creators.com opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Mark Shields
Mark Shields
18 Feb 2012
What Endorsements Can Tell Us

The endorsement of a political candidate by another politician generally draws a well-deserved yawn from voters.… Read More.

11 Feb 2012
Religion Provides Added Value to U.S.

Without the courage and the constancy of Methodists and of Quakers, the struggle to abolish slavery in the … Read More.

4 Feb 2012
“He Could Have Been a Contender ...”

At the 1972 Democratic convention that nominated Sen. George McGovern of South Dakota for president, McGovern'… Read More.

Independent Voters' Jury Still Out

Share Comment

TOWSON, MD. — Those of us who live in Washington, D.C., do not make movies or airplanes. We do not raise corn or cattle. What Washington occasionally makes is public policy, and we constantly produce "conventional wisdom."

Here, just six months into the presidency of Barack Obama, in a two-hour focus group composed of 12 independent voters conducted by respected Democratic pollster Peter Hart for the Annenberg Public Policy Center of the University of Pennsylvania, the prevailing conventional wisdom of the "everybody-in-the know — Inside the Beltway" variety sustained a brutal beating.

You may have heard the informed insiders' consensus, which announced that because of his daily, almost hourly, timetable of speeches, statements, events and press availabilities, that President Obama was being badly overexposed; the overscheduling by the White House had dissipated the voters' attention and diminished the president's influence with the public.

Wrong. Forget it. These independent voters welcome and appreciate seeing and listening to their young president. To Nora Seeley, 54, a dental hygienist, Mr. Obama is "more upfront … I like it. He is showing himself." Remi Brooke, 60, a rental agent, endorses how Obama "explains to people so they can understand it." Louis Moriconi, 63, a graphic designer, says: "I like the way he communicates," while registered nurse Jeanne Chambers, 56, likes his "town-hall meeting style," which shows him to be "obviously very intelligent."

Up to now, the voters' familiarity with Mr. Obama has worked to his advantage. Pollster Hart commented afterward: "There's a sense of intimacy," which indicates "how unbelievably powerful his personal presence is."

Obviously, a 12-person focus group does not represent a scientific sample. And the president's job-approval numbers have been consistently declining over the past four months in established public polls (including the NBC News-Wall Street Journal poll for which Hart is half of the polling team.) But Hart makes the point that "raw polling numbers only tell half the story.

What we learned (in Towson) is that voters are still very much rooting for Barack Obama to succeed."

But the jury is still very much out on the new president's toughness. When asked directly what Obama's backbone is made of, only two answered "steel" or "metal." Other responses were less flattering. "Wet cement," said Marsha Welder, 59, manager of a security firm. "Wood," suggested 37-year-old Tom Stranger, an accountant, which was more positive than the reply of "plastic" by David Sawyer, 39, a forklift operator. Tim Polen, a 24-year-old student, the youngest in the group, explained that Obama's vertebrae were simply "bone and tissue" because "he's just human."

The 12 in Towson are still waiting for the inevitable crisis that will test Obama and reveal if his spine is steel or some more pliable substance.

When asked with which political family — the Obama's, McCain's, Palin's, or Clintons's — they would prefer to vacation, three picked the Republican choices, but only three respondents named the Obama family; half would rather hang out with the Clinton family. Moriconi volunteered: "Bill's a party guy." But when told that a medical matter might prevent Bill Clinton's vacationing, all six respondents said they would cancel.

Even those voters who are rooting for Obama think that he is moving too fast. They feel the nation needs a timeout. They urge him to slow down. Stranger put it this way: "I hope he has learned that everything does not work at the speed of light." The president, Chambers adds, "needs to develop a little bit of patience …"

President Obama finds himself politically in rough seas. But, as we learned in Towson, he still inspires hope and support and he is far from alone.

To find out more about Mark Shields and read his past columns, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at www.creators.com.

DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS.COM

COPYRIGHT 2009 MARK SHIELDS


Comments

3 Comments | Post Comment
It's going to be four long years, Mark. For me his biggest vulnerability is Afghanistan. I haven't yet heard a coherent explanation as to why, yet again, it's ONLY WE who are fighting a war half way across the globe. Why isn't Mr. Popularity garnering a U.N. driven approach, or at least something resembling a true coalition of concerned nations sharing the burden equally, to dealing with Afghanistan and the many other troubled areas on the planet that are in need of intervention? If we continue going it alone this administration is going to lose the moral high ground faster than you can say "military industrial complex."
Comment: #1
Posted by: Masako
Sat Aug 1, 2009 10:45 AM
I really don't care whether the public thinks Obama is a good president or not. What people think does not define the President. What I care about is how the Congress is going to change the health care system, and why Obama is going to base his government insurance on the studies that are done daily on every aspect of our lives. Already, I am 74 years old and am denied a booster pneumonia shot even though I am very active for my age and have some health problems related to allergies and asthma. I wasn't any part of the study that said people over 70 don't benefit from a pneumonia shot, yet I am a victim of its ruling.

There are a lot of people who are judging the president just on the health care issue, hence his ratings have gone down, and I am wondering just what is in the bill, and why the hundreds of pages are so secret. Is the bill written in some other language than English? Newspapers are not printing the actual bill language and letting us decide if it's a bill we can live with. Thus there is a cloud of fear hanging over the American people because they are getting misinformation and perceptions. Also, there are 750,000 children (recent Express News Article) in Texas that are eligible for Medicaid and haven't signed up for it. Why does the president insist these children do not have access to health care!

I heard the president in one of his press conferences or one of his speeches on TV that state government insurance coverage would be based on studies, and that if the study didn't say it would help the people it studied or a person was too sick to get any relief from it, you would be denied that medicine and if you went to a doctor and paid for the medicine out of your own pocket, you would be fined. And now I read an article in the San Antonio Express News that states that a Federal Committee decided that swine flu vaccine (paid for by the government) will be given to healthy people under 65 if there is enough vaccine for all. In any case, people over 64 will be denied vaccine because the study said that people over 64 do not get or not bothered by swine flu. People over 64 may get regular flu shots, thank you very much.

Am I crazy--is there really that much difference between 64 and 65. Has anyone done a study to find out what that difference is?

Just tongue in cheek, I'm sure: the Express News has separated the Grandmas from a "We." The Froma Harrup column in today's (Aug 1) Express News is entitled "Really, Grandma, We Wouldn't Kill You" which has an ominous ring. Perhaps you could explain why the Express News thinks "We" have the power to kill "Grandma?" Thank you Express News for not killing Grandma today.

Hey, I guess government insurance will be handing out a lot of dark chocolate, so we over 64 will die happily. ;-)

I am an avid watcher of the PBS Lehrer News Hour, and I always enjoy your thoughts, which is why I singled you out to write this comment. I found this web site thanks to Froma Harrup's column. She includes this website at the bottom of the "Kill Grandma" column.

Sincerely, Margaret Rifleman prifle@sbcglobal.net
Comment: #2
Posted by: Margaret Rifleman
Sat Aug 1, 2009 11:39 AM
Sorry, Mark. Love you but hate this article. It's interesting stuff, of course, but it's been repeated in so many places that it was a waste of time here.
Comment: #3
Posted by: Mike Ohr
Sun Aug 2, 2009 12:46 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Mark Shields
Feb. `12
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
29 30 31 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 1 2 3
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Marc Dion
Marc DionUpdated 20 Feb 2012
Mark Shields
Mark ShieldsUpdated 18 Feb 2012
David Sirota
David SirotaUpdated 17 Feb 2012

16 May 2009 Republican Predictable Stages of Defeat

26 Apr 2008 The Fierce Urgency of Indiana for Obama

19 Jan 2008 A Debt of Gratitude Owed to Tom Davis