing to paint yourself as victim, which doesn't give me hope that you understand what red flags you initially overlooked. I really hope Torn is putting some heavy lifting into therapy, because her kids are relying on her to protect them from 1) future boyfriends/spouses and 2) their own father's abusive tendencies.
Comment: #2
Posted by: hedgehog
Sat Feb 4, 2012 6:47 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Cheryl Lavin
May. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2
About the author About the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month