The first woman speaker of the House, a tough, smart, rich and attractive pro, the most powerful woman in the world, helps get a Democrat elected president and then helps that Democratic president get his ambitious agenda through amid very difficult economic times and two wars. Did you think someone would send her flowers to say thank you?
Of course not. She's a witch and worse. Unprintable.
The best thing about this election cycle being over is that maybe everyone can take a break from beating up on Nancy Pelosi.
The president was right to take responsibility during his post-election news conference, but that won't stop a lot of people from blaming Pelosi. Easier than blaming the guy who is still president. I feel like making a sign: "Stop Blaming Nancy."
I don't know how much of it is sexist, and even that is unconscious and all but impossible to measure. Pelosi is one of those women people have strong reactions to. Haven't you noticed? You find people who have never met her and don't actually know all that much about her except that she personifies everything they hate.
Sorting through responses to politicians as opposed to responses to women politicians is especially difficult in a year when we saw so many different kinds of terrible — and terrific — women candidates that some of the stereotypes, good and bad, had to die. By any measure, though, Pelosi has been the punditry's pinata.
So let's set the record straight: She didn't single-handedly lose the Congress. She isn't the architect of destruction. She did precisely what her president asked her to do and what, dare I remind folks, he promised to do when running for president.
This was not some set of moves she devised on a freelance detour. This was the plan.
Getting one bill passed is close to impossible. Ask any kid who has spent a summer in Washington, or better yet a semester, and can't understand how people tolerate its menu of constant frustration. Imagine mastering it. She did. Imagine keeping all the independent contractors marching in the same direction when their jobs are at stake. You could say she made it hard, but you have to admit the Republicans did not at any point make it easy.
Some day, when our kids or grandkids take it for granted that everybody has a card that allows them to get health care when they're sick, maybe she'll be remembered as courageous. Even today, you aren't going to convince me that Democrats would have fared better in this election if they had nothing to show for the last two years.
Between pushing his plan through and failing to get it through, you'll be hard-pressed to convince me that Pelosi should be blamed for doing the former instead of the latter.
Of course, there is a third option. Maybe she should have convinced him to do less; to divide the health care plan into stages; less money for the stimulus; fewer jobs now but more in the long run. Like her members.
Politics isn't just about doing the right thing. It's also about winning. When doing what you think is right is going to cost you an election — as happened here — it's likely a good indication not that politics is bad but that you're wrong. Boy, that's a tough one. Did people really expect Pelosi to put the kibosh on change? Imagine what they would have said about her if she had.
To find out more about Susan Estrich and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.
Susan,
It is very easy to pass bills where you are giving other people's money away -- playing Santa Klaus. This doesn't take much talent, just a sufficient number of other lawmakers who believe the same. The truly talented lawmaker passes law that benefits no one in particular but the country in general. These are the people worthy of our praise -- not the Pelosi types.
Obama, Pelosi, and Reid only destroyed the Democrat Party! They lost the House. Of the Senate seats up they were embarrassed. At the state and local level across the country Republicans dominated to such an extent that when House districts are redrawn, Dems will lose 15-25 seats. This situation will last for 10 years.
The did it in the most brazen and dishonest way, violating many of their easiest campaign promises and overtly seeking to pay-back their campaign supporters.
Even the most basic oversight the Republicans will exercise will cause severe discomfort and legal impacts on many people
It's hard work building popular support for major social legislation, such as social security, medicare, and obamacare. Nancy Pelosi (and Harry Reid and Barack Obama) didn't do that. Medicare and social security were popular measures when they were passed. obamacare was (and still is) not.
For liberals, Nancy Pelosi will be remembered as both an ultimate Machiavellian manipulator and a legislative hero. For the rest of the country, she will be remembered as a craven ideologue who completely overcame the 'annoyance' of the principle of representative government -- and she will forever be an example of politicians who rule rather than serve.
