creators home
creators.com lifestyle web

Recently

Farewell Dear Larry: You are the sanest man in America! I look forward to your columns because I ALWAYS agree with your answers. Great work! Thanks for speaking the simple truth about all issues — racial, political, parental, common sense, etc. I often …Read more. Hate Groups Dear Larry: I want to forget for a moment that it is their constitutional right, because I detest the Ku Klux Klan, neo-Nazis and all other groups that preach hate. A long time ago, they came into cities across America without any protest. Now …Read more. Troubles With Raising Teenage Son Dear Larry: I am African-American and a single mother with three children, ages 15, 10 and 8. All of them are boys. I am having a lot of problems with them, especially the eldest. He argues with me about almost everything. He thinks he is the man/…Read more. How To Get Race Relations Back on Track Dear Larry: So many of my friends are upset with the way things are going, especially race relations. They are not saying anything openly, but among themselves there is constant complaining and fear. There is something simmering and brewing that …Read more.
more articles

Ethnically Speaking, November 15

Share Comment

Dear Larry: Two married friends of mine enrolled their daughter in school for kindergarten. The wife is white, and the husband is Hispanic. They had to fill out a mountain of paperwork, and part of the stuff was a section concerning the race of the child. They decided neither white nor Hispanic was accurate, so they checked "other."

The school did not agree with their classification and changed the child's race to "Hispanic." The school said the child has to be listed as Hispanic because her father's genes are dominant.

I have seen some exceptions: I knew a kid back in grade school whose father was Japanese, and his mother was white. He had more of his mother's features, including blond hair. The only features he had from his father were his eyes. He was listed as white.

I know a woman whose father is white and whose mother is Korean. She is listed as Asian instead of white because she has more of her mother's features.

I also have noticed that most of the time, when an interracial couple is black and white, the child always is listed as being black. What is interesting is that lately, black/white children now are being called by that old taboo name "mulatto."

When it comes to people who are biracial, why does society tend to identify what race the person should be? I thought it was up to the individual or the individual's parents to state the individual's identity. — Pat

Dear Pat: You have noted a real flaw in the whole race classification system. I am sorry to say there is no official way in which one should label race. I have seen white people listed as black, Hispanic and Asian.

I have seen blacks labeled as white, Hispanic, Native American and Asian. I have seen Hispanics labeled as every major ethnic group.

The most dramatic listing I ever have seen was a family with five children, each of whom had the same black father and Hispanic mother, and each child was listed in a different ethnic group. The parents thought the whole ethnic classification thing was a joke and would say with great pride they had the most politically correct family in America.

This is a multicultural society in which the races have blended so much that race identification is becoming more of an art than a science. As we blend, the ability to identify will become more and more difficult.

I believe there never could be a perfect system of race classification.

Someone asked me what race he should list on a document. I told him he could put any race he would like to be. Chances are he would be right.

Dear Larry: I am writing in response to "Confused," who wrote about how her black co-worker cursed her out and referred to her as a "naive fool" because she said racism doesn't exist anymore in the U.S. because of the election of Barack Obama.

She is wrong to think racism doesn't exist anymore. However, I agree with your answer that people need something to justify their lack of achievement.

My message to "Confused" is perhaps this "friend" isn't a friend at all. Anyone who treats you that way just for having a differing opinion is not your friend.

Perhaps in your response, Larry, you should have advised her to find better friends. — Alison

Dear Alison: You are right. I wish I had said so.

To find out more about Larry G. Meeks and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

COPYRIGHT 2008 CREATORS SYNDICATE INC.


