opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Jim Hightower
Jim Hightower
25 Nov 2015
The Agriculture Attitude

Thanksgiving — let's eat! America's most food-focused holiday traces its roots back to the abundant … Read More.

18 Nov 2015
Let's Get on Board With High-Speed Rail

Practically every wealthy nation today is making major investments in building high-speed rail networks to … Read More.

11 Nov 2015
Let's Break Away From Black-Friday Syndrome

Here comes the holiday season. It's a month-long season of friends, family and spiritual reflection, and a … Read More.

Killing the Competition


Golly, whatever happened to America's good ol', bold-and-brassy, can-do competitive drive?

To see a troubling sign for our nation's famed, free-enterprise frontier spirit, sneak a peek at the downward flight path of America's major airlines. These corporations have become no-can-do, anti-competition behemoths, whining that there are too many airlines, too many planes, too much competition.

"It's a jungle out there," wail top executives of the airlines. So, to enhance their "competitiveness," they are urging a rash of mergers that would consolidate the industry into fewer and even bigger corporations. Yes, in their alternate (and perverse) universe, airline CEOs say that the only way they can compete is to ... well, have less competition!

"The industry needs to evolve into a more rational structure," asserts a top official at American Airlines. "We have an industry that is too fragmented, with too many competitors and with different ideas of capacity, pricing and strategic activity."

Hmmm. Where have we heard that before? Oh yes, from Adam Smith, the 18th century Scotish economist who is considered a founding guru of the free enterprise system. The notion of "many competitors ... with different ideas of capacity, pricing and strategic activity" is precisely what Smith hailed as the proper model for free enterprise.

But the competitiveness that Smith celebrated as beneficial to society is what today's timorous airline leaders see as an irritating barrier that they simply can't hurdle. Better just to lower the competitive hurdle. As the former chairman of Continental Airlines put it: "I mean, do we really need 19 domestic airlines in the United States? I think three or four network airlines would still give you plenty of competition."

Plenty? What he and other executives mean by "a more rational structure" is one that allows a small club of gentlemen to divvy up the market, cut flights and raise ticket prices in unison — without being challenged by pesky rivals.

Soon, at least one more brand name is expected to join Northwest, Pan Am, TWA and others that have succumbed to consolidation. Both Continental and US Airways are presently in talks to merge with United Airlines. United's chief, Glenn Tilton, has long been a podium-pounding evangelist for the corporate gospel of shrinking the industry into a handful of more cooperative competitors. This is the route to consistent industry profits, he preaches.

Well, yeah! It's called a shared monopoly, and any goober in Guccis can make profits from that rigged deal. Of course, Tilton comes from the oil industry, where he led the merger of Texaco into Chevron, so he's partial to creating a tidier market for corporate fun and profit — consumers be damned.

Astonishingly, to press their case for consolidation, industry executives point to the example of the telecommunications giants, which went on a merger binge a decade ago. Excuse me, but consumer satisfaction with the arrogance and avarice of conglomerated and consolidated telecom providers ranks down around public approval ratings for Wall Street banksters.

Also, Tilton is hardly an inspirational figure for American workers. In fact, he's a poster boy for rapacious CEOs who try to profit by knocking down employees. He used our country's skewed bankruptcy laws to abrogate contracts, forcing flight attendants, mechanics and pilots to take massive cuts in pay, health care benefits and pensions. He did, however, exclude one employee from the pain: himself. He pocketed $6,471,062 in 2008.

You'll also be glad to know that he's been an industry leader in slashing service at United and socking customers with a plethora of new fees. Now, Tilton wants to bring his executive magic to Continental, US Air — and who knows what after that?

Thank goodness the airline chiefs are not trying to run a hot dog stand or taco trailer. The competition would kill them.

To find out more about Jim Hightower, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at



2 Comments | Post Comment
Keep shining this light Jim. The lack of true competition in a high number of sectors makes the 'free' market arguments a joke. The only free markets are the black ones, and the same anti competitive forces are in force there too.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Patrick
Fri Apr 23, 2010 9:53 AM
This comment is long overdue.I was a loyal Northwest Airline customer for so many years,flying using this carrier at every chance to visit my native country.The last 2 visits,it was a friendly Korean Airline.I wouldn't have chosen Korean,if a US airline was priced comparatively.First, it was the cheapest compared to other airlines and second the customer service was a step up from my experience with the other airline.
Since all these mergers,it was difficulty to find comparable prices with any US airlines.The result of mergers,profit, profit and more profits.
Comment: #2
Posted by: adlyo
Fri Mar 18, 2011 12:23 PM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Jim Hightower
Nov. `15
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Froma Harrop
Froma HarropUpdated 26 Nov 2015
Roger Simon
Roger SimonUpdated 25 Nov 2015
Jim Hightower
Jim HightowerUpdated 25 Nov 2015

6 May 2015 An Epidemic of CNE Syndrome Strikes Our State Governments

15 Jul 2009 Free Food Can Be Yours for the Picking

3 Aug 2011 Obama Says He'll Really Fight for the People ... Next Time