Yes, she has been extraordinarily powerful and effective. For those who share her beliefs, that is to her credit. For those who are shocked by her disregard of the expressed wishes of the citizens, her ruthlessness casts her as a tyrant. Thank goodness our constitution provides for a peaceful regime change through elections. The system works.
-- Bob Elkind
Comment: #4
Posted by: bob elkind
Thu Nov 4, 2010 7:09 PM
Susan, Susan, Susan. (while shaking my head, slowly and sadly, back and forth). The Healthscam is outside the enumerated powers, granted by The Constitution. Nancy (we have to pass the bill to find out what's in it) usurped authority to broker back-room bribes, denegrated American Citizens in her lust for power, and advocated socialism against capitalism. There are many, many truely American women politicians that you could praise and, yet, you continue to hold this rich, anti-American up as someone to emulate. You, still, don't get it. All you seem to care about is that she is a woman. You are the epitomy of sexism.
Comment: #5
Posted by: David Henricks
Fri Nov 5, 2010 3:36 AM
"Politics isn't just about doing the right thing. It's also about winning." Using Susans's philosophy doing the 'wrong thing' is ok as long as you win. So destroying our Constitution and implementing policies that are Socialist/Facist/Marxist are good things if you suceed at doing it, like Obama, Reid and Pelosi have done.
What a sick philosophy!
Comment: #6
Posted by: Early
Fri Nov 5, 2010 5:18 AM
Dear Susan, thousands of people are telling me my videos are racist and hateful. BARACK THE ANGRY NEGRO and TIME FOR A TEAHAD can be seen at, www.conservativesportsmen.com. Youtube keeps taking them down. I'd really appreciate your opinion. Thank you, GW
Comment: #7
Posted by: Grady Warren
Fri Nov 5, 2010 7:55 AM
Susan, you win the award for the most ridiculous spin by any democrat. So, the "TEA Party" had a couple of candidates not win in states that are typically not republican, big deal. How about all those democratic reps who had served for decades and got defeated? Perhaps, the democrats put the wrong candidates up. What about Russ Feingold in WI? And what about so many of us who don't give a rip about the "TEA Party" . And, if you think the American people did not speak, you are deaf. If Obama does not change his direction, he has NO hope (there's that hope word) of serving a second term. He's so proud and arrogant, I don't expect much change. The best thing: not having to see so much of Pelosi. Worse thing: having to listen to Hairy Read - and he will read, just like Obama has to off a teleprompter.
Comment: #9
Posted by: Lynn
Fri Nov 5, 2010 8:07 AM
Pelosi, Reid, and obama have done what might very well turn out to be irreparable harm to this country and to its people. This woman is the epitome of what a truly confident, liberated woman is. She is small minded, venal, self absorbed, petty, grasping, and quite a few other adjectives that I won't bore any readers with. Bottom feeding power junkies like these three are to be scorned, not praised. Estrich has finally gone over the side. After spending the last few years marginalizing herself with the idiocy that she has written, she has finally taken the brass ring. This column is bird cage liner.
Predictably, most of your comments come from the haters: hate Obama, hate Pelosi, hate Reid, hate Democrats, hate Government, hate, hate, hate (not that they ever have any worthwhile solutions, other than cut government spending -- conveniently overlooking the unparalleled spending spree in the eight years of Dubya -- and cut taxes, leaving all the messy bills for future generations to contend with. Nancy Pelosi did a very effective job in her role as speaker and she and all who supported her can look with pride on what she accomplished.
Comment: #12
Posted by: Mississippi Bubba
Sat Nov 6, 2010 4:47 AM
The Florida Times Union (Jacksonville, FL) posted your article in todays paper (Saturday Nov. 6, 2010).
I take offense to almost everything you said in this article. I am going to protest our paper and ask for your column not to be discontinued.
I have worked all my life to get what I have and nobody ever gave me anything! Now that Obama has been exposed for what a liberal can do wrong, you come along with your narrow-minded liberal ideas. I am quite sure that you could take your brain out and read the news paper thru it! Now that's narrow-minded!
