opinion web
Liberal Opinion General Opinion
William Murchison
William Murchison
9 Feb 2016
Notes on Cultural Collapse

That Donald Trump, in his quest to lead us back to national greatness, feels free to brag, distort, lampoon, … Read More.

2 Feb 2016
After Iowa

What's going on in this country right now, as exemplified in our current politics and the results in Iowa? I don'… Read More.

26 Jan 2016
What Matters in Politics -- And What Doesn't

My friends and fellow Americans: This Trump thing we're all chewing to death like a dog with a dishrag is … Read More.

Saying 'No' To Illegal Immigration


I wouldn't advise anyone's coming down too hard on the voters of Farmers Branch, Texas, who last weekend approved, two to one, a measure that bans the leasing of apartments to illegal immigrants.

Which — don't we all know it? — sounds like a nativist slap at hardworking folks who just want to get on in the world. Yes, and who happen to be living in violation of the laws of the country in which they are trying to get on.

The new Farmers Branch ordinance, if legal challenges to it fail, seems less likely to send illegals scampering back across the border to Mexico than to some other Dallas suburb. And yet this whole business concentrates the mind wonderfully, forcing thought about the idiocy of present U.S. policy and the desirability of a more rational policy. One aligned more or less with present-day realities would be nice, one sensitive to the U.S. economy's voracious demand for labor, sensitive as well to the need for a meaningful distinction between the non-American and the American.

I speak as one less in tune with America's large, let's-fence-off-the-border constituency than with those who see the need for regular replenishment of a labor force diminished by the effects of, among other things, abortion-on-demand; expected, moreover, by a neglectful Congress to produce more, always more, taxes for bailing out Social Security and Medicare.

I still propose not coming down unduly hard on the voters of Farmers Branch. I think one can see easily enough what they are getting at: They don't think it's a real nice idea to privilege outsiders over the native-born in terms of obligations to the majesty of the law.

As the city's mayor pro tem told The Dallas Morning News, "[Voters] are fed up with the fact that illegal immigration is being overlooked in all parts of our life. We think it is within our rights to take action for our city."

It's "nativist" to expect general adherence to democratically enacted rules? I don't think so.

What kind of rules, then? Maybe the one saying you don't get to come and live here absent some prior arrangement with the U.S.

government. Saying you ask permission before barging in.

It goes a little further than that, actually. If you do come without permission, you anticipate consequences. The non-emergence of consequences for illegal immigration is a constant irritant for many. It offends the common sense of justice. That the U.S. government fails to enforce the rules and many Americans agitate against their application only make matters worse.

For instance, why the ad hoc spread of bilingualism: the appearance everywhere in Texas of Spanish as, seemingly, the logical complement to English? The Latin-derived language of Madrid, and even of Nuevo Laredo, is lovely enough, but it is not easy to forget that knowledge of English is a requirement of citizenship. For whom are those ubiquitous Spanish notices meant? Clearly, for the non-English speaking. Meaning non-citizens? Of course. But why?

Why, too, in Texas, free public schools for the children of illegal immigrants? Why in-state tuition rates at state colleges and universities for these same children's older siblings? These are claims by the illegally domiciled against their hosts, whose sense of justice is duly outraged, as in Farmers Branch. Thus people resolve on forms of action meant — as in Farmers Branch — to redress the oversights of Those In Charge.

Those In Charge ought to listen better than they have been. They are losing — as in Farmers Branch, as in the Congress of the United States — the respect and acquiescence of those whose interests they supposedly advance.

It is one thing to accept, even welcome, the historic human phenomenon of immigration. It is another thing to see disrespect for law, for process, for rational modes of doing things, and not fear that a crisis of legitimacy is fast growing among us.

Congress this year — one reads — may finally do something halfway sensible about illegal immigration. Congress — one knows — has a lot of making up to do for squandered time.

To find out more about William Murchison and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at



0 Comments | Post Comment
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right: comments policy
William Murchison
Feb. `16
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
31 1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 1 2 3 4 5
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month
Authorís Podcast
Lawrence Kudlow
Lawrence KudlowUpdated 13 Feb 2016
Suzanne Fields
Suzanne FieldsUpdated 12 Feb 2016
Patrick Buchanan
Pat BuchananUpdated 12 Feb 2016

19 Aug 2008 Main Street U.S.A.

15 Dec 2009 A Kind Word for King George

16 Mar 2010 Education 'Reform,' From the Top Down