Comments

8 Comments | Post Comment
For the past twenty years or more, I fill in the blank for race as American and leave it at that.
My "mix" is Scottish English Welch, Swiss German, Irish and Native Indian, Whew!
Comment: #1
Posted by: cindra
Sat Nov 15, 2008 6:14 AM
I had a student whom I listed as white when we developed his special education paperwork - it was the first year for a high school program and many years ago. The next year, he identified himself as Native American and could substantiate this, too. It took a while and a lot of convincing the administration, but we were able to change the race. My feeling was that this young man could identify whatever race he felt was his.
Comment: #2
Posted by: BB
Sat Nov 15, 2008 10:56 PM
Call me a dumb Canadian (we live in the States now), but what is this obsession Americans seem to have about forcing people to declare themselves one "race" or another? The whole notion is repugnant to me. I NEVER fill out that section of any form. Ever. The few times someone has asked me about this, I've told them quite bluntly that I want it left blank. If they write something in anyway, I ask for a new form. It's the same with forms asking about religion or gender. I do not answer this question for anyone.
For many years in Canada, it has been illegal to ask questions (this is in regards to employment in particular) about any aspect of a person's life that could be used in a prejudicial manner. Race, sex and religion are the big ones. It's like asking a lady her age or weight. You just don't do it.
Comment: #3
Posted by: MessyONE
Sun Nov 16, 2008 6:43 AM
Re: MessyONE...I agree with you. It's LONG past time for the US to get rid of the entire system - federal, state, and local - of keeping statistics on race. I'd say that anyone in the entire country whose job it is to collect said information automatically loses that job. Quotas are rolled back, legislation repealed, court rulings abolished. It's the only way we will put America's sordid, racially-stained past (from Wounded Knee to Jim Crow) behind us once and for all. It is absolutely key to getting people to see each other as individuals rather than members of some group. Government needs to lead by example if our leaders are serious about a "color-blind society." There is only one race that counts - human.
Comment: #4
Posted by: Matt
Sun Nov 16, 2008 8:44 PM
Hello:
For all those folks with comments about race. I have spent a life time in law enforcement. I have worked all over the U.S. I have worked with people from every country or race. There is no race that will ever get along. Only people will get along. In the U.S. we spend a great deal of time and money trying to get different race's to get along. It will never happen. Only people will get along and treat each other with respect and kindness. There are a number of civil rights laws on the books. The U.S. Government still will enforce these laws. You can not make someone like someone. Education is the key. Children must be taught to respect and treat others the same way. Good luck hopeing that we will all become friends. It will never happen. Go to any country in the world. They all have the same problems.
Comment: #5
Posted by: Hoss
Wed Nov 19, 2008 1:50 PM
There is no reason to have race on any local , state, federal or private form.This is a nation of the peopple and for the people no exception. Yes if a physical description is required then you might need to say white,black american indian, or whotever but other then tat race should not be on any form
Comment: #6
Posted by: doris
Mon Nov 24, 2008 6:05 AM
If Rwanda can get beyond ethnic labeling after its history of Tutsi/Hutu violence-- and I'm talking about thousands of people getting chopped up with machetes-- so can we. One change that Rwanda made was to abolish any official labeling of people based on ethnicity. So now, the words "Hutu" and "Tutsi" don't appear on anybody's passport, birth certificate, or official government paperwork. Everyone's Rwandan. Since then... surprise... no more machete action. Meanwhile, getting rid of the official government recognition of the label doesn't seem to have taken away anyone's cultural identity as a Hutu or family traditions as a Tutsi. We can learn from this.
Comment: #7
Posted by: R.A.
Thu Jan 6, 2011 9:07 AM
In my opinion there should be no race question ever. The only reason it is there now is that race hustlers such as Jesse and Al make a living - millions of dollars I might add - on race hustling.
Comment: #8
Posted by: Patrick Turner
Sun May 29, 2011 8:53 AM
Already have an account? Log in.
New Account  
Your Name:
Your E-mail:
Your Password:
Confirm Your Password:

Please allow a few minutes for your comment to be posted.

Enter the numbers to the right:  
Creators.com comments policy
More
Larry Meeks
Mar. `11
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
27 28 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2
About the author About the author
Write the author Write the author
Printer friendly format Printer friendly format
Email to friend Email to friend
View by Month