I am going to request that the Florida Times fish wraper not dirty up the paper with your opinion!
I am not a cruel or vendictave person; however, I have no tolerence for ignorance (which you seem to have in excess).
Don't go away mad! Just go away.
Sincerely,
Dwight Strickland
Ponte Vedra Beach, FL
Comment: #13
Posted by: Dwight Strickland
Sat Nov 6, 2010 7:21 AM
Susan, dear Susan. Please forget about being a liberal for a moment. Think about being an American who has seen one of the most bitter power plays by the government against the wishes of the country. When a politician states that all bills will be put on C-SPAN for 72 hours so that everyone can read it and understand what the vote if for and then turns around and pushes it through with a majority vote without the politicians reading what is in the bill it sorta goes down wrong in everyones mind. This is something like a bully in a school yard would be doing knowing full well the opposition could not fight back. However, the people as a whole has fought back and dumped the people who voted for this bill and will certainly continue to vote against anyone who tries similar tactics in the future. I won't even go into the fact that this she was excluded from this bill being a member of the government, or that unions were excluded alone Muslims.
I think instead of trying to defend someone maybe you should look at the overall picture before putting words to paper.
Comment: #14
Posted by: Gene44
Sat Nov 6, 2010 10:37 AM
Dear Susan -
As a woman of your own generation, I applaud your success as a columnist. Increasingly I find myself cringing, however, at what you have to say ..... even the headlines come across as whiney.
Nancy Pelosi is a big girl. She's developed her "rep" by making choices and taking positions that reflect her political ambitions, rather than taking seriously her role as a representative of the people. She is a politician and not a public servant. She has also behaved very much as though she is the noblesse oblige - an approach likely to wear out one's welcome sooner rather than later. While she may be an accurate reflection of her constituency, one could certainly argue that her constituency is bent on economic self-destruction, which speaks volumes about her.
Your "don't be mean to poor Nancy" protestations on her behalf don't do a thing to change perceptions based on her choices/positions. Nor do they serve to justify her actions. They just make you look like a groupie and diminish your professional stature.
Pelosi is unquestionably as smart as a whip - which means she alone is accountable. What goes around, comes around; she's reaping what she sowed.
Comment: #15
Posted by: Jan
Sat Nov 6, 2010 5:00 PM
Ms. Estrich, you hit a new low with the 'sexist' quote!
I guess you're okay with Liberal Democrats bribing other members of congress to pass legislation you support. Just how hard was it to shove Health Care down our throats with both the executive and both houses of congress firmly in Democratic hands. If the Conservatives and / or Republicans stated they were going to cut 500 BILLION dollars from Medicare, YOU would scream bloody murder!
Nuff Said...Dennis
Comment: #16
Posted by: Dennis
Sun Nov 7, 2010 1:35 AM
"Some day, when our kids or grandkids take it for granted that everybody has a card that allows them to get health care when they're sick..."
No, I'm imagining a day when my kids and grandskids have to wait a year for anything but the most urgent of medical care--and, for some things, that care isn't provided at all. I'm imagining a day when my kids and grandkids, assuming they have the money, go to other countries for their medical care because the American medical system has been ruined by over-regulation, a paucity of doctors because any possible reward, financial, emotional, or otherwise, for a decade or more of learning <i>how</i> to be a doctor has been stripped away under government control. I'm imagining a day when the latest in medical research and techniques come from other countries because America can no longer afford to do the research.
I'm imagining "someday" when my kids or grandkids have to work eight months out of the year--rather than the present "only" five months--just to pay their taxes. I'm imagining a day when, due to outrageous taxation, people can't afford to save for their own retirements and are forced into the same government-mandated cookie-cutter pension system as everyone else.
All that may not be what you pie-in-the-sky Liberals have in mind, but that's what will happen, or some variation of it, if you succeed in ruining everything that brought America to a fast-fading greatness.
