creators.com opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Jamie Stiehm
Past and Present
10 May 2013
Cleveland Police or the Air Force: Which Failure Is Worse?

Two breaking stories — heartbreaking — of violence on girls and women tell us it walks around in … Read More.

3 May 2013
Chance Meetings: The World Comes Home

Hip workplaces, like Bloomberg and Yahoo, are all about promoting chance conversations to yield ideas. … Read More.

26 Apr 2013
The President -- Too Proud for Hand-to-hand Politics?

President Obama invited all 20 women senators to dine at the White House Tuesday and made the 17 Democrats … Read More.

Meet at Midnight: A Cliff Here, the Proclamation There

Comment

It was amazing enough to make an ink-stained wretch like me weep: Washington on New Year's Eve as midnight drew near. The fiscal cliff and the Emancipation Proclamation were about to meet "in the moment."

There I was — in the citadel of the Capitol and at the National Archives, a short ride up Constitution Avenue. The Proclamation was on a rare display, the marble building open until the wee hours. To see the president's handwriting on parchment was free.

Never have I felt so chagrined and moved at once. Past and present met at a mixed moment, midnight on Jan. 1, 2013. A convergence that puts irony to shame.

Abraham Lincoln's law freeing 3 million slaves collided in time with — um — a desperate deadline measure by lawmakers and President Obama to impose some discipline on themselves. The modern result wasn't pretty to watch.

You see, the stroke of midnight fell heavy on each scene because the E.P. of Jan. 1, 1863, was turning 150 years old, precisely at the first moment of the new year. Back then, Bostonians breathlessly awaited the news by telegraph as they gathered at Faneuil Hall late into the night. People rejoiced and church bells pealed all over the Northeast and anti-slavery Ohio. When word of mouth reached freed slaves in the Confederate states, many wept with joy and large numbers joined the Union Army. The Civil War's brightest hour, it was the greatest advance in the journey of American justice by light years.

It was a different story inside the funhouse of the U.S. Capitol, as the lantern burned bright and the Senate's Ohio Clock tick-tocked. Frustrated senators were dealing behind closed doors, trying to avert the "fiscal cliff" midnight deadline.

About a hundred reporters, a few dressed in party clothes, filled the hall outside the chamber with sighs, alert to whispers of what was going on with the tax code numbers — and when there would be a vote.

Don't ask. Well, we know House Republicans, including several tea party freshmen who had been defeated, almost thwarted an agreement. Senate Democrats wisely refused to revisit their hard-won package with them. Republican Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell seems to be the man of the hour, since he negotiated directly with the White House. Speechless, luckless, voteless House Speaker John Boehner seems to be the man of the dour. He may not last the year where he sits.

Then we come to the president. His name is Barack Obama. Once again, he flinched in the face of fire. He promised he'd hold out for the Clinton tax code rate for the wealthiest — defined as those making $250,00 or more. "Under no circumstances," he said, would he go as high as a household income of $450,000 — which is what he gave in to in the end, under heavy Republican artillery.

Whoever said he was like Lincoln? It's sad Obama can't stand firm when the stakes pale compared to a bloody rebellion.

When I arrived at the Archives at 11:00 on the eve of the new year, more than 4,000 people had already been there. Since the state of the Senate was choppy and punchy, I needed to escape the funhouse. Was I the only person in the capital to see the contrast that night: the majestic and the absurd? So close in space; far in time.

Nell Minow, a white Washingtonian who lined up to see the E.P., broke into tears at the momentous "thenceforward, and forever free" document. An African-American security guard said to her, "Yes, I understand how you feel. "

Enough to make you weep. Either new year's midnight scene — or both. Onward to 2013 we go.

To find out more about Jamie Stiehm, and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit www.creators.com

COPYRIGHT 2013 CREATORS.COM



Comments

1 Comments | Post Comment
Ma'am;... I hope I am not stepping into the usual man trap by stating the obvious, but no proclamation is worth more than the political will to enforce it... Lincoln realized the essential element of public opinion in the freedom of government to do good, or do anything...There were those who called at the end of war for the absolute crushing of the rebelious spirit in the South... It was very much a mistake to bring them back into the union unreformed... Many of those who played leading rolls in the war should have been despoiled, and their lands given to blacks or sold cheaply to others... Great estates built on the blood of slaves should certainly have been broken up...
Johnson was in many respects fair, but was in other ways a simply terrible post war president...And the problem dragged on into our time unresolved because of a lack of political will... To give a better example of a more intelligent approach to public opinion I offer the Warren Court in Brown V. Board of Education...There they did what all democracies should do in seeking consensus... We have on the one hand too much of courts and threats of law... We have on the other hand attempts by the media to beat people over the head with the club of public opinion...What the Warren Court did in addressing that thorney issue was to work to bring people along slowly and respectfully to face the inevitable, and push change forward...
Because of extraconstitutional changes in the constitution, primarily fixing the numbers of representatives in the house, great districts could be gerrymanered to assure victory to one party or the other... The people know when year after year they are unrepresented; and year after year representatives fed radicalism, and enjoyed perfect freedom, knowing their districts had no choice but them...The people long denied good government even while buying the radical message have begun to elect representatives out of their radicalism... This means government can no longer agree even to govern...Consensus is impossible... Radicallism sowed is becoming a harvest of radicalism, much of it upon the same lines as the long unresolved Civil War...
This problem is not going to go away, and if the representatives cannot empower the institution they will have lost all their power to their arson of public opinion... It was always a mistake to fix the number of members of the house... It made a seller's market of the house, and took personal power which was lost by the institution... Gerrymandering gags great parts of the population, and I care not who anyone elects, but it is offensive that so many on both sides do not have some one of their own choice sharing their concerns representing them in Washington...
Consensus is impossible, so democracy is impossible... Soon, agreement of any sort will be impossible...
I think Mr. Obama is just enough like Lincoln to get by... Americans are more and more realising their form of government is defective... It was necessary to show the people a government capable of doing something, even if it was wrong.... A people in contempt of itself and its government, radical and armed, with a government too broken to move out of its own way that has given the people every reason to hate it- is more ready for civil war, or revolution than self government; but self government, democracy would have averted the problems to begin with...
Self government was never a device for running over the top of anyone, but was a vehicle for bringing all along at their own pace...Tyrannies command their people... Democracies do the will of the people, and all the people..
Thanks...Sweeney
Comment: #1
Posted by: James A, Sweeney
Fri Jan 4, 2013 6:50 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Jamie Stiehm
May. `13
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
28 29 30 1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Susan EstrichUpdated 15 May 2013
Roger Simon
Roger SimonUpdated 15 May 2013
Robert Scheer
Robert ScheerUpdated 14 May 2013

22 Mar 2013 Michelle Obama: Keeping the Public at a Distance

25 May 2012 Obama and Romney: How Women Measure the Men

11 Jan 2013 Obama: White House Fraternity President