Racism and Discrimination in Health Care The highly influential New England Journal of Medicine published a series of perspectives on racial bias in health care. Dr. Mary Bassett, New York City's health commissioner, suggested that the medical community should not only do more to improve …Read more. When Is an Older Driver a Danger on the Road? Telling an older person he should no longer drive is difficult. This can be a devastating blow to the patient, who may resist the suggestion vigorously. No longer being able to drive takes away one's independence and increases isolation, depression, …Read more. Priorities in Lowering the Risk of Heart Disease Heart disease is the leading cause of death in the developed world. Although occurring at a later age, heart disease is just as common in women as in men. Despite this fact, fewer than 1 in 5 women believe that heart disease is a significant health …Read more. Being Your Parent's Parent Is Difficult But Potentially Rewarding I truly miss my mother, who died 18 months ago, at age 90. She was the quintessential Jewish mother and an expert at guilt. When I phoned her in South Africa, I didn't just say hello; I also said I'm sorry. I had almost always done something wrong. …Read more.more articles
End-Stage Alzheimer's Requires Good Decisions
It's common for patients in the final stages of Alzheimer's disease to be admitted to a nursing home. However, despite having advanced illness and being very dependent, the natural history of these patients remains unclear.
Until recently, there has been no clear consensus on the course of the illness, factors leading to death and quality of life after admittance to a long-term care facility. But new research could help families and caregivers better understand the path of advanced Alzheimer's disease.
In a recent study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, researchers followed 323 patients with advanced dementia who were recently admitted to a nursing home. After 18 months, more than half of the patients had died from pneumonia, swallowing difficulties or other febrile illnesses. This research clearly shows that advanced Alzheimer's disease is indeed a terminal illness and life expectancy is no longer than for a patient with severe heart failure, terminal cancer or a major stroke.
Although having a very poor prognosis, a substantial number of the patients were transferred to a hospital or an intensive care unit to treat pneumonia or to commence artificial feeding via a feeding tube. Unfortunately, few, if any, of the family members were aware of the poor prognosis, and most believed that life expectancy was likely to be much longer.
There was little discussion of palliative care and end-of-life choices. Ultimately, research clearly shows that hospitalizations were futile. It did not improve quality of life, may have caused needless suffering and definitely did not prolong life.
This research shows that end-stage Alzheimer's disease is associated with a great deal of disability and a very poor life expectancy. When a patient with Alzheimer's disease no longer recognizes family members, is unable to care for himself, has difficulty walking and eating, and cannot maintain continence, his prognosis is poor. As such, it is vitally important that family members understand how the illness progresses, what is considered "normal" and how to assure the smoothest transition from life to death.
For many older adults with advanced memory loss, the end of life comes with an inability to eat, which results in weight loss and a decline in the immune system.
Gradual weight loss is often accompanied by fatigue. The patient may have difficulty swallowing, which leads to an accumulation of mucus in the back of the throat that becomes a natural site for bacterial overgrowth and potential infection. This in turn causes more drowsiness, perhaps some confusion and almost always dehydration.
The patient becomes somnolent and can slowly slip into a coma. Without any artificial intervention, death almost always comes peacefully, at the accepted time, in a quite spiritual environment with the patient surrounded by reminiscing, loving and usually grateful family.
For anyone personally touched by Alzheimer's disease, it's extremely important to understand every phase of the illness. Battling Alzheimer's disease is a long, slow and often difficult challenge.
Early on, the illness can be maintained, sacrifices can be made, and your loved one can live many wonderful years after diagnosis. But once the advanced symptoms set in, you must understand the inevitability of death. In doing so, it becomes possible to avoid unnecessary therapy in a heartless, mechanical intensive care unit full of ventilators, cardiac monitors and artificial tubing. Simply with more understanding, the family and the physician can develop the best possible approach to comfort and end of-life care.
While families must be educated about the difficult road of end-stage Alzheimer's disease, the physician must play an important role in making the goals of care rational and realistic. American medicine has seen so many great advances that what was once impossible is now within reach, and physicians can help stave off death longer than ever before.
But, sadly, for patients with no good prognosis — for patients with end-stage Alzheimer's disease — there are far better choices to guarantee comfort and assure that the final hours are filled with peace, love and dignity.
Dr. David Lipschitz is the author of the book "Breaking the Rules of Aging." To find out more about Dr. David Lipschitz and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com. More information is available at www.DrDavidHealth.com.
COPYRIGHT 2009 CREATORS.COM