Comment: #17
Posted by: Henry Miller
Sun Nov 7, 2010 7:41 AM
"The truly talented lawmaker passes law that benefits no one in particular but the country in general."
<i>This</i> is what the Constitution means by "general welfare!" It has nothing to do with class-warfare schemes to rob the country's productive Peters to buy votes from the country's lazy Pauls.
Comment: #18
Posted by: Henry Miller
Sun Nov 7, 2010 7:49 AM
Pelosi is a great partisan and perhaps one of the best at procedure and politics regardless of gender. However, she still managed to irritate some and utterly anger others in the electorate. Perhaps only the most partisan and most liberal of the Dems see her as not only accomplished but right. The image of her walking up to the capital with the gargantuan gavel for the health care vote will forever be burned into my brain. If it had been a man, I would have been just as angered, but perhaps I would have felt more willing to call out loud all the names I was thinking when I saw her. Perhaps to be fair and modern, I should just call them out against her, too.
Regardless, all of her ability and accomplishments only satisfied a few, and many of those were clearly in her district. To think she lead an open debate to find the best solutions for all so that someone with preexisting conditions would not be left out in the cold is fantasy.
Comment: #19
Posted by: John in MA
Sun Nov 7, 2010 8:27 AM
I thought you were better than to reach to the gender (sexism) and racism cards that have been so overplayed in the last 3 years as to become meaningless. I guess you are now meaningless as well.
Thanks to Obama, Reid, and Pelosi policies most people didn't want were "cheated" though the system, and the dem party damaged for a decade.
Hope and change indeed. Thanks, but no thanks, I will vote a straight Republican ticket for the rest of my life as a result of the idiocy these 3 have visited upon my ex party and the country I "used" to be proud of.
Comment: #20
Posted by: Darrel
Sun Nov 7, 2010 12:19 PM
Nancy Pelosi is the gift that keeps on giving. I'm so glad for the Republican party that she is running for Minority Leader. She will raise lots of money for conservatives and serve as a rallying point for independents who were voting against the policies she promoted since the deficit started going up -- the year she became speaker! I love the face of the Democrat party going into the next decade: Jerry Brown (age 72), Nancy Pelosi (age 70), Barney Frank (age 70), Harry Reid (age 71). The ideas and policies of your only young Turk, Obama, have failed and become discredited. Yep, you guys are our future all right!
Comment: #22
Posted by: Lesley Barnard
Sun Nov 7, 2010 1:18 PM
Having pelosi as the number 3 in line to be president, has scared the living day lights out of me!! She is absolutely the craziest speaker in the history of the house. i.e. "We have to pass the bill to see what's in it." She needs to go home to that looney part of America, San Francisco. Any city that would ban the McDonalds Happy Meal needs pelosi!
She needs to retire, go home and spend time with her family.
Comment: #23
Posted by: Rome
Sun Nov 7, 2010 3:02 PM
Suzie, you are completely around the bend now. Let is all pray the democrats elect her as Minority Leader, nothing but nothing could better assure the democrats the loss of the WH and the rest of Congress in 2012 and this is a good thing. They have wasted enough of our money.
Comment: #24
Posted by: Paul
Mon Nov 8, 2010 6:45 AM
California deserves Nancy Pelosi, and Brown and Boxer. It's a state in rapid decline and the residents think everything is rosy because the rest of the nation will continue to bail them out. NO MORE! NO MORE!
Comment: #25
Posted by: Early
Mon Nov 8, 2010 8:11 AM
While I agree with what you say about Ms. Pelosi, it is also clear that Democratic leadership, including Ms. Pelosi and Mr. Obama, didn't "get" the message from the American electorate long before the carnage of the election itself. Say what you will about the accomplishments of this administration, and they are significant, they paled in the dark clouds of the nonrecovery and lost jobs. They were/are perfect fodder for an electorate that wants to be conservative, and for the Party of No to catch the wave. By the time the new Congress gets finished gutting or unfunding the gains of the Obama administration, the memory of the vistories - and the heroism of Ms. Pelosi - will be long forgotten.
