opinion web
Conservative Opinion General Opinion
Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop
26 Nov 2015
Let Pharmacies Prescribe Birth Control

Back in 1933, Rep. Walter Pierce of Oregon introduced a bill in Congress to let doctors discuss birth control … Read More.

24 Nov 2015
Are You Happy, and How Would You Know?

Like many others, I can't resist academic studies on happiness. They often come up with persuasive reasons … Read More.

19 Nov 2015
A Tale of Two Terrors: Paris and New York

Like most people, I'm thinking of the terrorist trauma in Paris, though with a somewhat different perspective.… Read More.

A Senate Seat Is Not a Kennedy Heirloom


Have New York Democrats lost all self-respect? Their excited talk of whether Caroline Kennedy is "interested" in Hillary Clinton's Senate seat makes you wonder. The late John F. Kennedy's daughter has made at least one feeler phone call to New York Gov. David Paterson. And Uncle Teddy, the Massachusetts senator, is busy pulling the levers to slip her in. The seat will be vacant upon Clinton's confirmation as secretary of state.

This unsavory spectacle has been upstaged by the wild drama in Illinois, where Gov. Rod Blagojevich is being accused of trying to sell Barack Obama's Senate seat. The doings in New York are not blatant corruption, but they are corrosive to our democratic ideals. Lest anyone forget the point of the American Revolution, our representatives are not chosen by hereditary succession, which, to quote Thomas Paine, "is an insult and imposition on posterity."

Of course, Caroline can ask for whatever she wants. The astounding part is that the idea of such a request hasn't been laughed out of the news pages.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, against all evidence, touts Caroline as "a very experienced woman." Her government service starts and ends at raising private money for the New York City schools. While a worthy endeavor, it's a socialite's job.

For nearly four decades after her father's assassination, Caroline commendably resisted the call to become a Democratic Party ornament. Then at the 2000 Democratic convention, she stepped on the stage to the tune of "Camelot" and, with no little presumption, thanked the American people for "sustaining us through the good times, and the difficult ones, and for helping us dream my father's dream." Then she introduced "Uncle Teddy."

Women's groups have been eager to see Clinton replaced by another female. The Feminist Majority and the National Organization for Women had already endorsed Carolyn Maloney, a congresswoman who has represented parts of Manhattan and Queens for 15 years.

But if Caroline Kennedy wants the job, all bets are off, according to Feminist Majority President Eleanor Smeal.

"You're talking to someone who thinks Ted Kennedy is the most effective senator there," Smeal actually told The New York Times.

Here you have it. Without a second thought, feminists talk of throwing a seasoned, self-made professional overboard to make room for a Kennedy princess.

Uncle Ted has been reminding Democrats that Caroline would be backed by — as the Times straightforwardly put it — "the Kennedy family's extensive fundraising network." That's nice, but this is New York state, where electing a Democrat requires no miracle.

Set aside whether any seat should be gender-specific. It certainly shouldn't be genealogy-specific. But that's one of Caroline's selling points, at least from the Kennedy perspective. The seat was held for three years by her uncle Robert F. Kennedy, who was killed in 1968. For this reason, RFK's son Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was also eying the seat for himself. (Perhaps he could be made ambassador to France, instead.)

Hey, what about the Moynihans? Democrat Daniel Patrick Moynihan occupied that Senate chair for over 20 years. No Moynihan has yet come forward to claim it as a family possession to be handed down unto the generations.

Are we really having this conversation?

Paterson says he hasn't decided whom he will choose, though he notes that Caroline is "thinking about" the Senate position. According to the Times, "Some influential Democrats have privately suggested that given the buzz set off by Ms. Kennedy's emergence, the governor would have little choice but to appoint her if she decided she truly wanted the job."

Actually, he does have a choice.

Can New York Democrats summon up some dignity? We shall see.

To find out more about Froma Harrop, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page at




4 Comments | Post Comment
I always have a problem when someone with little experience is handed a political prize. If we are now in the business of gifting Senate seats then my support goes to CHELSEA CLINTON to take her mother's place. She has brains, drive, and the proven ability to step into the political world of fund-raising and campaigning.
Comment: #1
Posted by: Rita Watson
Thu Dec 11, 2008 1:11 PM
hopefully someonw will take notice of your column and realize what you are saying is true. Being from WNY we finally thought that one of our dedicated congressmen had a real chance to do some good for WNY. But of course when someone from downstate with a hgh profile name gets mentioned for the job -with little or no experience they become the front runner. As usual its not what you know but who you know and the Kennedys know the right people.
Comment: #2
Fri Dec 12, 2008 1:57 PM
Your reasoning strikes me as faulty, and in the words of Tina Fey " a little bit high-school bitchy". Let's see...Hillary's qualifications when she declared her candidacy for the senate? Lawyer? Check. Political family? Check? Author? Check. New Yorker...not so much. Not at all, ever! Caroline Kennedy has lived in and contributed to New York for what? Forty-plus years? Why are you so threatened by the possible appointment of the niece of a sitting Senator, and the niece of a dead one, when the blatant truth is that Hillary was elected because she was the "wife of"?
Comment: #3
Posted by: Nancy
Sun Dec 14, 2008 7:29 AM
Thank you for pointing out the very important fact. I was born after Prs. Kennedy was assassinated and have no special sentiment or admiration for The Kennedys. So, Ms. Kennedy is just a nice bright socialite for me. Surely she is a capable person being an attorney and presiding many charitable organizations. But, being a socialite and carrying the famous family name are not enough qualification to be our senator. We need somebody who understands our daily lives. Not somebody who's spent all her life in a penthouse on 5th Ave. We need somebody who has strong legislative experience so that she or he can really replace Sen. Clinton's work. It shocked me that Ms. Kennedy has a notion that she is entitled to become our senator by just expressing that she is interested in.

Also, I'm sick and tired to see people who were loud during the presidential election to support Obama are getting appointed for the cabinet seats and other political positions. There is no differences between auctioning off the senate seat and appointing the biggest supporters --- people who gathered money or votes for Obama most will win the position. How corrupted is it? Somebody explain to me what's so new about Obama politics.
Comment: #4
Posted by: Paula
Tue Dec 16, 2008 9:43 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
Froma Harrop
Nov. `15
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Marc Dion
Marc DionUpdated 30 Nov 2015
Jamie Stiehm
Jamie StiehmUpdated 27 Nov 2015
Lenore Skenazy
Lenore SkenazyUpdated 26 Nov 2015

29 Dec 2009 We'd Be Happy to Do This 'Strip Tease'

3 Jun 2010 Time to Call the Tea Party's Bluff

7 Apr 2015 Good People Sometimes Back Bad Laws