Unfortunately, not so with the lessons that continue to be taught in national politics (and mirrored by states as well) - that crapping on the accomplishments of the opposition is effective and worthy of party policy all by itself.
John Holtz, Scottsville, NY
Comment: #26
Posted by: John Holtz
Mon Nov 8, 2010 8:45 AM
"Even today, you aren't going to convince me that Democrats would have fared better in this election if they had nothing to show for the last two years. "
If they would have followed through with promises such as PayGo, transparency where bills would be online 3 days before a vote, "draining the swamp," reigning in the deficit, bi-partisanship, etc., they may have had a lot to show over the last two years and still been in control of the House and the 19 State legislatures the Democrats lost.
Instead she saw her overwhelming majority, misread the "mandate" (as with every idiot politician), and shoved some of the most harmful legislation that will harm Americans for years to come.
I will assume the conservatives will stop blaming Pelosi about the same time the liberals stop blaming Bush.
Susan,
Your are out of your (unprintable) f-ing mind! Yes...we will continue to blame Nancy, Harry, Barry and any other
individual who played a part in perpetrating such a horrific crime of fraud against democracy...and the American PEOPLE!
Rebecca B
Northern Nevada
Susan, if only you'd read your readers' comments you might get some enlightenment. You take the position that Pelosi was only doing what she promised the voters, and that she and the President succeeded in keeping their promises despite being thwarted by the Republicans. Don't you realize that if it hadn't been for the Republican protest we'd be even worse off? Aren't you aware that the opposite of what you propound is true? That is, just as Bush was Cheney's puppet, unsophisticated O'bama is Pelosi's and Reid's. Yet the main problem with the outcome of Pelosi's and O'bama's efforts is caused by two things: (1) Hidden agendas on both their parts; and (2) they recognized the problems but formulated the wrong solutions, which exacerbated the major blunder which was the priority given to medical care when it should have gone to the economy. First things first, Susan.
Comment: #29
Posted by: OLIVER BERLINER
Wed Nov 10, 2010 7:12 AM
If you read your reader's comments, Susan, the only thing you'd learn is that the Internet has been taken over by brainwashed, Fox-sucking, right wing trolls. Oh, and that they hate you almost as much as Speaker Pelosi.
Comment: #30
Posted by: Michael Witthaus
Wed Nov 10, 2010 12:00 PM
Thank you for the thoughtfull column about Nancy Pelosi. Karl Rove's stated Republican strategy is to attack Democrats on their strengths, so the virulent, unrelenting criticisms of this amazing woman should be an indication how much they admire and fear her. When will people realize how manulipated they been, engage in thoughtful, fact bassed discussions and stop dancing to Fox News' owner, Rupert Murdoch's tune? What is best for the country is what is important, not what is best for your political party.
Thanks,
Suzie
Comment: #32
Posted by: susan caven
Sat Nov 13, 2010 1:18 PM
Susan,
Two in a row that I agree with you. I am a member of the republican party and a tea party supporter……..Im scared. How is this happening you better get back to your old hippie commie bs soon or my world will implode. We arent supposed to agree on things so keep your end of this bargain and make me mad like you used to or Im never coming back. Have a great holiday hope your fever breaks soon and you are back to normal.
Comment: #33
Posted by: tim blincoe
Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:46 PM
Susan,
Two in a row that I agree with you. I am a member of the republican party and a tea party supporter……..Im scared. How is this happening you better get back to your old hippie commie bs soon or my world will implode. We arent supposed to agree on things so keep your end of this bargain and make me mad like you used to or Im never coming back. Have a great holiday hope your fever breaks soon and you are back to normal.
Comment: #34
Posted by: tim blincoe
Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:46 PM